Hiroshima; Right or Wrong? Essay examples

Words: 993
Pages: 4
Open Document
1) Describe the main arguments, reasons, and evidence that support the perspective of Historian A.

-Historian A had a lot of reasonable and strong perspectives on the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima. She views the United States was not justified in dropping the bomb. A huge argument begins with the U.S. knowing that Japan was trying to surrender. This is a great example of unnecessarily kicking someone when they are already down. The Japanese wanted peace and tried to surrender, the only condition was that they could keep their emperor. The U.S. declined and said they had to have an “unconditional surrender.” After the bombing, the U.S. let Japan keep their emperor anyway. The U.S. could have saved so many lives if they had …show more content…
If the bomb had not been used and the U.S. had not insisted on unconditional surrender, would only have led to more war and loss of lives. Using the bomb ended sooner and although many lives were lost, it saved many lives over time.

3) Imagine that you were in the position of the U.S. president at the time, Henry Truman. Explain what action you would have taken with respect to the atomic bombs and explain the rationale for your decision.
-This is an extremely hard position to put myself in and when measuring out all the facts and details, it takes a certain kind of person to drop a bomb and kill all those people. Putting myself in Truman’s shoes, I do not think I would have dropped the bomb. Japan was very argumentative with the unconditional surrender however there could have been just as efficient, less dramatic ways to handle the situation instead of the bombing. I wouldn’t have even threatened the bomb because I would not have gone through with it. Henry threated it, so I’m sure his obligation to keep his word after Japan chose to ignore it was a huge influence. Japan had started war with us and we attacked them back. The second bombing so shortly after the first was inhumane, especially dropping it on a city. If the second bombing was the absolute final decision, perhaps more warning to Japan until they agreed to surrender unconditionally even if they chose to ignore the first
Show More

Related Documents: Hiroshima; Right or Wrong? Essay examples

The Pros And Cons Of Atomic Bombing

One of the many bombings from World War II that comes into question is the U.S.A.’s use of nuclear bombing one the Japanese islands of Nagasaki and Hiroshima. While the bombing did shorten the war and saved lives from both sides, the results…

Words 978 - Pages 4

Hiroshima Essay

Argument: Who Agrees? & Who Doesn’t? John Hersey the author of Hiroshima, addresses a very sentimental topic from a different perspective; that of the Japanese. He wrote this originally as an article for one of the most read newspapers at that time, The New Yorker, in 1946. His article gained popularity quite fast because people were interested to know the other side of the story. Soon he made it into a book that is still read by many. Hiroshima gives the reader an understanding of the suffering that Japanese…

Words 841 - Pages 4

The Pros And Cons Of Atomic Bombs On Hiroshima

President Truman had to make a very controversial call, it was to drop two atomic bombs on Hiroshima. Many people think he made a rash and harsh decision, but when you look at the facts that is all wrong. President Truman made a calm and calculated decision by dropping those bombs, he made a definitive statement to not only Japan but too the world, he saved millions of lives in the process, he chose the better of two bad options. President Truman didn’t decide to bomb these cities easily. He had…

Words 563 - Pages 3

World War 2 Research Paper

back on potentially killing someone who is killing people every day? If we have to kill some civilians to take care of someone that will continue to kill the longer we allow him to why not just end it? Yes we will kill people who have done nothing wrong but, if we destroy the source of the problem while we’re at it is it not worth it? Over time the hours and days we could of wasted, they may have more than likely killed many more than we might have. Therefore I don’t see why we shouldn’t just pull…

Words 645 - Pages 3

Essay on Hiroshima: Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and Atom Bomb

drastic and unnecessary, so, did President Truman make the right choice? And was it necessary to use this weapon? These are questions that most historians to this date are still trying to figure out. The war between Japan, and the U.S.A, was extremely deadly, it carried on for nearly three and a half years, until President Truman gave out the orders to unleash the atomic bomb onto Hiroshima, The blast of the atom bomb did not only effect Hiroshima but anywhere from 19.6 square miles was effected. Three…

Words 817 - Pages 4

Informative Essay: Dropping The First Atomic Bomb

with training exercises. We have to learn every part of the B-29, inside and out, and we have a weekly test about operations and the actions to be carried out during emergencies. My crew and I are taught to drop the bomb in the ocean if anything goes wrong in flight. Even the smallest problem could cause the bomb to end up at the bottom of the…

Words 1494 - Pages 6

Albert Einstein's Atomic Bomb And The Civil Right Movement

from a learning disability, dealing with an atomic bomb, and the civil right movement. Growing up with a learning disability is really hard but some people have adapted to them better than others like Albert Einstein. He may have been dyslexic, schizophrenic, and Autistic but he never let that hold him back. He came up with E=mc^2 and The Theory of Relativity, and helped the world in many ways. Some say her never had anything wrong with him but others believe he did. When he was growing up they didn’t…

Words 486 - Pages 2

Classical Utilitarianism

Refined Emphasizes the importance of quality over quantity in regards to pleasure. The only ones fit to judge if a particular pleasure is worth a particular pain are the experienced. William Ross Intuitionism Posits that we inherently know right from wrong, but this knowledge is not in every case self-evident. There are certain duties that we naturally assume and those are: fidelity, reparation, gratitude, justice, beneficence, self-improvement, and non-maleficence. Non-maleficence is more important…

Words 637 - Pages 3

Oppenheimer's Argument In Favor Of The Atomic Bomb

comprehend the damages my work brought to America. In my defense, I believed that what I was creating at the time was something to protect our nation and keep American pride strong and faithful. Little did I know what this abomination could do when in the wrong hands. It has come to my attention that 21st century America has outside threats that will use my creation against them. North…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Essay on Ethics: Ethics and James Fieser

principles that influence a person or group’s behaviour. The principles illustrate to society the standards of what is right and wrong, good and bad. Furthermore, these principles directly influence how people choose to carry out their lives along with the choices and decisions that they make. With that said there are many diverse opinions in relation to what is morally right and wrong; the main factor that differentiates people’s opinions are differences in cultures and beliefs. Upon investigating the…

Words 1091 - Pages 5