Conflict In John Locke's Second Treatise

Words: 877

Pages: 4

Open Document

In his “Second Treatise,” Locke suggests that people in a community have an obligation to obey the laws of the community’s government if the people gave their consent. However, one might point out the apparent conflict that many people in a community never gave explicit consent to obey the government, but rather were just born into the community. In this paper, I will discuss Locke’s arguments to resolve this apparent conflict. Then I will argue that Locke’s attempt to resolve this conflict is not very successful. Lastly, I will point out the flaws in Locke’s argument and provide relevant examples. Locke writes about two social contracts which serve as the basis for why people are obligated to follow the government if they gave their consent. In the first social contract, social compact, the community reaches a …show more content…
After some period of time since the initial establishment of the government, the government is able to establish services and facilities for its people to use and people have the time to acquire and own property in its territory. According to Locke, as long as you use and enjoy such services and property within the government’s territory, you are tacitly consenting to following the government. This makes it very difficult for the community to ever have the opportunity to give explicit consent. Most of the community is probably utilizing services by the government or own property within the government’s territory, thus tacitly consenting to follow the laws of the government. If you are obligated to give tacit consent and continually follow the government, there is really no need to give explicit consent, such as voting, anymore to the government. This appears to conflict with how the government was initially established, which was via explicit consent from the

Hobbes Vs Locke

Thomas Hobbes and John Locke are both very influential theoretical philosophers. They have both shared their ideologies in how the government should operate. Despite their shared commitments in philosophy, Hobbes and Locke have several points of divergence. Hobbes’s ideology is mostly based on a monarchy. In Hobbes’s eyes a monarchy solves conflicts, insures stability, and consistency in policies. While in the other hand Locke believed voluntary dictatorship/ democracy is the best way to govern a…

Words 561 - Pages 3

Summary Of John Locke's Second Treatise Of Government

John Locke discusses, in his Second Treatise of Government, the use of prerogative by the executive. While declaring the rule of law to be the foundation of government itself, he also argues the necessity of prerogative as “the legislators [are] not able to foresee, and provide by laws, for all that may be useful to the community” (pg. 83). Because of this, Locke proposed that the executive requires the “right to make use of [prerogative] for the good of the society … where the municipal law has…

Words 1257 - Pages 6

John Locke And Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Analysis

John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau present powerful arguments on a wide array of topics in their respective works. Locke’s Second Treatise of Government (1982) discusses how man’s natural inclination for property brings him into civil society. All individuals are equal, and the community is free. However, man is in a constant state of fear and uncertainty trying to preserve his welfare. As man ultimately wants to improve his life, the preservation and protection of property are perceived as sacred…

Words 612 - Pages 3

An Analysis Of John Locke's Two Treatise Of Government

The founding father of liberal political thought was John Locke, a 18th century English political philosopher. Locke was part of the Glorious Revolution of 1688-89 that saw the overthrow of the Stuart monarch Charles II and the formation of a parliamentary government. Unlike Hobbes, Locke believed in the concept of government having limits to the power over its own citizens. With his theory of Natural Rights and his work titled, Two Treatise of Government, Locke established a political though that…

Words 648 - Pages 3

Essay on Crusoe’s Island as an Allegorical Expression of Locke’s Theories on Property and Government

2011 Crusoe’s Island as an Allegorical Expression of Locke’s Theories on Property and Government Two prolific writers captured what was pressing to the economic and political zeitgeist of 18th century England. John Locke’s ideas on property influenced readers like Thomas Jefferson who would be a prolific politician involved in the founding of the United States. Locke’s views on an individual’s right to property is discussed in his Second Treatise of Government. But what also are compelling to readers…

Words 2244 - Pages 9

Pros Of The Enlightenment

In fact, in the Second Treatise of Government, John Locke claims ““Being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions,” which is remarkably similar to what the founding fathers stated in the Declaration of Independence. One would…

Words 755 - Pages 4

John Locke's Second Treatise Of Government

In "Second Treatise of Government," John Locke discusses the characteristics of civil society through explaining our human rights. According to Locke, there is a level of steps we take before joining as one. To him, a civil society is official when everyone gives consent. Although in a state of nature we are free and have a variety of benefits, civil society has a greater impact. This is because civil society provides protection, law, order, and regulation. Based on Locke's work, there are three…

Words 1175 - Pages 5

Similarities Between Locke And Rousseau

natural law helps to make all people equal. This theory includes the assumption that natural law is based on a set of rights to which everyone has equal access to. Another condition to the social contract which allows individuals to live free of conflict are property rights. Locke considers…

Words 1544 - Pages 7

Property Debate Between Locke & Rousseau Essay

Introduction John Locke and Jean Jacques Rousseau, two philosophers with differing opinions concerning the concept of private property. Rousseau believes that from the state of nature, private property came about, naturally transcending the human situation into a civil society and at the same time acting as the starting point of inequality amongst individuals. Locke on the other hand argues that private property acts as one of the fundamental, inalienable moral rights that all humans are entitled…

Words 1117 - Pages 5

Essay on Study Guide

SSUSH3 The student will explain the primary causes of the American Revolution. There are many causes of the American Revolution. The primary ones are: the French and Indian War, Treaty of Paris, Stamp Act, Proclamation of 1763, the Intolerable Acts, and Thomas Paine’s Common Sense. a. Explain how the end of the Anglo-French imperial competition as seen in the French-Indian War and the 1763 Treaty of Paris laid the groundwork for the American Revolution. The future of the North American continent…

Words 3082 - Pages 13