Civil Disobedience In America

Words: 784
Pages: 4
Open Document
This paper will consider the question “Do the protestors in Ferguson, Baltimore, and other places where there have been riots protesting police brutality have a duty to obey the law?” by drawing off of Joseph Raz, John Rawls, and Martin Luther King’s interpretations of civil disobedience. Civil disobedience is the active, professed refusal to obey certain laws or commands of a government; it is a symbolic violation of the law, rather than a rejection of the system as a whole. I shall argue that the protestors in Ferguson, Baltimore and other places where riots have emerged, do not have a duty to obey the law; civil disobedience is justified among the individuals protesting against police brutality.
Police brutality is the deliberate use of …show more content…
Jim Crow laws). John Rawls states that civil disobedience is a political justice addressing the majority. The rioters’ civil disobedience in Ferguson and Baltimore was justified because the protestors did not identify with a community where African Americans are being targeted by police and are brutally abused. The duty to obey the law is a social contract theory, if the government violates the rights of the people then people do not have a duty to obey the laws the government implements, an example being Ferguson and Baltimore. When the execution of a law becomes unjust, the government lacks authority, this results in protestors rioting against the injustice to bring about a …show more content…
The Civil Rights Movement occurred to change the policy of segregation as the protestors believed was unlawful. The boycotting done by African Americans made it difficult for the system to function, their actions would be considered coercive. Martin Luther King’s letter from Birmingham jail explained his reasoning behind his non-violent civil disobedience. King mentioned “one has a duty to disobey unjust laws” the unjust laws being segregation. King also states “I submit that an individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for the law”. MLK understands that civil disobedience should be the last resort in correcting unjust laws, King would not support the violent riots in Baltimore and Ferguson that resulted in property damage or the injury of others. King believed that violent protests cause violent retaliation from the authorities which is not beneficial for the aim of correcting unjust laws. The distinction between violence against property and violence against people cannot be made, simply because both actions involve violence; civil disobedience is usually defined as
Show More

Related Documents: Civil Disobedience In America

Why Is Civil Disobedience Important

their future security.” This is among the most powerful statements in the history of America and one of the most resolute within the Declaration of Independence, but it is only one of the many phrases that defines the United States. America was founded on the idea of standing up for rights, among them life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Throughout the history of the United States and today, Civil Disobedience and standing up for beliefs has been a cornerstone of American philosophy. Resistance…

Words 789 - Pages 4

Civil Disobedience's Role In Democracy

Civil disobedience has long played a key role in democracy. America was founded on the belief that all people should have unalienable rights, and they should have a say in the government. Prior to the signing of the Declaration of Independence, settlers in the colonies portrayed resistant to the British monarchy through events like the Boston Tea Party. Hundreds of years later, people still use civil disobedience to fight for their rights and defend the liberties granted to them through the Constitution…

Words 511 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience Acceptable Times Essay

Acceptable Times for Civil Disobedience Most people do not know what civil disobedience is. Civil disobedience is when a person breaks a rule or law because of morals and beliefs (“Civil Disobedience”). Martin Luther King, Junior’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail” is an example of when civil disobedience is acceptable. The Negroes in the piece of text are treated unjustly. Officials are not willing to help the negroes, so some have come to accept the fact that they will have many disadvantages in society…

Words 1016 - Pages 5

Civil Disobedience In Today's Society

In America today, there are protests, revolts, and chaos slipping through the cracks of the tranquil states of the united nations. Imagine living under the rule of a tyrannical leader who did all sorts of inequitable things. Would you just sit there like a puppet on a stage, or would you stand up and do what is right? Without civil disobedience, our generation would be a joke. Would African-Americans and other minorities have the same rights as white people? Would America, even exist? What makes…

Words 650 - Pages 3

Martin Luther King Jr Rhetorical Analysis

American congressman and civil rights activist John Lewis famously stated before he died in 2020 that "Ordinary people with extraordinary vision can redeem the soul of America by getting in what I call good trouble, necessary trouble." Throughout history, whether it be American colonists throwing tea into the harbor, Civil Rights activists rallying protests, or suffragettes holding hunger strikes in protest of their arrests, trouble has typically always precedent change in America. Lewis knew that to…

Words 806 - Pages 4

Civil Disobedience: The Boston Tea Party

acts of civil disobedience, individuals have resisted injustices throughout history and have impacted our society in positive ways. The willingness of these individuals and movements to disobey controversial laws in a civil manner has resulted in our society being a better place for all. I strongly believe that without the use of protest and acts of civil disobedience that it would not have been possible for so many accomplishments be achievements throughout history.…

Words 666 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience Research Paper

Immigrants. In history Civil Disobedience is something every race does, consequences always follow civil disobedience, and today some of the consequences have changed. In the start of the United States, the country known for its freedom, was created due to civil disobedience. When the colonist refused to follow the taxes the king instructed to be collected the colonist reacted with civil disobedience. In the days when the English, French, and Spanish came to the Americas and took land of the Native…

Words 248 - Pages 1

Civil Disobedience Consequences

Immigrants. In history, Civil Disobedience is something every race does, consequences always follow civil disobedience, and today some of the consequences have changed. In the start of the United States, the country known for its freedom, was created due to civil disobedience. When the colonist refused to follow the taxes the king instructed to be collected the colonist reacted with civil disobedience. In the days when the English, French, and Spanish came to the Americas and took the land of the…

Words 625 - Pages 3

The Nonviolent Resistance To The Civil Rights Movement

the concept of law itself. Civil disobedience is defined as “refusal to obey governmental demands or commands especially as a nonviolent and usually collective means of forcing concessions from the government” (Merriam-Webster), and is not only immensely beneficial to, but is a crucial tenet of a free society. There are few countries in history that came to be without some form of resistance, violent or otherwise, and this is especially true in the case of America.…

Words 799 - Pages 4

Why Is Civil Disobedience Effective

United States of America. So why do the people have to protest to get the government to change things? Although people may say civil disobedience is not the correct manner of getting things changed, it is still very effective. Civil Disobedience has helped improve the world by giving people equal rights; therefore, it is a very effective agent of change. The Boston Tea Party lead to rebellion against Great Britain, which eventually lead to the creation of the United States of America. Back when the…

Words 777 - Pages 4