Bernard Williams And Utilitarianism

Words: 298
Pages: 2

Bernard Williams goes into asking the question if Utilitarianism is the correct answer in every situation. Sure, considering the greater happiness of everyone when making a decision is a good idea, but when it comes down between choosing how someone actually feels about a certain contingency, should they choose the greater happiness, or what they feel? The morally correct response in the trolley event, according to Utilitarianism, would be to run over the one person instead of five. In actuality, if you knew that one person was a beloved family member, most would go with running over the five strangers, because no one could possibly live with knowing that they killed one of their family members. This is where Utilitarianism gets tricky. Williams