Criminal Jurisdiction in Indian Country Essay

Words: 1343
Pages: 6
Open Document
Criminal Jurisdiction in Indian Country Tribal nations enjoy a unique legal position in the United States attributable to their sovereign status with built in powers of self-government. They also enjoy a special relationship with the federal government. In turn, this status and relationship has consequences for tribes and their members; for the states and their citizens; and the federal government. This paper will explore the significance of tribal sovereignty, the tribal-federal trust relationship, and their impact on criminal jurisdiction in Indian Country. It will also identify the division of criminal jurisdiction between the tribes, the federal government, and the states, which flows from this unique status and relationship. I will …show more content…
Yet, this authority to regulate commerce with the tribes has been transformed into a plenary power over Indian affairs, almost without limits. Obviously, the federal government must operate within the boundaries of the United States Constitution in its dealings with tribal nations. However, while the federal government uses its plenary power and trust responsibility as a shield for tribes and their sovereignty, through its duty and power it also wields a mighty sword. The federal government has a trust responsibility to protect tribes, yet Congress' power has been interpreted to be great enough to unilaterally abolish treaties or certain treaty rights, and to end the government-to-government relationship with any particular tribe. At its most extreme limits, Congress can legislate who is and is not an Indian tribe. Congress also has the power to increase, decrease, or remove entirely from tribal governments their criminal and civil jurisdiction. Congress also has the power to export into Indian Country federal criminal laws due to its plenary power. The relationship between Congress and Indian tribes is complex. Often the duties and powers of Congress, in relation to the tribes, conflict with each other. When such conflicts arise regarding the
Show More

Related Documents: Criminal Jurisdiction in Indian Country Essay

Native American Essay

Crime Trends 2 California’s Population and Racial Makeup California is the most populated state in the country and it is ranked third in its extensive geographic area. In the state of California, according to the United States Census the population is numbered at 37,253,956. California is truthfully one of the most diverse states in the union that is home to many immigrant families from all around the globe. The racial makeup of the population in…

Words 1971 - Pages 8

Concept Of Extradition

another state after successfully escaping the former state, in such circumstances, what should the latter do? What will be the duty of the latter in this regard? Should it try him in its own courts and sentence him accordingly or give him up to the country whose laws he has broken? These were the questions that will come up while dealing with the concept like extradition. And the international law does not give a particular answer to these questions. Some jurists like Vattel, Kent, Grotius believe that…

Words 1406 - Pages 6

Essay On Surrogacy Arrangements

for childless couples, and singles, seeking to fulfill their dream of becoming parents. Yet while more jurisdictions are now regulating the practice of surrogacy this is by no means the rule. Some jurisdictions, such as Malaysia, have no legislation expressly permitting or prohibiting surrogacy arrangements, while others have expressly banned the practice, making (certain aspects of) it a criminal offence. Yet prohibiting surrogacy does not appear to be an effective way to prevent such arrangements…

Words 2068 - Pages 9

How to Take Notes and Write Reports Essay examples

Concealed from view Indian Country Jurisdiction What is Indian Country? 1. 18 USC 1151 2. Within the limits of any Indian reservation under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Government, including patented lands and rights-of-way (18 U.S.C. 1151 (a)) 3. Dependent Indian communities 4. All land allotments, the Indian title to which have not been extinguished, including rights-of-way (18 U.S.C. 1151 (c)) Who is Indian for criminal jurisdiction purposes? 1. Some degree of Indian blood; tribe or federal…

Words 5222 - Pages 21

State Vs Szloh Case Study

police to stay away from the property and cut off all communication with his ex-wife. However, Mr. Szloh returned a third time. This time he was arrested for three separate accounts of menacing by stalking, which is the act committed. There is no criminal case without an act that is declared illegal. Due to his act and intent to cause distress to Mrs. Szloh and her mother, the case led to a trial. The state of Ohio requires the following elements to be proven; (1) pattern of conduct, (2) knowingly…

Words 452 - Pages 2

United States and Cbi Essay

servants was felt. The Delhi Special Police Establishment Act was passed in 1946 to give the organisation a statutory base. Its jurisdiction was extended to cover cases of corruption involving employees of all departments of the Government of India. The role of the SPE was gradually extended and by 1963, it was authorised to investigate offences under 97 Sections of the Indian Penal Code, offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act and 16 other Central Acts. Presently, the CBI Consists of the…

Words 1789 - Pages 8

Birthright Citizenship Definition

born on the territory of the United States automatically become citizens, regardless of their parents’ legal status at the time. In 1868 the Fourteenth Amendment that states “All person born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside” made the birthright citizenship a part of the Constitution. This practice has created many debates whether or not to benefit children with citizenship, of illegal…

Words 1058 - Pages 5

Why Is Death Penalty Wrong

executing an innocent person can never be eliminated. Since 1973, for example, 150 US prisoners sent to death row have later been exonerated. Others have been executed despite serious doubts about their guilt. [The penalty] Does not deter crime. Countries who execute commonly cite the death penalty as a way to deter people from committing crime. This claim has been repeatedly discredited, and there is no evidence that the death penalty is any more effective in reducing crime than imprisonment.” (Amnesty…

Words 1886 - Pages 8

Act 27: Anti Federalists Views On The Judiciary

government, and have direct experience in government Small territory, and basically homogenous population as necessary Did not insist that every citizen exercise legislative power AUGUST 29TH – SEPTEMBER 1ST : The American Revolution French & Indian War (1754-1763) Wars were very expensive Stamp Act (British were poor after war, how they were going to raise money) America “owes” British money for securing their land Colonists thought Stamp Act was very bad John Marshall famous quote “the…

Words 1106 - Pages 5

Queen Victoria Research Paper

influence Britain, but many other countries including India, Australia, Canada, Africa, and many more. She was not like any other ordinary queen. She was responsible for multiple governments and was helpful with many leaders and their decisions for their countries. Not only was she a queen, but a legacy. She ruled over a quarter of the planet and was provided with over 400 million subjects under her power. Queen Victoria revolutionized the future for many countries, politically and technologically…

Words 1101 - Pages 5