Civil Disobedience Argument

Words: 225

Pages: 1

In the article “Civil Disobedience” written by Henry David Thoreau, it discusses the topic on how to peacefully disagree with a person or persons. First, Thoreau states that he doesn't want to get rid of government but simply a new one. For instance, it states,” I ask for, not at once no government, but at once a better government” This is interestingly important because in the 21st century there are people protesting other people, the people that are protesting are not doing it to rid of the government but to help try and create something greater than themselves. Secondly, Thoreau states that we should do it peacefully and be able to still stand fast in what we believe in. For instance, “ The objections which have been brought against a

Show More

Arguments Against Civil Disobedience

use peaceful resistance, which is needed to positively impact a free society. Shown through the treatment of minorities and the true feelings behind civil disobedience, peaceful resistance is undoubtedly detrimental to many causes. As Carl Cohen wrote many rebuttals in “Arguments Against Civil Disobedience” addressing the issue of civil disobedience, he had a continuous theme of the true meaning behind it that should be highlighted. Cohen goes on to explain how breaking the law shows how much…

Words 798 - Pages 4

Seven Arguments Against Civil Disobedience

But, unfortunately we do not live in perfect world sometimes people have to fight for the right to be treated as human. For this reason, the concept of civil disobedience is such a powerful notion. It allows those without a voice to gain one and demand equal treatment. It allows a society to change in a positive manner for without civil disobedience free society would never truly be free. A government, in theory, is responsible for the safety and fair treatment of its but sometimes the government…

Words 799 - Pages 4

Carl Cohen's 7 Arguments Against Civil Disobedience

societies evolve based on the premise of civil disobedience. It created bills such as the civil rights acts of the 60s, motivated equality lead by Mahatma Gandhi, and has been the fundamental element of a free society dating back to our founding fathers finding motivation in Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience. Without these upstanding leaders the ideals and morals that shape modern day society would not be prevalent. The practice of civil disobedience does not only positively reform and maintain…

Words 671 - Pages 3

Carl Cohen's Seven Arguments Against Civil Disobedience

not meant to be broken, and if broken, you are considered a criminal, and that is that. According to Carl Cohen's Seven Arguments Against Civil Disobedience, he says, "Civil disobedience implies contempt of the law." He also says that when a disobedient breaks the law willingly, he will be punished anyway, because it is a written law and will be enforced as such. For some civil disobedient people, the punishment for the crime will be more severe than the accidental law breaker's punishment for the…

Words 501 - Pages 3

The Justness Of Civil Disobedience

Civil disobedience is nonviolent resistance manifested by an active, perceived refusal to obey certain laws or commands of a government. It involves the symbolic violation of a particular law and not a rejection of an entire system. Individuals that engage in civil disobedience often than not found themselves on the wrong end of the law. It is because, those in power feel threatened by such acts and feel the need to enforce the law at all cost. It has led to the branding of a civil disobedient individual…

Words 1220 - Pages 5

Why Is Civil Disobedience Important To Society

Civil disobedience is important to creating a functioning and fair society. Blind following of laws can create the opportunity for inequality to take hold. A violent reaction to a law you don’t like can lead to more abuse and disapproval among others in the community. While civil disobedience can cost money for a government being affected by it, it does more good than harm. The damage is can do is far outweighed by the good it has already done throughout history, even recently. A good case to show…

Words 507 - Pages 3

Thoreau's Civil Disobedience

To history, civil disobedience is the driving force that is integral to keeping a free society free. It is in civil disobedience that we find the keys to social change. From Thoreau's Civil Disobedience, one of the first intellectual writings supporting the idea, to the Black Lives Matter movement, and the Women's March on DC after President Trump's inauguration, civil disobedience is found as a prominent theme, a theme that keeps government as the tool to serve the will of the common many, rather…

Words 629 - Pages 3

The Benefits Of Civil Disobedience

Throughout the course of history one group's go against another's. Civil Disobedience is a necessary moral obligation we need to protest the unjust, such as Dr.KIng did for equality, without going to extremes, such as Gandhi did by not rioting in order to gain India's independence. Why? What would drive a human to go against others of its own kind. Imagine your daughter running up to you with red, hot tears asking why she cant go to the new playground built right down the street, because the Jim…

Words 395 - Pages 2

Martin Luther King's Letter From Birmingham Jail

Jail" were civil disobedience, unjust law and a just law. Martin Luther King is arrested and jailed during anti-segregation protests in Birmingham, Alabama. There he writes "Letter from Birmingham Jail," which advocated nonviolent civil disobedience. One of the greatest letters ever written. After being jailed in Birmingham Ala. Dr. King responds to 8 clergymen and preachers who criticized his civil disobedience. In “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” Dr. King, defending civil disobedience, cited Augustine…

Words 431 - Pages 2

Thoreau's Theory Of Civil Disobedience

laws that promote freedom, justice and equality. Although this is ideal, in theory, it doesn’t always happen, and in those moments where the laws conflict with what the people find to be just, and free, civil disobedience and protests are born. Henry David Thoreau coined the term “civil disobedience” in his 1848 essay, which attempted to justify his refusal to pay the state poll tax enacted by the government to pay for a war against Mexico and enforce the Fugitive Slave Laws. Thoreau argued that the…

Words 785 - Pages 4