Essay on Assess The Sociological Explanations Of Suicide

Submitted By iffatunisas
Words: 1249
Pages: 5
Open Document
Assess the sociological explanations of suicide (21 marks)
Introduction
Durkheim takes a positivist approach to study suicide through quantitative data
Found- suicide rate for given society remain constant, different societies has different rates, rates varied between social groups
E.g. married people with children has lower rate than single
Concluded, patterns were evidence that suicide could not be result of motives of individuals
Durkheim explained suicide rate as a result of social facts or forces which act upon individuals.
Paragraph 1:
Identified ‘4 different types of suicide’
In which 2 social facts determine rate of suicide
Social integration- individual experiences a sense of belonging to a group
Moral regulation- individuals actions and desires are kept in check by norms and values
Suicide = too much or too little social integration + moral regulation
First type of suicide= Egoistic- too little social integration
Lack of social ties – most common type of suicide in modern society
Explains low rate of suicide among Catholics – close knit, protestant – freedom
Unmarried and childless have little integration into family- more prone to suicide
Second type of suicide= Altruistic- too much social integration – opposite of egoistic suicide
Individual sacrifices own life as a sense of duty- has little duty
Illustrated by Suttee- where individuals were expected to perform sati- throw themselves on their husbands burning funeral pyre to not be a burden on the family
Third type of suicide= Anomic- too little moral regulation – society doesn’t regulate its individuals sufficiently
Traditional norms and values are disputed by rapid social change providing uncertainty in individuals as to what society expects of them.
Rates rise during times of economic slumps- wall street stock exchange crash= depression= suicide
Fourth type of suicide= fatalistic- too much moral regulation – individual feels that they can do nothing to affect their situation
Slaves and prisoners are most likely to experience this.

Paragraph 2- Evaluation of Durkheim’s study – ADV + DISADV
Adv. of Durkheim’s Study
Disadv. Of Durkheim’s Study
Theory is simple and focused- allowing him to study groups accurately= accurate results to support study
Theory is logical- easily explain many suicides + differences between cultures.

Gibbs + martin- theories aren’t precise + idea of social integration is poorly defined

fails to consider most reasons for suicide too vague + doesn’t consider multiple influences on an individual behavior

Findings are unrepresentative – unable to generalize as his findings on European countries- as it was found in 19th century- no longer apply to modern society.

Altruistic suicide- outdated or irrelevant in most western societies – In today’s society- fulfil one’s own selfish desires

Categories based on Christian religions and societies- irrelevant to rest of the world.

Only 4 categories- not possible, as every suicidal act is unique- interpretivists= cannot be categorised + reasons vary on why the deceased committed suicide.

Social suicidal behavior cannot be blames solely on two factors of social integration and moral regulation- both are structural
Ignoring psychological factors based on relationships

Halbwachs et al found – important differences other than religion
E.g. social disorganization, urban dwelling + people living alone- only 4 factors are not the only reasons why people commit suicide.
Durkheim- too deterministic as it proposed societal factors cause an individual to kill themselves- freedom.

Paragraph 3-
Douglas criticizes Durkheim- on 2 grounds
1. Use of statistics – whether they should be relied on- decision to classify a death as a suicide depends on coroners – influenced by family and friends= bias verdicts
Explains high level of integration + low level of suicide rates- as well integrated people have friends and families – deny death as a suicide because of own feeling of guilt.
Whereas
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Assess The Sociological Explanations Of Suicide

Assess The Usefulness Of Different Sociological Approach To Suicide

Assess the usefulness of different sociological approaches to suicide. Different sociologists have taken to the study of suicide. Positivists and Interpretivists have totally different views about society, sociology and how to study suicide.Positivism is the belief that society can and should be studied scientifically and that sociology should model itself on the logic of natural methods of natural sciences. Interpretivism is the idea that society in an objective , observable form; rather it…

Words 2186 - Pages 9

Sociology and Social Sciences Essay

power of society to guide our actions, thoughts and feelings. For example, a mother feels guilty for wanting to spend money on herself. Another example is that we may think that people get marriage simply because they have fallen in love, yet the sociological perspective show us that…

Words 2284 - Pages 10

CRM 1301 Midterm uOttawa Carolyn Gordon Essays

The Demonic Perspective Trephining Individual who were having illusions or were delusional had a hole drilled in their skull in order to get rid of the spirits. If that person was still alive, the procedure was successful Witchcraft Correlated with ‘The Crucible’ where Tituba, Sarah Good & Sarah Osborne are accused of witchcraft in Salem, 1692 What to do with the witches?! Exodus 22:18- Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live Leviticus 20:27- A man also or woman that hath a familiar spirit…

Words 10213 - Pages 41

Essay on Anthro EXAM REVIEW

Exam Review UNIT ONE: Anthropology ­ studies the origins, beliefs, development, and customs of humans. It interests in earliest forms of human race. Anthropology is divided into three groups: ● Physical ­ how humans have adapted ● Cultural ­ different societies are compared ● Social ­ studies social organization of people Questions anthropologists may ask include: ● how does the distant evolutionary past affect us today? ● how are humans different from apes? Fields of study include: ●…

Words 7683 - Pages 31

Gerontology and Older Adults Essay

Wk 1: Gerontological Nursing N410 Young-Shin Lee, PhD, RN School of Nursing San Diego State University 1 Learning Objectives     Examine the history of gerontological nursing. Discuss the nurse’s role in caring for older adults. Identify educational preparation and certification requirement for gerontological nurse generalist and specialist. Related course objectives: 1.1~1.4 2 **Gerontological Nursing  Gerontology: study of aging; a branch of science that deals with the aging population…

Words 8953 - Pages 36

Criminology Notes Essay

The Demonic Era recap -two main paths that can lead you to the devil? Temptation (choice), possession -5 trials -Patriarchal society Modern Day ‘Witch Hunts?’ -A witch hunt occurs any time a group of people persecutes another group unfairly, usually blaming that other group for larger problems, form of a socially constructed problem -e.g. expansion of AIDS blaming on homosexuals, blaming unemployment rates on immigration -early 1900s Chinese immigrants come to Canada to work on the railroads…

Words 8665 - Pages 35