What is wrong with adultery Essay

Words: 1699
Pages: 7
Open Document
Evaluating Adultery Bonnie Steinbock in her essay “What’s Wrong with Adultery?” starts by quoting the data from studies to show that the number of women who have committed adultery has significantly increased. Despite this increase in female adultery, it is in some degree due to the attitudes changing toward sex and sexuality, but Steinbock thinks that people should use rational justification to evaluate the disapproval of adultery. Then in the rest of the parts of Steinbock’s essay, she is generally arguing against adultery based on the plausible claim that our views toward adultery are varied, and these views are bound to be connected to important conventions about marriage, fidelity, romantic love ( Romeo and Juliet’s case ), the …show more content…
Then the lack of concern and the desire to cause pain will lead to a lack of love. The fallacy of slippery slope is clearly presented here. Although sexual infidelity may to some degree to be a sign of the lack of love, there is no good reason to think that committing sexual infidelity will actually and finally result in the lack of love. For instance, a married female sex worker may still love her spouse. She sells sex which is mainly due to a financial issue. She makes money by selling sex to support her family and her spouse. In such a case, can we say that sexual infidelity means a lack of love toward one’s spouse? Definitely, the answer is no. Thus, slippery slope here weakens Steinbock’s argument considerably. Furthermore, in “Open Marriage” and “Fidelity as An Ideal” sectors, Steinbock defends the position of rejecting adultery and thinks open marriage is moral by stating that sex which involves physical and psychological exposure shows intimacy and creates trust between a couple. In such a way, sex should be reserved for couples in love and “true love” is based on Romeo and Juliet’s model of love. The author commits selective attention here. She looks at sexual fidelity as the ideal in relationship only through an emotional and psychological way but ignores nonexistent emotional and psychological aspects. This seriously limits the application of her argument. Overall, based on Steinbock’s
Show More

Related Documents: What is wrong with adultery Essay

Examine the Way in Which One Religion Uses Scripture as a Basis for Its Teachings on Sexual Behaviour Essay

applied to everyone, everywhere at all times. The purpose of the sexual organs and sexual activity was procreation, and any other use of sex was intrinsically wrong. Sex was to take within the bounds of marriage and must be open to the possibility of procreation. Aquinas argued that sexual acts can be morally wrong in 2 ways. Sex is wrong when the act of its nature is incompatible with the purpose of procreation Acts in which the natural style of intercourse is not observed (foreplay) acts with…

Words 1499 - Pages 6

Philosophy On Sexual Morality Essay

regarding sexual morality. Throughout this literature I will address, establish, and compare the views of each philosopher to that of the conservative position, explain what moral theories they use to derive their conclusions, and attempt to tackle with the best of my ability the scenario regarding what Mappes would say about adultery(the focus of Halwani) using the same beliefs and guidelines he outlines in the class readings. In order to understand the contents of this piece of literature it is necessary…

Words 1152 - Pages 5

Why Is Adultery Important In The 18th Century

The only thing worse than the guilt was the fear of getting caught.”― Elin Hilderbrand. Committing adultery was the worst thing you could do in the 1600’s. You would get put to death or even worst, live with the harassment and guilt and public shame from others. Modern America is similar to these standards, where we still live up to the puritan past. And being different means there is something wrong with you, and you should be punished and suffer with the public humiliation. Modern day society is…

Words 499 - Pages 2

Why Dante Damned Francesca Da Rimini Analysis

her. She judges her by use of philosophy and literature which has no space for adultery and lustful sins. Dante criticizes her in a way that she views hell as the best place. However, all she did to get this criticism was falling in love with her brother in law. She was only tricked to adultery after she was tricked into marriage. Nevertheless, she was murdered by her husband before she got any chance to repent for what she had done. The piece concentrates on judgments of Dante, who was always against…

Words 1585 - Pages 7

Canterburry tales essay

Kadar College English III 27 October 2014 There are many ethics, moral views, and religious views today that many people live by today. Ethics are moral principles that govern a person’s behavior. Ethics is being able to determine between what is right and wrong, good and bad. Ethics are guideline that we follow according to a social system. While morals are also principals that control a person’s behavior, morals are set at a personal standard not socially. Both Morals and ethics have been changing…

Words 1038 - Pages 5

The Crucible John Proctor Tragic Hero Essay

up committing adultery, one of the Ten Commandments we should not do, with a younger girl that was supposed to be his servant. John’s wife, Elizabeth ends up finding up and it forever hurts their marriage but, even with his mistake, his wife still understood he was a good man and not everyone could be perfect. As we proceed through the first 2 Acts, we get a glimpse into the life of an honorable, hard-working man, who is straight forward and refuses to do what he knows is wrong. What he thinks is…

Words 537 - Pages 3

Compare And Contrast Hester And Dimmesdale

Nathanial Hawthorne writes about the story of adultery committed in a puritan community; Hester and Dimmesdale are two important characters that suffer from the sin that try not to tell the truth about the past. When they are suffering some people may say that Dimmesdale suffers more than Hester; which, in fact, is true, accounting all the evidence. Dimmesdale being a minister while Hester being a mother battle between who has suffered the most about adultery. Dimmesdale being a minister of the church…

Words 812 - Pages 4

Jurisprudence Essay

are as followed; the Qur’an, Hadith/Sunna, Ijma (consensus) and Qiyas (analogical reasoning). Practices such as adultery, sexual harassment and homosexuality can be identified as halal (permissible) and haraam (forbidden) by using Islamic jurisprudence; providing Islamic individuals with an idea of what is deemed ethical, or morally right, and what is not. Premarital sex and adultery is classified as unlawful sexual intercourse (zina) in Islamic sexual ethics. Although it is acknowledged that…

Words 643 - Pages 3

Puritanism In The Crucible

purify the church or make it a lot holier than it already was. The characters in The Crucible are affected by Puritanism in a big way. Everything they do has to do with their beliefs of Puritanism, for example, the way they dress, their punishments, what they believe in, etc. The characters in The Scarlet Letter are affected by Puritanism, but not as greatly as in The Crucible. The Scarlet Letter has to do with Puritanism, for example, in the way that they look at their ministers and reverends, the…

Words 622 - Pages 3

Tiger Woods Essay

the masses. According, to the Judeo-Christian values that our country was founded on (Cherry, 2007) adultery is believed to be morally unacceptable and thus makes the basis of the utilitarian approach to this discussion. The utilitarian theory is based on the greatest good for the greatest amount of people. This theory may hold true when speaking of adultery. I agree that adultery is wrong but do Tiger’s personal indiscretions warrant the abandonment of his endorsers. Was Tiger hired on the…

Words 817 - Pages 4