Common Patterns Of Illogical And Fallacious Thinking

Submitted By feterschuyler
Words: 1195
Pages: 5
Open Document
1. THE ART OF CRITICAL THINKING
We all engage in reasoning everyday. We engage in reasoning whenever we argue with each other, evaluate what we read and hear, and consider the evidence for and against views or ideas. So it is not something that’s foreign or alien. But reasoning is something that you can get better at doing. It is a skill or an art. Like any skill, it requires a bit of knowledge and practice. Lots and lots of practice.
Our aim in this course is to teach you the fundamentals of good reasoning. We will illustrate these fundamentals by looking at reasoning from newspapers, journals, advertisements, textbooks, and some philosophical works. By the end of the course you will know the difference between good reasoning and bad reasoning. You will be able to detect fallacies and bad reasoning in others. You will become more clear-headed and logical in your own thinking. The skills you acquire through doing this course will stand you in good stead whatever course you take at Macquarie and whatever career your pursue afterwards.
Even though reasoning is something we all do, it can be quite difficult at times to do correctly. We are all prone to making mistakes in reasoning. Indeed, there is an entire branch of psychology which is dedicated to examining the common patterns of illogical and fallacious thinking. To illustrate the difficulty of correct reasoning I want to consider two reasoning tasks that have been much discussed by psychologists. The two tasks show how easy it is to fall into the traps of fallacious reasoning.
2. EXERCISES IN CRITICAL THINKING
The card selection task
You are presented with four cards as below. One half of each card is masked. The other half is blank or has a circle. Your job is to work out which of the masked cards you need to see in order to answer the follow question decisively:
FOR THESE CARDS, IS IT TRUE THAT IF THERE IS A CIRCLE ON THE LEFT THERE IS A
Blackboard Learning System 2/03/09 2:35 PM http://learn.mq.edu.au/webct/cobaltMainFrame.dowebct Page 2 of 129
CIRCLE ON THE RIGHT?
You have only one opportunity to make this decision. You must not assume that you can inspect the cards one at a time. Name those cards which it is absolutely essential to see -- ie that you absolutely must see to answer the question.
Before you read any further, pause to consider what you think is the right answer.
What do most people say?
The most common answer is that you should see cards (a) and (c); the next most common answer is that you need only see (a).
The correct answer:
The correct answer is: you must see (a) and (d). Let’s consider each card in turn.
You must see (a) because if the right-hand side of (a) has no circle, the conditional is shown to be false.
You need not see (b) because it has no circle on the left-land side and so whatever is hidden on the right-hand side has no bearing on the truth of the conditional.
You need not see (c) because what is hidden on the left-hand side does not bear decisively on the truth of the conditional, does not have the potential to decisively show the truth or falsity of the conditional.
You must see (d) because if the left-hand side of (d) has a circle, the conditional is shown to be false.
The original experiment by the British psychologist Peter Wason is described in the article:
Wason, P. C. (1968). Reasoning about a rule. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 20,
273-281.
For a good review of the theoretical psychological discussions see:
Oaksford, M., & Chater, N. (1994). A rational analysis of the selection task as optimal data selection.
Psychological Review, 101, 608-631.
Blackboard Learning System 2/03/09 2:35 PM http://learn.mq.edu.au/webct/cobaltMainFrame.dowebct Page 3 of 129
The Monty Hall problem
This problem is named after the presenter on the American TV show Let’s Make a Deal.
On the table are three identical boxes, each with a lid and also a neat pile of ten dollar bills. This
Show More

Related Documents: Common Patterns Of Illogical And Fallacious Thinking

critical thinking Essay

Class: Philosophy 150 Date: 04- Nov - 2013 Critical thinking “the systematic evaluation or formulation of beliefs, or statements, by rational standards”. This statements can be view and discuss in numerous dimensions. Critical thinking is the ability to think clearly and rationaly. It is not a matter of accumulating information. A person with a good memory and who knows a lot of fact is not necessay good at critical thinking. A critical thinker is able to bring out consequences from what…

Words 661 - Pages 3

critical thinking Essay

sources to teach critical thinking skills in world literature: “Critical thinking, as defined by the Foundation for Critical Thinking, is the intellectually disciplined process of actively and skill fully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and/or evaluating information gathered from, or generated by, observation, experience, re flection, reasoning, or communication, as a guide to belief and action.” According to the Army Handbook for Self Development: "Critical thinking involves questioning…

Words 488 - Pages 2

What Is Critical Thinking?

What is critical thinking? Critical thinking has various definitions according to different academic societies and educational institutes internationally. Despite the varies definitions its importance is something that is understood throughout educational institutes, this is evident though the number of published articles that have been published by Universities around the world. One quotes from The Critical Thinking Community, critical thinking… the awakening of intellect to the study its self.…

Words 673 - Pages 3

Critical Thinking Essay

Critical Thinking Steven L. Barker Jr. Gen 200 11/03/14 Nichol Garrison Critical Thinking Although the term, ‘Critical Thinking’ is in widespread use today, it wasn’t a popular term until relatively recently. Critical thinking became a hot topic over the last decade because of concerns that were expressed by international educators, business leaders, and other organizations. They were concerned that students weren’t being prepared for real life in the 21st century. This spurred education leaders…

Words 629 - Pages 3

What Is Critical Thinking

Critical thinking can be defined as the process an individual takes that includes thinking in a logical and sensible manner in order to make a rational decision. Critical thinking also requires an individual to think past their normal capacity or “outside of the box” while improving the quality of thought. “The thinker improves the quality of his or her thinking by skillfully taking charge of the structures inherent in thinking and imposing intellectual standards…

Words 317 - Pages 2

Essay Critical Thinking

Critical Thinking Catherine Brinner April 9, 2012 Abstract The challenge for critical thinking instruction lies not in convincing people of its value but in developing a model of what to teach and how to teach it. Toulmin's model provides a useful framework for students to examine the ability of an argument to justify rather than prove a point. Utilizing this model can make critical thinking the very means by which students construct knowledge. Critical Thinking Debating, questioning, analyzing…

Words 1185 - Pages 5

Define Critical Thinking

clear understanding of what is meant by "critical thinking," why are employers making these comments? I believe that employers are making these comments because often people lack of "superior critical thinking and problem solving skills” also if they come from an undergraduate and graduate programs. I mean, having done high school or university doesn’t mean necessarily that a person owns a proper critical thinking. I understood that a critical thinking is a skill that must be develop with the…

Words 607 - Pages 3

Critical Thinking Assessment

is critical thinking. Traditionally, critical thinking was defined and related to the philosophical practices of formal logic and reasoning (Dauer, 1989). However, this definition has evolved to include other concepts such as problem solving and learning new information (Lipman, 1988), as well as, reflection (Facione, 2000). Research associated with the Critical-thinking Assessment Test has helped faculty across the country identify a set of skills that they feel best define critical thinking (Stein…

Words 1289 - Pages 6

Critical Thinking Paper

Critical Thinking Application Paper Tabatha White MGT/350 November 19, 2012 Kevin McPhee The purpose of this paper is to describe critical thinking. By doing this critical Thinking must first be defined. According to Wikipedia…

Words 797 - Pages 4

Critical Thinking Essay

What is Critical Thinking? Aaron Moore Axia College of University of Phoenix . What is Critical Thinking? Does every need to think critically? Yes! If everyone just made assumptions on how they could do things, the world would be in chaos. Critical thinking is what helps everyone in his or her day-to-day decisions. No matter how big or small the decision everyone thinks critically. Critical thinking is basically making…

Words 318 - Pages 2