Limitation Of Psychodynamic Therapy

Words: 931
Pages: 4
Open Document
Freud's views on therapy continue to influence therapeutic practice in today's age. Many of his basic concepts are still part of the foundation on which other theorists build and develop their ideas. Some major concepts of the psychoanalytic theory include the personality, the dynamics of the unconscious and its influence on behavior, the role of anxiety, and the development of personality at various stages of the life cycle. Freud's psychoanalytic therapy is still used today, even with the draw backs and limitations.
In the Freudian psychoanalytical view, the personality consists of three systems: the id, the ego, and the superego. The id is all the untamed drives or impulses that might be likened to the biological component. The ego attempts …show more content…
A major limitation of traditional psychoanalytic therapy is the relatively long time commitment required to accomplish analytic goals. The emergence of brief, time-limited psychodynamic therapy is a partial response to the criticism of lengthy therapy. A potential limitation of this approach is the anonymous role assumed by some therapists. This stance can be justified on some theoretical grounds, but in therapy situations, other than classical psychoanalysis, this stance is restrictive. From a feminist perspective, there are distinct limitations to a number of Freudian concepts. Object-Relations approach has been criticized for its emphasis on the role of mother-child relations in determining later interpersonal functioning. This approach gives greater responsibility to mothers. While mothers are to blame for inadequate parenting, fathers are absent from the hypothesis about patterns of early …show more content…
For example, April broke up with Adam, and three months later went on a date with Mark. While at the restaurant, April accidentally called Mark by Adam’s name. While this could have just been a simple accident, psychoanalytic theory says that there is a deeper reason for April’s slip. For example, she still has feelings for Adam and her mind is on him, and therefore she called her new date by her old boyfriend’s name. Putting Freud's techniques into practice, therapists would say that April is experiencing physical symptoms of a deeply repressed conflict, and projecting them onto Mark. Therapists would have April lie on a couch to relax, and they would sit behind her taking notes while she told them about her dreams and memories about
Show More

Related Documents: Limitation Of Psychodynamic Therapy

Case Study Essay - Critical Analysis of Cbt and Psychodynamic Appoaches

presenting issues. Here a case study of Jane is used to argue /evaluate and assess how both a psychodynamic counselor and cognitive behavioral therapist (CBT) would view the case study of Jane from their perspectives. Consideration will be given from both a psychodynamic approach and CBT approach of how a therapist might work with Jane. The main similarities and differences of both the psychodynamic and CBT approaches will be analyzed. This will lead into an evaluation of which is the most appropriate…

Words 2474 - Pages 10

Definition Of Psychopathology

abnormality Example of the definition Failure to function adequately Deviation from ideal mental health Deviation from social norms (3 marks) 1 (b) Select two of the definitions given in the table and explain one limitation of each definition. ....................................................................................................................................... ...................................................................................…

Words 864 - Pages 4

Essay on Compare and Contrast Person Centred with Psychodynamic

Approach the core conditions are necessary for the therapeutic relationship to develop. In the two other approaches they were sufficient for the relationship to develop. With humanistic approach all of the core conditions are present, but with psychodynamic non judgemental attitude are poignant to the relationship, and the counsellor will not take side in the conflict, however congruence and empathy is present, but not widely used by the counsellor. With cognitive behaviour again all three core…

Words 2466 - Pages 10

Schizophrenia: Schizophrenia and Social Cognition Essay

antipsychotic medications and psychosocial therapies, however it is incurable. This disorder generally onsets during early adulthood and tends to be chronic. Through the course of many decades, research on possible causes, risk factors and potential strategies of prevention, have led researchers to have multiple perspectives on the disorder. This review of studies will discuss the symptoms, etiology and treatment of schizophrenia from a cognitive and psychodynamic perspective of the disorder. Symptoms…

Words 3029 - Pages 13

Essay on Psychology and Behaviour Psychodynamic Approach

heads towards anything that touches their cheek. Strengths: -Scientific and experimental methods in the investigations. - Strong argument for the nature-nurture debate. - Many useful applications- drugs that alleviate disorders. Limitations: -Reductionist. It explains the behaviour in terms of the actions of nerves or chemicals. -The approach is over-simplistic. Don’t appreciate environmental factors on our behaviour. - Ethical issues- genetic mapping.…

Words 2005 - Pages 9

Definition Of Abnormality

differences – Psychopathology Definitions of Abnormality- 1. DEVIATION FROM SOCIAL NORMS: Deviation refers to dominant behaviour – ‘Behaviour which is considered undesirable by the majority’ – For example; Talking to yourself in public LIMITATIONS: The definition is susceptible to abuse: Diagnosing someone with a mental illness could just be a way to exclude non conformists from society For example, homosexuality was considered a ‘mental disorder’ in the USA until 1970s also anyone who…

Words 2457 - Pages 10

CBT Model

In terms of limitations; the results for the self-reported social anxiety measure were less sensitive and researchers are unclear why they presented a trend in favour of CT in the in the intent to treat analysis. There were also issues in terms of including clients with secondary comorbid conditions such as depression. There was also the possibility of therapists using interventions that should have only been specific to one treatment. In relation to IPT, further developments such as addressing empirically…

Words 611 - Pages 3

Essay about Discuss the Biological Approach in Psychology

Discuss the biological approach in psychology. Refer to at least one other approach in your answer. (12 marks) The biological approach focuses on both the physiological and evolutionary aspects which explain human behaviour. The causal level of analysis incorporates physiological explanations, such as the effect of nerves and hormones on behaviour. According to biological psychologists, behaviour is controlled by the nervous system, which consists of the central nervous system (the brain and the…

Words 1789 - Pages 8

Theory Outline Essay

Theory Outline Tiffany Woods PCN-500 August 8, 2012 Theory Outline 1. Theory: Psychoanalytical Theory a. Key Concepts i. There is a focus on unconscious psychodynamics. ii. Individuals pay attention to repressed information. iii. In therapy, the therapist and client work to build the ego to moderate ID and superego. iv. The client works on establishing transference. He/she will tell the counselor what has caused the difficulties and the therapist…

Words 1983 - Pages 8

Essay on Psychology: Frontal Lobe and mentally Healthy Person

Abnormality 1: Definitions of Mental Illness Deviation from Social Norms Social norms are the unwritten rules of behaviour for a situation. If people break social norms, their Behaviour is said to be deviant. This in turn could be a symptom of a mental illness. For example, schizophrenics often show inappropriate levels of emotion i.e. laughing at a death. Y: We expect people to behave in a certain way. If they do not, this helps us to help them seek medical treatment. X: Cultural…

Words 6017 - Pages 25