Civil Disobedience Comparison

Words: 891
Pages: 4
Open Document
Because of the Bible and Thoreau’s teachings the world had a drastic change. Both have good things to offer in regard to their teachings but in the end it leaves us with the question, who is right? How do we respond to what Thoreau says? In Thoreau’s piece Civil Disobedience he offers his strong opinions on the government and how it should be. Thoreau believes that no government is the best government. Thoreau’s opinions on government and how to follow the government rules often contradicts the Bible and contradicts my opinions on how to deal with unjust laws, taxing, and the government itself.
Thoreau and God’s Word have differing views about government and the people’s interaction with it. Thoreau’s argument is that “which also I believe- …show more content…
The question is whether we should be content to obey them, whether we should try to change them but obey until they're changed, or whether we should disobey them at once. Thoreau believes that the second course is best. They believe that if they resist, the revolution would be worse than the injustice. However, it is the government's fault that this is the case: The government doesn't encourage reform and dissent. Thoreau asks, "Why does [the majority-led government] always crucify Christ, and excommunicate Copernicus and Luther, and pronounce Washington and Franklin rebels?"This shows his hatred towards unjust laws. The bible contradicts thoreau’s statements and beliefs. The bible agrees more with the first option that was mentioned. In 1 Peter 2:13-14 it says “Submit yourselves for the Lord’s sake to every human institution, whether to a king as the one in authority, or to governors as sent by him for the punishment of evildoers and the praise of those who do right.” Rather than disobeying and creating a bigger problem we need to slow down and realize that God has a plan no matter how unjust the law is. Just because you do not want to do something does not mean that you just cannot not do
Show More

Related Documents: Civil Disobedience Comparison

Civil Disobedience Gandhi And Mandela Comparison

The thing that Thoreau, Gandhi, and Mandela had in common is that they all believe that civil disobedience is an effective way of change government, they had served time in prison for civil disobedience, and all their legacies have impact on the terms they had on civil rights and equality. Also, they have inspired may people up until today for the great work they did, and a lot of the people admired them. They have done amazing things for their country and mainly for their people so that they would…

Words 582 - Pages 3

Comparison Of Civil Disobedience And Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Civil Disobedience was written by Author Henry David Thoreau and published in 1849. Letter from Birmingham jail was written by Civil Rights leader Dr. Martin Luther King Jr in 1963. I will be comparing their two works. Author Henery David Thoreau and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr were like each other because they were fighting for justice, constitutional rights and protested. They were different because Thoreau and King were from different times and they fought for different things that was currently…

Words 281 - Pages 2

Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience: A Troublesome Guardian Of Liberty

Civil Disobedience: A Troublesome Guardian of Liberty From the time of Henry David Thoreau to the day when Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat, acts of civil disobedience have been the subjects of enormous national controversy. Civil disobedience constitutes a peaceful refusal to submit to a law which a person feels is morally wrong or otherwise unjust, though still accepting the consequences the law dictates, to express their opposition. Defined thus, there is no room for arrogant contempt…

Words 798 - Pages 4

Fahrenheit 451 Comparison

Fahrenheit 451 Comparison What is your favorite book genre? If science fiction popped in your head, you may be interested in what i'm about to say. Science fiction is defined as “fiction based on imagine future scientific or technological advances and major social or environmental changes frequently portraying space or time travel and life on other planets”(science). In “Fahrenheit 451” by Ray Bradbury, the setting takes place in an environment ran by technology, where books are illegal. In this…

Words 799 - Pages 4

Mahatma Gandhi's Civil Disobedience

In a time of countries attempting to stake their place in the world even more than they already had, Gandhi fought for fairness and freedom from empire's dominance. Gandhi did so with a technique of non-violent, non-cooperation civil disobedience. From the realization in Africa that Indians did not have the same rights, Gandhi created a fearless demeanor of non-compliance with popular judgements and injustices(Briley). In 1915 when Gandhi went back to India, he also brought a strong fight that was…

Words 556 - Pages 3

Edward Snowden Civil Disobedient

Civil disobedience can be defined as a peaceful form of protest where individuals do not comply with the law. People engage in civil disobedience with hopes of changing a law they do not like or simply to spread awareness of an issue. Edward Snowden is a man who has been generalized as a civil disobedient. Snowden was under a contract with the NSA when he leaked classified information. Snowden revealed that United States agents were collecting telephone records and internet activity from citizens…

Words 680 - Pages 3

Differences Between Civil Disobedience And Terrorism

However, rebellions developed into two different types during the process of development: civil disobedience and terrorism. These two types have distinct characteristics and people’s opinions about them are quite diverse too. People always feel sympathetic about the protesters when they are talking about civil disobedience. The society regard civil disobedience as the…

Words 1382 - Pages 6

Black Lives Matter Movement Analysis

the Watts, California Black urban community. The repetitive patterns of civil disobedience in the African American community has displayed itself an insurmountable number of times since slavery. The African American community has always responded through social activism to defend their civil rights. A historical comparison of how the African American community through activism has responded to this type of civil disobedience in the past and present will be examine. Currently, most are familiar with…

Words 1244 - Pages 5

Comparing Crito And Martin Luther King's Letter To Birmingham Jail

their emotion, endeavors and passion that makes one, or many, act in retaliation. Retaliation against government and its laws is a reaction that is caused because free individuals cannot cooperate within the political landscape of that time. Civil disobedience is a term used to reference an agent who seeks to better understand the laws and change them to appeal to the individuals within society. Throughout history individuals have fought against the laws in their time to maintain basic human needs…

Words 1520 - Pages 7

Sosh Payper Essays

inclination to disobedience.” From a teenager rebelling against a controlling parent to the colonies revolting against the British, the suppression of freedom instinctively breeds resentment. Even more important than the probability of an act of disobedience, however, is the projected impact such an act could have for everyone involved. When viewed from this more general perspective, as the extent of an authority figure’s control increases, so does the impact of an act of disobedience from the followers…

Words 1395 - Pages 6