After the Mayflower Essay

Words: 925
Pages: 4

Paper 1
Part 1: At the start of the film After the Mayflower: We Shall Remain, the English and the Native Americans celebrated the first Thanksgiving together in 1621. Both groups of people seemed trusting of each other and showed personal respect. At this time the Wampanoag Indians had the power and chose to use it to form a treaty with the weak English Pilgrims. The two groups shared everything and traded their assets with each other. As the film continued there was an obvious change in power to the English with more and more Puritan immigrants from Europe arriving. By the end of the movie the English decided to use their power to control all lands instead of keeping the treaty with the native people. The English “thanksgiving” at
…show more content…
Just like the Wampanoag Indians, the Pueblos considered their land to be their homeland, especially not a commodity. After the arrival of the Spaniards, the Pueblos saw Catholicism as another religion that could share ideas and that could be learned from. This initial encounter with Catholicism could be seen as a pluralist approach to religion. The Spaniards saw this pluralist standpoint as an overall acceptance of Catholicism from the Pueblo people. In the short film God in America the Spaniards take an exclusivist approach by believing their path is the only true path to salvation. The Spaniards began to destroy everything displaying alternative beliefs; even the Pueblo religious leaders were imprisoned. These imprisonments and beatings eventually lead the Pueblos to their breaking point and Pope declared war against the Spaniards. After 10 days of war and more than half of the Catholic priests being murdered by the Pueblos, the Spaniards fled New Mexico. “The Catholic Empire had faltered. European religion would not survive unchanged in the new world” (God in America). The Puebloan Revolt against the Spanish ended in victory and the protection of their heathen beliefs. With distinction from King Phillip’s War in Massachusetts, “It was over. They tyrants with the sword had been driven from the lands of the Pueblo people. The first American Revolution had succeeded (Sando 41). This greatly differed from the ending of King Philip’s War where the