Blame Paper

Submitted By pjkoscher
Words: 1412
Pages: 6
Open Document
PJ Koscher

An Analysis of the Nature of Blame: Reactive Attitude vs. Assessment

In current philosophical literature on moral responsibility, there have been recent developments on the increased focus on the nature of blame. A theory of the nature of blame claims to understand what it means for one to morally blame another for an act previously performed. An account of the nature of blame is an account of the conditions necessary for the holding of the blame relation to be deemed appropriate. There are three main accounts of the nature of blame currently in play in philosophical literature on moral responsibility: sanction, assessment, and reactive attitude. In this essay, I will provide a thorough explanation of both the reactive attitude and the assessment accounts and will show how the reactive attitude account outperforms the assessment account. Then I will introduce a common objection to the reactive attitude account and sketch how an advocate of the reactive attitude account might respond to the objection.

The assessment account of blame suggests that when we blame a person for an act they performed, we reveal something negative about the person’s character. One way to explain the assessment account is to imagine a moral balance sheet. This moral balance sheet can also be thought as a demerit system. When a person acts out of a norm and is blamed, then something negative is revealed in their character. When something negative is revealed in a person’s character, their moral record is considered negative, suggesting they have lowered their moral worth. This works in the other way as well. When a moral act is performed, something positive is revealed in one’s character. When this happens, a person’s moral record is considered positive, suggesting they have increased their moral worth. In other words, when an act is praised the person has increased their moral worth, while when an act is negative the person has lowered their moral worth. One of the key points to recognize from the assessment account of blame is humans care about what people think of them, meaning they care about their moral evaluations because these moral evaluations are how people judge our moral worth. An advantage to the assessment account of blame is it allows for private blame. Private blame is where one can make an assessment without ever expressing it to the person. In blaming a person, we are not only judging blameworthiness, but also judging the negative bring up of someone’s character.

The reactive attitude account of blame relates to a set of attitudes that hold people responsible for their actions. This account of blame derives from the notable philosopher, P.F. Strawson. These “reactive attitudes” are emotional reactions to the good and bad actions that people perform towards themselves and others. The emotional reactions in reactive attitudes tend to relate to negative emotions such as resentment and guilt. An important note of the reactive attitude account of blame refers to the interpretation of blame. Blame is more than just emotions resulting in a reaction from certain behavior; blame is an emotional response to the ill will that people exhibit towards themselves and others. When we are blaming someone, we are emotionally exercising on what they have done. This emotional exercise carries a negative reaction towards the person whom we are blaming. Therefore, we are holding the blamed person accountable for their actions through exercised emotion. An advantage of the reactive attitude account of blame is it also allows for private blame (see previous paragraph for private blame definition). Not only can the reactive attitude account allow for private blame, but it can also give us a way to communicate our reactive emotions with others. This communication leads to the “basic moral demand,” which consists of our expectation of moral behavior. In other words, we demand a displayed absence of ill will behavior. If moral behavior is
Show More

Related Documents: Blame Paper

Rhetorical Analysis Of Flint Water Crisis In Flint By Morckel

passive-aggressive manner. She blames the Flint water crisis on the city’s government and society itself, putting blame on large groups of people and institutions. This makes the reader feel guilty for the occurrences in Flint, as well as other crises mentioned later in the article, and ultimately angry at those who failed to recognize or prevent the problem beforehand. Although this gets her point across, it is very hostile and relatively unsophisticated. Morckel also referred to her own paper throughout her…

Words 299 - Pages 2

Personal Responsibility Research Paper

make strenuous personal efforts to live by those standards. But personal responsibility also means that when individuals fail to meet expected standards, they do not look around for some factor outside themselves to blame. The demise of personal responsibility occurs when individuals blame their family, their peers, their economic circumstances, or their society for their own failure to meet standards" (Haskins). We all need stability in our lives. Just ask the single mother of two who works full-time…

Words 1104 - Pages 5

Meg Wiviott's Paper Hearts Essay

Scapegoating is present in Meg Wiviott’s novel, Paper Hearts in order to emphasize the horrendous conditions which Fania and Zlatka lived in; Wiviott successfully argues that even in a world that is corrupt, it is necessary to find a reason to stay alive through the recurrence of scapegoats. Paper hearts takes place in World War II, the late 1930s until the mid 1940s. World War I was resolved with the Treaty of Versailles which blamed Germany for all aspects of the war. As a result Germany had a…

Words 548 - Pages 3

Ethical: Academic Journal and Term Paper

pick one of the topics listed below. Please follow APA format (if you are not familiar with APA, Purdue OWL has an excellent website on APA format). You must submit your paper to blackboard via safe assign and to live text. The term paper is a requirement for this course. Write a 5 – 7 page (body of the paper) APA term paper from the list of ethics topics below. Ethics Topics (Please select one) 1. Politicians often say that President Bush’s tax cuts were for the rich. In 2005, the top…

Words 627 - Pages 3

Domestic Violence Against Women Research Paper

Domestic abuse against women In her news article, the spokesperson for amnesty international describes domestic violence as a worldwide phenomenon that violates the human rights of female victims (Mite, 2005). In addition, the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) described violence against women as “a global epidemic that kills, tortures, and maims – physically, psychologically, sexually and economically. It is one of the most pervasive of human rights violations, denying women and girls…

Words 981 - Pages 4

Cary's Rhetorical Analysis: Provincial Freeman

From the very first word of the piece, “we”, the audience is included in the subjective minority struggle that the paper accompanies. Their path becomes part of “our wants and grievances”, personalizing a possibly foreign sense of empathy and suffrage. Then Cary, while including the reader still introduces the appeal to “our fellow subjects”, or the non-included audience…

Words 571 - Pages 3

the Irish Famine Essay

will give them the hunger and lust to work and gain money to buy more meat. Source L was written during the time of the famine so is therefore a primary source and details, although possibly left out due to the biased nature of the British tabloid paper and the discrimination against the Irish people, were not simply forgotten over time. Source M is an extract from a letter written by Cork magistrate Nicholas Cummins after a visit…

Words 656 - Pages 3

Research Paper On Obama Care

Anthony Facey Laura SamalEnglish 101 – 05 May 2, 2014 Dear Monsieur de Tocqueville, In 2008, we elected a new President and it seems that all people do is blame and complain about him, with “Obama this, Obama that.” The president has become the idol for blame to the American citizens. This blame can be seen all over the media, blaming him for the economy crisis, Obama care, and supposedly not passing laws that could better the United States. Now, Obama Care was a law created by the president…

Words 2744 - Pages 11

The Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill What Essay

The Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill: What Happens When Technology Fails & Who’s to Blame Ginamarie Paladino Montclair State University Abstract The BP Deepwater Horizon oil spill that occurred in 2010 posed great economic risks to the Gulf of Mexico and raised questions as to how this event could possibly happen. This essay reviews the Deepwater Horizon’s building and purpose, two key findings in the investigation, and the evidence provided in the Section 4 Overview of the Deepwater Horizon…

Words 1832 - Pages 8

Abigail Williams Downfall

the Devil, which put her at the center of it all. At the trial, she was the one who people watched to see if she would react from the people. She is the main factor as to why so many people were killed. By the end of this paper, you should understand why Abigail deserves the blame for the outcome of events in the play. At the beginning of the play, Abigail is accused of being a witch and contacting the Devil after dancing in the woods and drinking a blood charm. It can be shown in the following quote:…

Words 869 - Pages 4