Circle Justice In Touching Spirit Bear

Words: 547
Pages: 3
Open Document
Circle Justice vs Jail “Circle Justice gives certain clients a second chance to get rid of all the pain, if so, left inside of them.” Daquan Gleason. Circle Justice provides more opportunities for Cole Matthews, the main character in the novel Touching Spirit Bear, by Ben Mikaelsen. Rather than going to jail, Cole would get a better chance at a successful future going back to the isolated Alaskan island. Cole should continue Circle Justice and go back to the island because he needs to finish his sentence, he has signs of change, and he has a better chance at success. The first reason I believe Cole should go back to the island is because he should finish out his banishment sentence. Matthews’ sentence was originally one year on an Alaskan …show more content…
Life is beautiful in Cole’s eyes now that he has experienced nature first hand on the island. When the birds were killed by the fallen tree, Cole felt sympathy towards the baby sparrows. Yet earlier in the book, he would’ve shown anger towards them because they got attention from their mother. The final reason I believe Cole should return to the island is because he has a better chance at success. Since Circle Justice was introduced as an option, juvenile arrest rates have dropped almost 45%. And about 70% of the teens in Circle Justice, stayed out of trouble and no longer had run-ins with the law. Statistics say that Cole would have a better chance at changing if he returned to the island to finish out his sentence. In addition, the island is isolated and away from contact to other people who could harm Cole and be harmed by him. Although I feel that Cole would be better off going back to the Alaskan island, I can see where some people may think Cole should be put in jail. Many people believe that because Cole Matthews broke the contract with The Circle, he doesn’t deserve a second chance on the island. If the goal is to see change in his behavior, then Circle Justice will be the more successful
Show More

Related Documents: Circle Justice In Touching Spirit Bear

Circle Justice In Ben Mikaelsen's Touching Spirit Bear

“There is a higher court than courts of justice and that is the court of conscience. It supersedes all other courts.” -Mahatma Gandhi. In the novel, Touching Spirit Bear, Cole Mathews is portrayed as a violent, trouble-making youth. After his most recent crime, he is offered to go through circle justice to be healed and avoid jail. The author tells the readers how the current justice system is ineffective and how other justice systems, like circle justice, can shape up even the most violent juvenile…

Words 856 - Pages 4

Analysis Of Touching Spirit Bear

The sequel of Touching Spirit Bear is The Ghost of Spirit Bear and it has a theme that is different it's predecessor, has similar concepts of the original book, has differences to it as well, and is within a competition with its creator for which book I enjoyed more. The theme of Touching Spirit Bear to be able to forgive yourself. For example on page 194 in Touching Spirit Bear Cole shouted “I forgive you, I forgive you”. Also Cole was alone when he was shouting these words so he must have been…

Words 457 - Pages 2

Touching Spirit Bear Analysis

Many people around the world believe in karma. Karma is another way of saying what goes around comes around. The theme in Touching Spirit Bear is also karma. Throughout the book, there are several scenarios that prove karma exists. The first piece of evidence is when Cole is mauled by the Spirit Bear. Cole is a fifteen year old, juvenile delinquent who has created a raucous in Minneapolis. Cole trashed and robbed a hardware store. A kid named Peter Driscal told on Cole. Cole was outraged by this…

Words 507 - Pages 3

Touching Spirit Bear Book Report

Touching Spirit Bear, T.S.B, and The Devil’s Arithmetic ,D.A, are 2 books that have environments that are dangerous that have some similarities and some differences. Let’s compare them! First the backstory of the books, starting off with T.S.B. T.S.B is about a boy named cole that is on the wrong side of the law. Prision won’t work for him so he is sent to circle justice which is a Native American form of justice , originating in Canada that seeks healing in contrast to the regular punishment ways…

Words 497 - Pages 2

Character Analysis Touching Spirit Bear

Cole Matthews Character Profile Cole Matthews, the main character in the book, Touching Spirit Bear. Cole Matthews is a fifteen year old delinquent, he has been in and out of juvie since he was seven years old. He has blonde hair, a baby face and, is big for his age. On page five, it states, “He was a baby-faced fifteen-year-old from Minneapolis who had been in trouble with the law half his life.” He is from Minneapolis, Minnesota, and has two parents that are seperated. His parents are both heavy…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Touching Spirit Bear Literary Analysis

idea of satisfaction of helping others. This theme shown directly in the novel Touching Spirit Bear by Ben Mikaelsen. This concept of satisfaction of helping others can be counted many times throughout the book, but many of it is prevalent within the first few chapters and can be seen inside the characters during the novel. Cole Matthews, the troubled law-sickened boy, has had his life altered through circle justice. Garvey and everyone else included in Cole’s punishment and redemption have shown…

Words 459 - Pages 2

Essay On Restorative Justice

Why is Restorative Justice more beneficial than our current discipline system? By Francesca Gervase There will always be people around the country getting in trouble with the law. This creates a need to handle misbehavior and law breaking. The current system doesn't always solve the problems and works to punish people by sending the offender to jail or fining them. However, Restorative Justice, also known as Circle Justice, works to heal people and help with the situation by having the offender…

Words 877 - Pages 4

Comparing Touching Spirit Bear And Devil's Arithmetic

future. Another book called Touching Spirit Bear is about a stereotypical teenager by the name of Cole Matthews, who disrespects adults and kids. He finds himself going to Circle Justice after an attack on a kid. He goes to an island off the Alaskan Coast. He fights for survival and hopes he gets off the island. While Touching Spirit Bear and The Devil’s Arithmetic have different themes, the motivation to change characters are surely similar. In Touching Spirit Bear and Devil’s…

Words 389 - Pages 2

Touching Spirit Bear Analysis

I am currently reading Touching Spirit Bear by Ben Mikaelsen. I am still enjoying this book. Cole has not been very happy since he has been at the island, he has been very angry towards everything. On his first circle of justice meeting, the judge that been hearing the case the first time Cole played gilty went, his parents, his lawyer, and Peter the boy Cole had beat up were all at the circle of justice meeting. During the meeting “ Cole peeked and caught Peter peeking back” (37) This tells me it…

Words 386 - Pages 2

Theme Of Touching Spirit Bear

happened in the past, as an example of what may answer questions, explanations of character motivation, character’s fears, and the character’s daily life was like. While Touching Spirit Bear and The Devil’s Arithmetic have similar types of conflict and use of flashback, the themes are clearly different. Touching Spirit Bear Cole Matthews is the main protagonist and antagonist has problems that lead him to harm a fellow student Peter…

Words 406 - Pages 2