Is Brutus A Tragic Hero

Words: 1245
Pages: 5
Open Document
“Et tu Brute?” are some of Caesar’s solemn final words as he realizes his most loyal, trustworthy friend has malignantly plotted his demise and deceived him. To betray a friend’s trust is one of the most dishonorable and despicable things a man can do and many view Brutus’ plot against Caesar in such a way. It seems irrational for one to illustrate this sequence of events in any other way gay than Caesars’ tragedy and a happy resolution with the conspirators’ demise at the hands of the Second Triumvirate. However, even though the play bears his name, Julius Caesar is not the tragic hero. In the play Julius Caesar, Shakespeare portrays Brutus a heroic figure due to his noble motives and his honorable patriotism. Similarly, the playwright depicts …show more content…
After brutally striking down his closest friend, Brutus delivers a logical, honorable speech to the mob to show them why he committed the heinous crime and to convince them to support his cause. Brutus honestly tells the people that it is “not that [he] loved Caesar less, but that [he] loved Rome more” that ultimately drove him to assassinate Caesar (3.2.24). In saying this, Brutus selflessly declares that his love for Rome trumps all other personal friendships. The fact that he would sacrifice someone he loved and undergo overwhelming guilt and sorrow for a noble and patriotic cause is one of the most heroic things one could do for his country. Furthermore, when Brutus realizes that Cassius’ motives were out of envy of Caesar’s power and greed, he is disgusted and the audience witnesses his greatness as he confronts his counterpart’s betrayal of values. After questioning if “great Julius bled for justice’ sake”, Brutus honorably declares that he would rather “be a dog and bay at the moon that such a Roman” who supports robbers and accepts bribes to kill Caesar (4.3.20-25). Although this dispute is shortly resolved, Shakespeare illustrates Brutus’ patriotic and honorable values that make him great. Most importantly, even Brutus’ enemies …show more content…
While contemplating whether to kill Caesar, Brutus receives a letter supposedly from the people of Rome that encourage “speak, strike, and redress” against his best friend. He responds to these fake letters in a monolog saying that if “a redress [from tyranny] will follow” violence, Rome will receive his “full petition” and devotion to the cause (2.1.49-62). Cassius knows that Brutus will always do the honorable and just thing for his country and he takes advantage of this flaw for his own motives. In this case, Brutus’ honor blinds him as he doesn’t recognize Cassius’ trickery and the repercussions of his naïve decision to join the conspirators. Similarly, after sparing Antony’s life because their “course will seem too bloody”, Brutus is again tricked into letting deliver a funeral oration (2.1.175). He adamantly declares that “Caesar shall have all true rites and ceremonies”, including a speech from Antony that he believes will “advantage more than do [the conspirators] wrong” (3.1.266). As Cassius did, shrewd Antony knows honorable Brutus will let him speak at Caesar’s funeral and is so trusting and naïve that he could never expect such a cunning, manipulative oration. Even though his honor makes him a great man, the fact that it prevents him from making the necessary ignoble choices needed to
Show More

Related Documents: Is Brutus A Tragic Hero

Brutus: A Tragic Hero

A tragic hero is, by definition, one who is noble and honorable, has a great character flaw, experiences a downfall and great suffering, and goes through much internal conflict. In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, the tragic hero is obviously Brutus. Brutus is a well-respected and honorable praetor in the government of Rome, as well as one of Caesar’s closest friends, and this therein is his struggle. To kill Caesar would be to betray him, but Cassius convinces him that to not kill him would lead to…

Words 369 - Pages 2

How Is Brutus A Tragic Hero

students alike on who the true tragic hero is. After all, a true tragic hero typically show signs of catharsis; that is, evoking the audience towards feelings of pity and fear, then relieving the audience from pent up emotions. Both Brutus and Julius Caesar can be the tragic hero; however, Brutus can be accounted as the true tragic hero for more than just personal opinions. Brutus is unfailingly presented as a noble, upright, virtuous man who is, however, led into the tragic act of betraying a friend…

Words 686 - Pages 3

How Is Brutus A Tragic Hero

Caesar: The Tragic Hero The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, a play written by William Shakespeare, shows the conspiracy of the killing of Julius Caesar. The play has five acts in it, each with a few different scenes. Marcus Brutus is one of the main characters in the play and has the main focal point on him throughout. He is one of the conspirators that killed Caesar and was the biggest surprise to Caesar, for he was one of his closest allies. The play really reveals that Brutus was the tragic hero of it…

Words 1618 - Pages 7

Marcus Brutus: The Tragic Hero

Julius Caesar, written by William Shakespeare, Marcus Brutus is the Tragic Hero because he contributes to his own destruction by tragic flaw, he suffers more than deserved, and has many moments of chance. The first piece of evidence to support the fact that Brutus is the tragic hero is that his tragic flaw, poor judgment, contributes to his own destruction. Cassius complements Brutus until he “will consider, what [he] has to say”. This is Brutus’ first mistake: buying into Cassius’ lies, joining the…

Words 559 - Pages 3

How Is Brutus A Tragic Hero

A Tragic Hero’s Pride Every story has a tragic hero, sometimes in stories or novels it’s more obvious who that hero is. In the beginning of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Brutus is loved and described as a noble person by everyone in Rome that knows him, but he lets this go to his head. He ends up judging people based on his ideals on what’s moral and right, causing him to make rash decisions that lead to his ultimate demise. In the end, Brutus becomes a tragic hero who lets his pride lead…

Words 370 - Pages 2

Julius Caesar Essay: Brutus As A Tragic Hero

The concept of a tragic hero was first presented by Aristotle in ancient Greece who defined it as a character who evokes feelings of pity among the audience. A tragic hero always has a flaw or an error in judgement that causes his downfall, and is typically an honorable man favored by the people. Eventually the Aristotelian tragic hero must courageously accept their tragic death, having fallen from great heights and having made an irreversible mistake. In William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius…

Words 577 - Pages 3

Examples Of Julius Caesar Tragic Hero

The Tragic Hero The tragedy of Julius Caesar, as people will say, drew many people to its attention. The author of this play includes William Shakespeare. The plot begins with many people gathering around and celebrating the return of Casar from war in which he just won. The whole town celebrates with games in which Julius Caesar joins in on. A tragic hero is someone who makes a wrong decision in which leads to their own destruction. Marcus Brutus was the tragic hero in this play because he…

Words 542 - Pages 3

Essay Tragic Hero

4 March 2015 Julius Caesar Essay Brutus Vs Antony Almost in all of Shakespeare's plays a tragic hero is always identified; a heroic figure that demonstrates a character flaw that leads to their death. In William Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, there have been many disputes about who was the real tragic hero. Over half the people agree that Marcus Brutus was the true tragic hero. However, others have argued and identified Julius Caesar as the real tragic hero. After analyzing these two great characters…

Words 715 - Pages 3

Julius Caesar Research Paper

Who is the Tragic Hero? Which character had the most tragic death? Who was also the biggest hero in Julius Caesar, Brutus or Caesar? There are many differences between whether either Brutus or Caesar could have been the tragic hero. But why was one a more tragic hero? There are three reasons why one character is a more tragic hero. The first, was that Brutus was more prideful and cared about the people more than Caesar. Second, the character that is the tragic hero was killed in an honorable way…

Words 497 - Pages 2

Julius Caesar essay

Brutus, the Tragic Hero Aristotle’s description of a tragic hero includes many things. It is someone who is noble according to birth. It is a man whose audience gets attached emotionally to the character and thus feels fear or triumph along with the character’s emotions. It is someone who, although noble and chivalrous, has tragic flaws that lead to his downfall. In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare, Brutus is the tragic yet noble hero. First of all, Brutus is the tragic hero…

Words 544 - Pages 3