Descartes 'Dream Argument'

Words: 1034
Pages: 5
Open Document
Descartes started an argument called the Dream Argument, in which he believes that we shouldn’t trust our senses completely and that our senses are capable of blurring the lines between reality (awake) and dreaming (asleep). Descartes didn’t rely on his sense of perception but rather he held the belief that true knowledge comes through reason. When he put his argument forward, G.E. Moore created his defense against the Dream Argument. and stated that “the senses should be trusted completely and that some things cannot be explained”. The things that were not able to be explained would be explained as common sense. Most often, that is not the case and reasoning should justify certain knowledge since senses are often warped by illusions or impaired. …show more content…
Descartes states that he doesn’t know when he isn’t dreaming because his dreams have deceived him previously, but Moore argues that for one to know that they have been deceived they must’ve trusted their senses. This is where Descartes argument becomes inconsistent/self-defeating because one point he says is that he never knows when he is dreaming but on the other point he says he has been deceived in dreams”. Moore wants to understand: how can Descartes know he has been falsified? This means that Descartes acknowledges his senses, and that's how he knew he was awake and that whatever he saw was in his …show more content…
Descartes, and other philosophers who hold a similar mindset believe that our sense are inaccurate and we can only obtain true knowledge through logic. On the other hand, there are philosophers who don’t see the seriousness of it and brush it off as common sense. Such a person was Moore, who believed that we know a lot of things, but many of those things simply cannot be explained and it's due to common sense. He created two oppositions, “Flipping over the argument and the other considering Descartes as inconsistent”. Both these oppositions point towards Descartes claim of how he specifically knows the fine line between fake and real, what made him believe the dream was actually a dream and when did he know he was he awake. Although senses might seem accurate they can be distorted, and for this reason, we need to understand certainty by the use of
Show More

Related Documents: Descartes 'Dream Argument'

Descartes Dream Argument Analysis

popular of them is Descartes. He thought we can often be fooled by our senses and they are not to be trusted. According to Descartes, all we can put faith in is the natural light of reason since our senses can be fooled. He uses a couple of examples to make his point in his meditations. I will look at a few of them and give my personal thoughts on his arguments. The Descartes dream argument is a renowned argument he uses to prove that our senses can be fooled. He claims that in a dream one can sit by…

Words 1289 - Pages 6

Descartes 'Skepticism In Sextus Empiricus'

senses have deceived him on some occasions. Thus, Descartes conjectures that we cannot be certain of knowledge that is based upon the testimony of our…

Words 1920 - Pages 8

Mind and Descartes Essay

Rene Descartes: Meditation 1 an d2 1. Identify the author’s essay thesis, i.e. the position the author supports on the topic. Descartes begins to question and place doubt on all the beliefs that come to us from senses. He basically questions is it knowledge and if so what makes it different from opinion. 2. Identify the position against which the essay’s author argues. Descartes uses three very similar arguments to open all our knowledge to doubt: The dream argument, the deceiving…

Words 635 - Pages 3

Essay about Descartes Senses

communicate with the world outside us and even inside our bodies. Descartes in his “Meditations” just pretends that he does not trust his senses to get a new insight in his mind, to make a switch in his custom form of thinking, to look at the world from the new perspective. Even though Descartes says he rejects everything he knew before, he conveniently retains memories of Classical and Medieval philosophy, which he periodically refers to. Descartes thinks he accumulated a lot of questionable and dubious…

Words 1226 - Pages 5

Philosophy: Descartes Essay

Descartes Paper Dualism is defined as the division of something conceptually into two opposed or contrasted aspects. (Oxford Dictionary) It is a theory or system of thought that regards a domain of reality in terms of two independent principles. Descartes differentiates the mind and the body as distinct from one another. The mind does not extend in space and the body cannot think. Res extensa refers to extended things such as the body and res cogitans refers to mental substances such as the mind…

Words 1558 - Pages 7

Philosophy: Logic and Radical Philosophers Essay examples

which presents arguments in a much more logical and reasonable way. Descartes tries to say he must doubt all of his beliefs based on the fact that he cannot trust his senses because he might be sleeping and is being deceived into thinking he is awake. He is skeptical of his senses in this dreaming argument because he is a human and humans sleep and that there are situations that “there exist no certain marks by which the state of waking can ever be distinguished from sleep” (Descartes, #). He also…

Words 1088 - Pages 5

Skepticism Arguments

Even if most of our beliefs happen to be true, but there still is no way of knowing any of them. The Skeptic is not claiming that its unreasonable to believe most of the things that we believe in. One of the great skepticism arguments is The Possibility of Error Argument: 1) If S knows that p, then there is no possibility that S could have been wrong about p 2) For any belief that p, there is always at least a remote possibility that S could have been wrong about p (even if it is the cause…

Words 718 - Pages 3

Rene Descartes Meditation 2

Kraft Descartes’ Meditation II René Descartes wrote the Meditation II, along with the other five, during the 1640s. The Meditation II talks about the nature of the human body and functions of the brain but begins with the explanation of how strong doubts exist in Meditation I (Descartes 1). The difference of what actually appears and what is perceived to be there are the two main topics examined. (Descartes 1-16). The Meditation II is very tricky, but clever at the same time. Descartes writes…

Words 725 - Pages 3

Paper 2

Haley Berlett The Method of Doubt The method of doubt was created by Descartes to find out what was absolutely true, and what he could prove with certainty. According to Lex Newman, the author of "Descartes Epistemology", published in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, he brings in a quote of Descartes' which explains why his method of doubt works cooperatively with foundationalism. "Throughout my writings I have made it clear that my method imitates that of the architect. When an architect…

Words 977 - Pages 4

Mark: René Descartes and Real World Essay

(C) Descartes’ Cosmological Argument There are two main steps in Descartes’ version of the cosmological argument: firstly, a proof that we possess the idea of God, and secondly, that the cause of that idea can only be God himself. (a) The Idea of God In the Third Meditation, Descartes considers his ideas, and finds that all of them, except the idea of God, cannot come from without. His idea of God is of an all-perfect being and he can be sure of this because he knows that he himself is imperfect…

Words 1291 - Pages 6