Compare And Contrast The Anti-Democrats Vs Anti Federalists

Words: 572
Pages: 3
Open Document
The Anti-Federalists attacked the Constitution's separation of powers from the perspective that there was a homogenization of the various branches of government. In Centinel I, it argues that there was not enough separation powers among the branches . The Anti-Federalists believed that the necessary separation of powers were dependent on a caste system not established in the United States, such as an aristocracy as opposed to a bourgeoisie. Federalists argued for the supplying of the positions of the Legislative branch via elections that are either direct or indirect. Patrick Henry, argued that these elections would create an elected aristocracy in all branches of government and not a system of checks and balances . The Anti-Federalists feared that the election of Senators would lead to the development of this aristocracy, taking more and more power. The idea that Senators who were elected by the state legislatures for six years, …show more content…
This is the Anti-Federalists weakest argument pertaining to the Legislative branch as annual elections decrease the stability of the branch and doesn’t provide a reasonable timeframe for a representative to implement legislation and attain results. In Federalist No. 52, the Federalists respond by explaining that biennial elections are necessary in order for representatives to develop experience without them being immediately concerned about reelection . The Constitutional structure of the House of Representatives forces representatives to be accountable to the people. The people directly elect their representatives and the chances of the house becoming an aristocracy is unlikely compared to the Senate. Therefore, the length of the terms of representatives is not as important when the constituents have control over who represents
Show More

Related Documents: Compare And Contrast The Anti-Democrats Vs Anti Federalists

APUSH Review Sheet Essay

William Pitt, Impressment, The Fall of Quebec, Wolfe and Montcalm, Treaty of Paris, Effects of the War, Colonialists vs. British, Proclamation (Line) of 1763, King George III, Pontiac’s Rebellion, The Imperial Crisis, Debt, Prime Minister George Grenville, The Sugar Act, Parliamentary Acts, Committees of Correspondence, , Revenue Act (Sugar Act of 1765), The Stamp Act (1765), Internal vs. External Taxes, Virtual Representation, Patrick Henry, Virginia Resolves, Samuel Adam, The Sons of Liberty, Stamp…

Words 1761 - Pages 8

Essay Hist405 Full Course Latest 2015 Spring [ All Discussions , All Quizes and All Assignments ]

hist405 full course latest 2015 spring [ all discussions , all quizes and all assignments ] Click Link Below To Buy: http://hwcampus.com/shop/hist405-full-course/ week 1 The Cost of Expansion (graded) Explain how and why slavery developed in the American colonies. Why couldn’t colonists use indentured servants as they had in the past? How would you describe the differences between slaves and indentured servants Colonial Identities (graded) The colonies of New England, the Mid –Atlantic…

Words 3084 - Pages 13