Diagnostic Decision Support Systems:
Why Aren’t They Used More And What Can We Do About It?
Eta S. Berner, EdD, Department of Health Services Administration
University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL
Clinical decision support systems have been promoted as one of the key features of electronic health records most likely to lead to a real transformation in our healthcare system. A major concern, however, is that often these systems are underutilized. Decision support features are often not used and clinicians frequently ignore, override, or fail to seek out suggestions that could improve care.
This underutilization may be even more true for diagnostic decision support systems (DDSS), which were some of the earliest examples of medical informatics innovations.
This presentation will explore some of the reasons behind the lack of utilization and will offer design and implementation suggestions to improve the use of systems. It will focus on the aspects of the technology, the users, and the current healthcare environment that lead to less than optimal use of DDSS, despite evidence that diagnostic errors represent a significant source of medical errors and adverse events.
There have been a variety of DDSS that focus on specific problem areas, some of which utilize artificial intelligence approaches and others use statistical pattern recognition models. However, this presentation will focus primarily on the broad-based systems designed to address a variety of diseases in
Internal Medicine and Pediatrics.
DDSS on improving users’ diagnostic and work-up decisions3-5. The remainder of the discussion will include an examination of those features of (1) DDSS design and implementation, (2) the current healthcare system and, (3) DDSS users that together lead to an underappreciation of the extent of diagnostic errors, failure to recognize the role that DDSS can have in healthcare, and lack of use of system suggestions.
Specific aspects of DDSS that are addressed include the need for users to select relevant patient data, enter it into the DDSS (usually by means of a controlled vocabulary), and review what is often a lengthy list of diagnostic suggestions. The challenges for proper utilization that result from these and other design features will be examined. In addition, we will review aspects of the healthcare system that make appropriate use of DDSS a challenge. These include its fragmentation, time pressures, lack of electronic capture of patient outcomes, and reimbursement mechanisms. Finally, characteristics of clinicians that impact DDSS use will be discussed.
The presentation will conclude with suggestions for the role that medical informaticians can play in strategies for effective design and implementation of
DDSS and other applications to improve diagnostic decision making.
As background to the discussion of DDSS, the presentation will begin with an overview of the extent and impact of diagnostic errors, followed by what is known about diagnostic decision making 1. It will draw on a variety of literature from psychology, as well as research in medical education and medical decision making. This literature will include efforts to teach and assess physician problem solving, as well as efforts to improve decision making.
This discussion will be followed by a description of the functions of DDSS and a brief history of DDSS development and evaluation2. Examples will be drawn from several DDSS, some of which are currently commercially available today.
The
discussion will also include a description of results of studies that specifically examined the effectiveness of
AMIA 2006 Symposium Proceedings Page - 1167
References
Biosketch
1.
Graber ML. Diagnostic Error in Medicine: A
Case of Neglect. Joint Commission Journal on
Safety and Quality Improvement 2004;31:112-9.
2.
Miller RA and Geissbuhler AG. Diagnostic
Decision Support
