Essay about Scarlet letter analysis

Submitted By mollygrace10
Words: 786
Pages: 4
Open Document
Scarlet Letter Final
Public shaming has been used throughout history; today we are faced with the question, “should we or shouldn’t we.” Public shaming has become a controversial topic; neither the pros nor the cons outweigh each other. People must take it upon ourselves to make this important decision. When deciding we should ask ourselves does the punishment fit the crime, and is it the only other possible punishment? The Scarlet Letter
, by Nathaniel Hawthorne, is an early example of public shaming. The main character, Hester Pryne, was shamed for adultery, she had to wear a red “A” on her chest so the people could see the horrible sin she had committed. At first her punishment worked well and it forced Hester and her daughter away from the town and into the woods where she could be more secluded. Yet as time slowly passed the people in the town began to forget the significance of the “A.” Towards the end of the novel, Hester was no longer the talk of the town and she didn’t need to hide anymore, she no longer felt ashamed.
Hawthorne does a great job telling Hester’s story and explaining all that
Hester and her daughter went through. He shows us examples of the guilt and the exclusion that Hester felt after she had been shamed in front of the whole town. Our society has changed so much since Hester Prynne’s time. Today guilt no longer bothers us; things that were considered sinful in Hester’s time are now normal. It doesn’t matter if we are told it’s the wrong thing to do, if other people can do it then

we can too. What is it that makes us believe that the same types of demeaning punishments will work today. The crimes that are committed are now much larger and more dangerous so would a sign or one shaming session truly work?
In the article entitled “The Two Faces of Shame” by The Association for
Psychological Science, an author discusses public shaming and criminals. A study was conducted with criminals that had been found guilty, some received shame as a punishment and others didn’t. June Tangney, a George Mason University clinical psychologist and the scientist behind the experiment. wanted to determine what the better punishment was: self-guilt or shame. Tangney discovered that when some people are found guilty in a court of law, they begin to feel remorse and regret for the crime they committed. Conversely when certain people are shamed as a punishment they begin to feel worthless, diminished and bitter about the crime they had committed. This led Tangney to believe that shame would not work well as an alternative to jail time. At the end of Tangney’s research she reported,” Shame did indeed cause former inmates to blame others for their misfortune, which in turn kept them from learning from their mistakes- and led to repeat crimes”.
As a society looking into public shaming we need to view all of the effects of
Public Shaming. In a way, we need to put ourselves in the criminals shoes to understand the full effect
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Scarlet letter analysis

Scarlet Letter Analysis Essay

in Salem, Massachusetts in 1804. After the death of his father due to the Yellow Fever epidemic, he was raised with his two sisters by a single mother. As a writer, Hawthorne produced many pieces including House of Seven Gables. However, The Scarlet Letter, written near the end of his career, is thought to be his Magnum Opus. In relation to the novel, Hawthorne not only lived in the same general area as his characters, but also under many of the same circumstances. His upbringing by a single…

Words 1326 - Pages 6

Scarlet Letter Rhetorical Analysis

The Scarlet Letter Rhetorical Analysis Hawthorne’s reverential admiration toward Hester Prynne, and from it, his sickly and feeble, yet feministic view on women in general, are elucidated through his irate yet carefully judicious tone toward Puritan society, as well as through anaphora and juxtaposing connotations. Through juxtaposing connotations, Hawthorne conveys his admiration toward Hester, and from it, develops his view on women in general. While wearing the scarlet letter “A” for a few years…

Words 776 - Pages 4

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Scarlet Letter

Hester finds peace in the forest after her encounters with the townspeople. Hawthorne’s heavy use of symbolism and comparisons were also prominent throughout the novel. He often uses Pearl to allude back to the scarlet letter and to Hester’s sin. Also, Hawthorne develops the symbolism of the letter A as the story goes on and as Hester changes. He creates a sort of detached or removed tone by not taking any sides in the…

Words 121 - Pages 1

The Scarlet Letter Analysis Essay

History Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter is a perfect example of cruel, harsh, and unreasonable punishment for the breaking of one law based off of religious background in government. Hester, the main character, is punished for her crime of adultery and it’s discovered that religion in this colonial time highly influenced resident behavior, punishment, and daily life. Our story’s protagonist, Hester Prynne, gives the book its title by being the wearer scarlet letter, a small piece of fabric in…

Words 1145 - Pages 5

The Scarlet Letter Rhetorical Analysis

lay the embroidered letter glittering like lost jewels." -All three images showcase the importance of the scarlet letter and nature as well as a tone of…

Words 450 - Pages 2

Scarlet Letter Coverdale Analysis

chapters work to dismiss the hope that this experiment will last, especially as Coverdale notes, “Whether he meant to insinuate that our moral illumination would have as brief a term, I cannot say” (Hawthorne 12). Although it makes sense for each character to come into Blithedale with their own ideas about how to make a better society, they begin to put their own desires ahead of the community. By introducing Mr. Coverdale and the Veiled Lady within the first few opening lines, a sense of illusion…

Words 1230 - Pages 5

Scarlet Letters Literary Analysis

Kay, Sarah. “Adultery and Killing in Le Mort le Roi Artu.” Scarlet Letters: Fictions of Adultery from Antiquity to the 1990s. Ed. Nicholas White and Naomi Segal. MacMillan Press Ltd., 1997. 34-44. Rpt. In Epics for Students. Ed. Elizabeth Bellalouna. Vol. 2. Detroit: Gale Group, 2001. Literature Resource Center. Web. In medieval times adultery was wrongful because it was an “offense against property” and the laws of inheritance. However, in Le Mort d’Arthur it is considered wrong because…

Words 632 - Pages 3

Scarlet Letter Close Analysis Outline Essay

Jeuel Bayawa Scarlet Letter Close Analysis Outline Ideas Evil can seep into even the most purest of people Sin consumes the lives of people and unless it is confessed, there will never be any peace Evil rots purity because it causes great suffering Evil can be defeated with acceptance and confession of the truth Acceptance and confession of the truth can lead a person to become better Intro: Nathaniel Hawthorne explores the theme of sin and the nature of evil in The Scarlet Letter. In this novel…

Words 1038 - Pages 5

Scarlet Letter Rhetorical Analysis Essay

one that would never be redeemed, thus shaming her with the scarlet letter. It represented the death of her purity. However, this passage shows how Hester is reborn within Pearl, for Pearl is Hester’s pride and happiness, regarding the fact…

Words 456 - Pages 2

Rhetorical Analysis Essay On The Scarlet Letter

Jackson Young Mr. Limon AP Language and Composition 5 October 2016 The Affair of the Affair In his essay “On the Scarlet Letter”, D. H. Lawrence ridicules Nathaniel Hawthorne’s protagonist Hester Prynne. He views Hester as an abomination who seduced society to maneuver her way out of punishment of an unforgivable sin. In order to achieve his purpose of mocking Hester Prynne, Lawrence uses derogatory diction, structured syntax, and biblical allusions. D. H. Lawrence incorporates…

Words 666 - Pages 3