Criminal Court Model Vs. Juvenile Justice System

Words: 560

Pages: 3

Open Document

The criminal court model is a more formal approach than the juvenile justice model. In the criminal court system, the purpose of sentences are to enact punishment proportionate to the offense; tends to limit discretion because determining the sentence by the crime produces fixed sentences. The juvenile justice model is relative to the offender, which can create discrepancies in sentencing, and the model believes in the process of rehabilitation for the defendant who are adolescents’ in this case. The crimes in juvenile court differ from those in criminal court; stemming from a belief that adolescents have a right to be treated differently than adults, due to the caliber of the crime, lack of awareness of the consequence, and development, and legal restrictions as minors.
The sequential justice model combines aspects of both models; the criminal court model occurs up to the sentencing, because the …show more content…
Both sides have compelling arguments, but although I support the offender based consideration, I believe the criminal justice model should be imposed because the principle of government rests on equality before the law, and deeper inconsistencies of this fact are found in the juvenile justice model. In regard of varying sentences for (essentially) the same crime and two separate procedures for adolescents and adults; which can deny all the rights of due process, the juvenile system rests too heavily on opinion rather than fact. The brutal reality is the US legal system cannot possibly account for everyone, in the ideal world both models would produce uniform sentences, and rehabilitation would be successful in all situations. But America is too big and diverse to make judgments solely based on everyone’s personal state, and in some cases this principle eliminates the operation of legal law- to be independent from informal law that is based on the collective consciousness of societies to

Juvenile Justice System Essay

The juvenile justice system is the primary system used to address youth who are under the age of 18, and have committed a crime. The theories and practices of the juvenile justice system have evolved a great deal over the years. The juvenile system consists of five periods from 1646- the present. The first period of juvenile justice is the Puritan Period. This period lasted from 1646- 1824. It was believed that bad children were evil and there was no rehabilitation for them. If parents could not…

Words 552 - Pages 3

Essay Jury and family Group Conferencing

Internationals view on Courts describes public prosecution v. private prosecution. Private prosecution is the oldest and is usually initiated by the victim or victim’s family. Private prosecution is now mostly civil in nature for example slander or libel. In Ohio, cities solicitor either elected or appointed, other counties have a prosecuting attorney elected by the federal government and they also have United States prosecutors designated by regions of United States or appointed by the United States…

Words 736 - Pages 3

Essay about Crim 309 Notes

1/5/15 History of Juvenile Defining the Child Paten Patriae The idea that the state is obligated to care for people (children/ mentally ill) in head of care and protection Antebellum Child Welfare Legitimate vs. illegitimate child Apprenticeship “ The children” in the 1900s: Context: Children seen as malleable; future citizens Child development was in the interest Materialism and the child-savers Materialism Valorized the women’s role as a mother Defined many progressive- era politics Became…

Words 2457 - Pages 10

Together Love And Family In The Shadow Of The Prison Book Report

non system has three traditional agencies of CJ: a police, courts and corrections, and victim service is considered modern. The system speaks to individual agencies, which structure for individual agencies. But, the non- system speaks to an individual you can’t identify, as courts correction they acknowledge that someone made the crime, but they have mental issues. Therefore, the two models of criminal justice came along, with due process and crime control model; the first establish…

Words 850 - Pages 4

Juvenile Deliquents: Forensics Essay

A juvenile in the criminal and civil courts is defined as someone who is under the age of 18. There are more male juvenile offenders than female juvenile offenders, however since 1985 female rates doubles while males rose only 30% (site alternative.org). According to the U.S. Department of Justice (2010), the top juvenile crimes in general are theft, disorderly conduct, drug abuse, liquor law violations, running away, and vandalism. A Juvenile Offender has been subjected to many different classifications…

Words 2779 - Pages 12

Essay On Recidivism

and outpatient clinics in particular—have frequently been ineffective because they focus too much on the juvenile individually, provide services in a setting different from the home environment, and have little accountability for success. MST addresses these issues by providing an intensive treatment that focuses on the multiple factors related to delinquency in various settings or systems (e.g., school, family, peers) in the adolescent’s life. It provides this treatment in the home and community…

Words 8788 - Pages 36

Juvenile Offenders Essay

Stanley JUVENILE OFFENDERS AND THE DEATH PENATLY Juvenile Offenders and the ideas of how to punish them for their crimes has been a national topic of discussion with just about everyone you meet. From the local politicians to the concerned parent who worries about their children. What punishment juveniles should receive has always been a sensitive subject. From state to state, city to city the views and opinions vary and varies on what should be the correct punishment for a juvenile offender…

Words 3223 - Pages 13

Forensic Psychology Review Essay

Forensic Psy Test 1 Review 1. What types of activities do clinical forensic psychologists do? 2. Psychology in the law what kind of activities: A psychologist in court providing expert testimony concerning some issue of relevance to a particular case. EX: the psychologist might testify that, based on his or her understanding of the psychological research, the eyewitness on the stand may have incorrectly identified the defendant from a police lineup. A police officer using his or her knowledge of…

Words 1762 - Pages 8

Essay on Operant Conditioning in the Criminal Ju

Operant Conditioning in the Criminal Justice System Z. M. Keys Psychology of Criminal Behavior CCJS 461 17 October 2014 "The only way to tell whether a given event is reinforcing to a given organism under given conditions is to make a direct test. We observe the frequency of a selected response, then make an event contingent upon it and observe any change in frequency. If there is a change, we classify the event as reinforcing to the organism under the existing conditions." (Skinner…

Words 2665 - Pages 11

Essay about The Fourth Amendmet

warrant has to be written for a specific reason; not just for anything. Warrants have to say exactly what the government officials are looking for and where they need to look. “In 1886, in a case called Boyd vs. United States, the Supreme Court of the United States referred to Entick vs. Carrington as a ''great judgment,'' ''one of the landmarks of English liberty,'' and ''one of the permanent monuments of the British Constitution". This established the Entick decision as a guide to understanding…

Words 2301 - Pages 10