Childhood Drownings Essay

Submitted By Capella15
Words: 1613
Pages: 7
Open Document
Childhood Drownings in Arizona Julianne Barone ASU ENG102

Drowning is the leading cause of death in Arizona among children 1 - 4 years of age. In 2011, fifty-six percent of drowning deaths were among the 1-4 age groups. The total number of deaths among children older but younger than 18 was 837 of which 35 percent of these deaths could have been prevented. (Rimsza M.D., 2012)
In a study by the Arizona Department of Health Services (ADHS), among 38 incidents involving children less than 5 years of age, 38 incidents occurred in pools. ("Water-related incidents in," 2010) Toddlers aged between one and four years are most at risk, because they are mobile and curious but do not understand the danger of water. ("Unintentional drowning: Get," 2012) In 2009, 103 drowning accidents reported via 9-1-1 determined that children 0-4 years of age accounted for 59 of these incidents, 47 of which occurred in swimming pools. Of the 59 young children, 14 died. Others had permanent neurological damage. (Flood, 2009) Taking precautions to reduce the risk of drowning around your home is very important. A toddler or child can drown in five centimeters of water. Every exposed water source, no matter how shallow, poses a significant danger. This includes many other sources besides swimming pools such as buckets, bathtubs, birdbaths, and fishponds. (Flood, 1989)
Many programs initiated in the ‘90 have proposed awareness and pool fencing. Although a good beginning for prevention, there is more to do to meet a sufficient goal. Local ordinances enacted in Los Angeles County before 1996 do not appear to have been effective in reducing the rate of childhood drowning in residential pools (Morgenstern & Bingham 2000). The US National Library of Medicine (NLM) at the National Institutes of Health determined a few reasons for this ineffectiveness. Insufficient building codes for isolating pools from homes, inadequate enforcement of the ordinances, and inadequate operation or maintenance of fencing equipment by pool owners. ("Effects of pool-fencing," 2000)
There is an ordinance in Arizona that grants exemptions to certain cities, similar to L.A. and therefore poses the same hazard for our state. It allows older built homes to be exempt from having to install fencing. In a graph review from the Phoenix Association of Realtors’, several cities such as Scottsdale and Litchfield Park are not applicable to the State Law. The state ordinance for these cities allows for all new pools in communities that do not have their own ordinances prior to June 1, 1991to install pool fencing, but it does not apply to pools built prior to June 1, 1991. (Phoenix Association of Realtors (2002) Therefore, if a house is older than 23 yrs, then it is not mandatory to install fence /gates for the pool until sale of the house.
The problem with Arizona’s law is that it does not focus on the health problem as an overall statewide problem. Taking action to address a law but then grandfathering homes built prior to a certain date, and allowing for these exemptions does not solve the problem. If the intention is to further the reduction of the drowning death rate, then it is crucial to make sure it is achievable. Ensure that there are wider use of barriers such as secure fencing and a self-latching gate on all properties statewide. It should not matter how old the pool is or if it is a built-in or an above- ground pool. Although significant change has occurred over 25 years, there is a need to ensure that the law is applicable in all cities.
There are also homes that do not isolate the pool from the house. They have three-sided fencing with doors or windows from the house to the pool and are additional ways for children to have access. Fencing that completely encircles a pool and isolates it from the house is much more effective than fencing that allows children to gain access to the pool through the house. (Thompson & Rivera 2013) A pool fence must be 5ft tall
Show More

Related Documents: Childhood Drownings Essay

Toddlers Research Paper

maneuvers toddlers learn. Swimming lessons for toddlers Of all childhood accidents, drownings and near-drownings are most likely to mar warm-weather fun. Contrary to what you might expect, most drownings happen within a few feet of adult supervision, with toddlers more likely to drown in bathtubs, toilets, fountains or fish tanks than in swimming pools or ocean waters. Parents look to swimming lessons to protect against drowning without realizing that toddlers cannot yet execute…

Words 765 - Pages 4

Elizabeth Strout's Incoming Tide

living in New York, returns to his small childhood town in an attempt to find closure in his seemingly lonely and unsupported life. However, with the presence of his former middle school math teacher, Olive Kitteridge, Kevin is able to push his agony aside in order to rescue one of his childhood classmates. Kevin’s ability to return to his childhood home and endure a sense of segregation and familiarity pertain to my sentiments whenever I visit my childhood town in South-Eastern Washington. The…

Words 992 - Pages 4

The Truman Show Analysis

the people he has every met have been actors. To Keep Truman from finding out the real world or to stop him from escaping, the cooperation has used a range of tactics from fear to deception. These include the fear of water who was onset by his dad drowning, to him wanting to be an explorer and being put off by his teacher and finally his co-workers stopping him from going to Fiji. 1) The fear of water has stopped Truman from finding out the truth. This all happened when Truman and his father kirk…

Words 504 - Pages 3

Kari Strutt's Touching Bottom

Strutt recounts her childhood experiences of swimming as a starting point to show how this has shaped her life and influenced her morals and values. Later on, readers will see that Strutt’s memories, particularly the lessons she learns from swimming, help her in coping with conflicts…

Words 706 - Pages 3

The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien: An Analysis

While dreams guide the narration of The Corpse Washer, the central motif in The Things They Carried is storytelling, with personal reflection by the author Tim O’Brien, seen through his own semi-autobiographical character, Tim O’Brien. Composed of short, fantastical stories that O’Brien repeats, changes, and claims are true only to later reveal they are false, reality is continually questioned in the text. Instead, O’Brien focuses on memory and fantasy, utilizing a number of different perspectives…

Words 1789 - Pages 8

Andrea Yates Case Study Essay

patients. From the discovered risk factors, Yates must have been exposed to mental disorder risks throughout all the stages of development; childhood, teenage, and adulthood. 2. Biological Perspective on Yates’ Condition…

Words 529 - Pages 3

Comparing Poems 'On Turning Ten And Owl Pellets'

what it feels like to be young. Collins conveys the sadness of growing up by saying, “This is the beginning of sadness, I say to myself, as I walk through the universe in my sneakers.” This is a beautiful way of expressing the realization that his childhood is coming to an end. In contrast, “Owl Pellets” talks about being young through a specific incident. “You sit with Jon Fox, ignore me completely.” The pain of new experiences is fresh, and it reveals how we can get hurt so easily. They both demonstrate…

Words 601 - Pages 3

Those Winter Sundays 'And All Bad, Dad, Not Bad'

Hayden and “Not Bad, Dad, Not Bad” by Jan Heller Levi both reveal an adult’s buried remorse of never truly appreciating their father while growing up. Word for word, “Not Bad, Dad, Not Bad” details an event in the narrator’s childhood where her father struggles to save her from drowning but fails to do so. In the poem, the narrator compares her father’s parenting in an abstract manner, equating it to her father swimming in an ocean towards the narrator as she drowns. Thus, swimming is used as a metaphor…

Words 1656 - Pages 7

Theodore Roosevelt Research Paper

Theodore Roosevelt was the embodiment of a walking medical disaster with the several ailments that he developed throughout his lifetime. It began in his childhood with long asthmatic nights, as well as headaches, stomach pains, and severe insomnia (Grondahl, 2004). Later on, he developed myopia and awful tooth structure (Grondahl, 2004), which led to several problems for him throughout his life. Genetics was not the only misfortune Roosevelt endured. His adventurous ways led him to getting shot,…

Words 345 - Pages 2

Life and Music of Ray Charles Essay

Life and Music of Ray Charles The history of musicians is a very interesting subject. There are thousands and millions of interesting types of musicians. Ray Charles was a very talented musician. His focus was on Soul Music, which was Jazz combined with Gospel music. Jazz was also a big focus of his music. Ray Charles wasn’t like other musicians. He was a blind musician. Many often wonder how someone can be blind and also be a musician, but Ray Charles was a fine example to show that it was possible…

Words 1124 - Pages 5