Conscription and Conscientious Objectors Essay

Submitted By damii23
Words: 1717
Pages: 7
Open Document
Frankie Donahue
19 February 2003
WR 121, Sec 20
Conscientious Objector

In 1661, conscientious objection was first recognized in America (Schlissel 28). The Quakers in Massachusetts were termed men with “tender conscience (Schlissel 28)” and were relieved from every duty to bear arms when dealing with the Indians. Throughout history conscientious objection has become more prominent. The American Revolution, Civil War, both World Wars, and the Cold War had conscientious objectors. The peak numbers for objection occurred during Vietnam when over 470,000 men claimed to be conscientious objectors and 170,000 of them were actually granted a conscientious objector deferment (Tollefson 6). Also, throughout history, the process to claim conscientious objector status has evolved. In 1948, the Selective Service Act was passed that made believing in a Supreme Being a requirement to apply to be a conscientious objector. Then in 1970, the belief in a Supreme Being was repealed and the reasons were changed to provide for any “objection based on a deeply held and coherent ethical system with no reference to a Supreme Being” (Columbia). This remains the current requirement; however, unlike during Vietnam era, today more of the country is in support of the military action. In a current CBS News poll, 70% of the voters said that they believe the United States is justified in taking action against Iraq (http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/02/07/opinion/polls/main539763 .shtml). Even though the majority of the public is supportive of military action, there are still many protests and history has demonstrated there will again be conscientious objectors. If a draft is enacted, conscientious objectors should not be able to avoid it because they receive the same benefits from the country; however, they should be able to avoid being combatant. One must understand that there are three types of conscientious objectors. First is the conscientious objector who only refuses to be in combat. This objector is willing to join the military; however, he refuses to participate in any actions that deal with combat. When applying to be a conscientious objector, the person is classified with a “1-A-0 status” (Moskos 61). This states that the person will go into a noncombatant position. The second category includes people who refuse to join any military branch. These people are against the military in general and will not participate in the service. These objectors are given a “1-0 status” (Moskos 61). Thirdly are those objectors who refuse to be drafted in any way, including community service. These people do not have a certain claim status. These people are the most difficult to deal with because they are not willing to serve the country in which they live. It is not fair for conscientious objectors to be able to avoid the draft. Every person who lives in this country has certain rights and freedoms that they are entitled to because they live in this country. People who live here believe in freedom and expect to have their specific freedoms. These freedoms, referenced in the Constitution, include freedom of speech, press, the right to bear arms, the right to a trial by jury, protection from cruel and unusual punishment. As a person living in the United State of America one is automatically guaranteed these fundamental rights. To ensure these freedoms are not abolished by another country the military was formed. The military protects the country to keep everyone safe. It does not seem fair that people can avoid helping the military; yet, they still enjoy the freedoms of living in America. Some people only claim to be a conscientious objector to benefit themselves. Technically, this is not allowed; however, to apply to be a conscientious objector the process is very simple. All that a person must do is interview with the local board. He must provide written proof about how he arrived at his beliefs and how these beliefs influence his life. If
Show More

Related Documents: Conscription and Conscientious Objectors Essay

Essay on H General Information On A British Tommy 1

British Tommy Vs Alternative conscientious objector This booklet will be comparing the lives of two characters from the First World War. My two characters are, Private Stephen Brown (British Tommy) and Mark Hayler, who is a conscientious objector. There will be a lot of primary and secondary data on both character’s lives, these will help me determine which of the characters I would rather be. The secondary information will give us a bigger idea of what life was like in the trenches, and from this…

Words 4396 - Pages 18

History: Cold War and Truman Doctrine Essay example

Cold war The cold war was the geo-strategic, economic, and ideological struggle between the world’s super powers; the Soviet Union and the USA by their respective and emerging alliance partners. 1947-1991 * Propaganda attacks * Economic issues policies of non-cooperation * Shifting power between super powers * Raw materials to advance societies * Yalta, Potsdam, iron curtain, Truman doe, Marshall plan, coniform, berlin blockade, hate, Korea, Vietnam, warzones, berlin wall,…

Words 517 - Pages 3

The Us Draft Essays

While the United States Constitution does not officially mention the word 'Draft” or even an older term with the same meaning “Conscription.” Congress has the right to institute a draft if the need arises. The draft is administered by the US Selective Service System. In the event that there is not enough volunteers to staff the military, the draft can be re-instated. My views on the draft are ones of disagreement. Military service should be left up to each citizen, and it is unconstitutional for…

Words 561 - Pages 3

The Great War Essay examples

population at home - the basics People in Britain were affected by six main ways: Recruitment - there was a huge poster campaign to get people to join up, and the government had to introduce conscription [Conscription: Compulsory enrolment in the armed forces. ] in 1916. Conscientious objectors [Conscientious objectors: People who refused to fight in the two world wars, because of strong personal beliefs against war. ] could be imprisoned. Women were recruited into the armed forces as nurses, drivers,…

Words 403 - Pages 2

Canadian Conscription of 1917 Essay

A LETTER TO MY BROTHER: MY THOUGHTS ON THE CANADIAN CONSCRIPTION OF 1917 Dear brother, Dad told me you have recently been conscripted and ordered to report for military service. I suppose the persuasiveness of the drafting posters and how important it is for us “to stand shoulder to shoulder with Britain” as Prime Minister Borden so clearly stated seemed to leave no room for alternative measures. While I am completely against you reporting for service, there are negative consequences…

Words 1167 - Pages 5

Nic Clarke's Unwanted Warriors

B. Curry’s religion was not a well-recognized religion in Canada and as a result, he was sentenced to two years less one day at the Burwash Prison Farm. Similar to the men rejected from military service that Clarke describes in his book, these objectors are also men who appear to be able to fight but do not. Arguably, their stories are just as important to the historical account of Canada’s role in the war. Clarke’s historical account would have benefited from him challenging the standard historical…

Words 1644 - Pages 7

Essay on World War I and Military Voters Act

depressed economy. Among French Canadians recruiting was much less effective, due in no small part to ham fisted direction by Sam Hughes who had a long history of fanning anti-French, anti-Catholic sentiments for political gain.[1] Opposition to conscription did not mean opposition to the war. In the February 1917, there had been a very successful campaign by the Patriotic Fund in Quebec to donate one day’s pay. Both Le Devoir and La Presse had donated space to support the campaign in the spirit…

Words 651 - Pages 3

Military Draft Essay

Many draft victims filed for the status of Conscientious Objector, a person opposing to serve in the armed forces. “While others facing the draft fled to Canada, others burned their draft cards in protest to both the war and the draft” (Jahnkow 1). Conscription supporters have said in the past that the Selective Service System has “favored privileged youths” (Jahnkow 1) and therefore did not trigger…

Words 777 - Pages 4

Australia in the Vietnam War era Essay

Topic 5 – Australia in the Vietnam Era Responses to communism: How did Australia respond to the threat of communism after World War II? (Syllabus Question) Australia’s response to the threat of communism in Asia after WWII included: Korean War ANZUS Treaty (1951) SEATO Alliance (1954) Australia’s response to the threat of communism within Australia included: Referendum to ban Communist Party Petrov Affair The background to communism after 1945: After WWII, a new conflict arose called the Cold War:…

Words 2216 - Pages 9

Conscientious Objector and Men Essay

people to volunteer for the war as it would make men feel patriotic and feel the need to serve their country. However this poster clearly didn't encourage enough men as in 1916 January conscription was introduced, where single men aged 18-41 had to join the war, and if they didn't they were called conscientious objectors. 4) Source E shows a cartoon of a man pushing munitions shells who states, "Well I'm not taking a holiday myself just yet". This tells us that he is clearly enjoying his work, and…

Words 469 - Pages 2