Effects Of Democracy In Antigone

Submitted By FrankGD
Words: 1537
Pages: 7
Open Document
EPICENTER OF THE EARTHQUAKE: A PAPER ON THE EFFECTS OF CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE ON CITIZEN-STATE RELATIONSHIP IN SOPHOCLES’ ANTIGONE

BY

OKOYE GOSIFE DONALD

FOR

HISTORY 100: CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE FROM ANCIENT GREECE TO MODERN AFRICA

SUBMITTED ON TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 5TH, 2013

PLEDGED:

Democracy is defined as “That form of government in which the sovereign power resides in and is exercised by the whole body of free citizens directly or indirectly through a system of representation.” (Black's Law Dictionary, Fifth Edition.) However, the idea of democracy as far back as before 300 B.C would have had different implications, and as such, it would be rather unfair to judge people from that era with our current notion of what constitutes democracy. Therefore, it would stand to reason to consider the government run in Sophocles’ Antigone in terms of the system of government that Sophocles was born into and in which he grew up. The Athenian government was based on aristocracy; a government ruled supremely by the state with little or no contributions by the citizens. Citizens had their own opinions but the law was absolute and the law was decided upon by the reigning monarch. Needless to say, citizens can only be controlled absolutely for so long before they revolt. These revolutions came in form of public mass demonstrations that were based mainly on the principle of strength in numbers, and this is considered civil disobedience. Compare this crowd mentality to Antigone’s singular decision to swim against the tide alone and bear the consequences and one is left with a concept that transcends civil disobedience. One comes to the conclusion that Antigone’s actions are not borne simply out of a desire to justify her political and moral inclinations, her actions rather have far reaching implications that completely revolutionizes the relationship between the state and her citizens.

The Athenian state was a powerful one, and one that continued to propagate and impose its laws upon its colonists. Consider the way that Athens had moved to threaten the Melians into submission, and one would come to the conclusion that had the Spartans not defeated Athens, they would have continued to overpower the world and no one could stop them. Little wonder why the Melians were reluctant to subject themselves to the control of the Athenians without putting up some form of resistance. This conclusion would lead to an even direr one; injustice would propagate as long as it remains unopposed. Kreon had his own idea of what justice should be, but unfortunately his misguided definition of justice brought the entire kingdom to the brink of destruction. Kreon’s injustice needed to be stopped before it got out of hand, and Antigone unflinchingly stepped into the role of the knight. Antigone went against Kreon’s decrees and buried her dead brother knowing fully well that she would die for it. Antigone without directly mentioning it implies that the citizen, though bound by honor to dwell within the laws, is equally bound by the higher power of conscience to follow the dictates of one’s conscience. This calls to mind Henry Thoreau’s stance in ‘On the Duty of Civil Disobedience’ that “When a person’s conscience and the laws clash, he or she must follow his or her conscience.” Antigone followed her conscience and proved that the citizen-state relationship is not akin to that of a slave and his master as the Athenians had made it out to be when they tried to intimidate the Melians during the Peloponnesian wars.

Besides, Antigone did not do something that the rest of the citizens did not think was right. In fact, when she retorts to Kreon’s accusation that “You (Antigone) are the only citizen who holds that view,” by pointing out that “They (the citizens) keep quiet to please you (Kreon),” she was absolutely right. The citizens had their opinions but were too scared of authority to confront it. The sycophantic chorus knew the right paths to follow but
Show More

Related Documents: Effects Of Democracy In Antigone

Jervis Role In Crafting Credibility

that both autocracies and democracies place different values on the importance of credibility. For a democracy the support of the opposition and the public is linked to its credibility through audience costs, which can cushion the blow to the leaders credibility if they back down in a crisis. Autocratic states have the advantage of limited audience costs if they choose to back down, which makes losing credibility less of an issue in an international crisis, but does mean that autocracies struggle…

Words 1572 - Pages 7

Dictatorship In George Orwell's Animal Farm

the moderate amassing of force, which means there is an orderly movement. Prior to the ascent of tyranny, the right to speak freely and expression exist among the creatures however since another type of government built up which for this situation autocracy, the animals are no more ready to appreciate the things they had some time recently. Distinctive social stratification are influenced in view of fascism, Boxer who takes after Animalism reliably and lives by Napoleon's request. From this character…

Words 380 - Pages 2

World War I and Rasputin’s…prostitute Gregubova Essay

more important factors such as World War One, which impacted on Russia’s social and economic environment thus heightening the resentment of the public towards the government. Moreover, the war acted as a catalyst towards the long term weaknesses of autocracy highlighting its anachronistic nature in the process. The significance of Rasputin lies in the fact that his personal life served to discredit the Tsar although his role in Nicholas II’s fall has been exaggerated. It can be argued that Rasputin…

Words 550 - Pages 3

Why was Nicholas the II Forced to Abdicate? Essay

the abdication of Tsar Nicholas II and the end of 300 years of Romanov rule and centuries of a Tsarist regime ruling Russia. The reasons why Nicholas II was forced to abdicate can be explained in terms of beliefs, such as Nicholas II belief in autocracy, circumstances, such as world war one, and actions, such as Nicholas’ decision to take direct control of the armed forces. In this essay I will be arguing that circumstances were the most important factor in causing the Tsar to abdicate. World war…

Words 1449 - Pages 6

1905 Bloody Sunday Essay

irreconcilable attitudes.” To first understand this statement we must look at the political system the recent Tsars of Russia had adopted. Russia was run as an autocracy. Nicholas II who was in power during the revolution very much embraced this system. He, like his father, wanted Russia to follow the principles of ‘nationality, autocracy and orthodoxy.’ To bring Russia to follow this model, many areas of government where reforms had been previously made, were rolled back to bring back the old style…

Words 1087 - Pages 5

Princess Dashkova Essay

Cassidy To Squeeze a Lemon Dry: How Princess Dashkova’s Memoir Reveals Common Themes Among Russia’s History Princess Ekaterina Dashkova was an intelligent, impressive woman who, at 18 years old (an age when many modern teenagers are still living at home with their parents), helped to stage a coup d’ etat for Catherine Alexeyvna, who was destined to become Catherine the Great.1 Ekaterina was actually called Catherine the Little2, because both women held the same saint namesake and both were considered…

Words 1836 - Pages 8

Ivan The Terrible Research Paper

Ivan the terrible came to the throne at age 3 and was crowned Tsar at age 16. Ivan’s reign represented the end of princely power and the beginning of autocracy in Russia. The early part of his reign was relatively peaceful. Ivan made reforms and modernizations. He established a law code, created an army, and established a council of nobles. During this period he introduced the first laws regulating the freedom of the peasants. These laws would eventually lead to serfdom in Russia. Some of the russian…

Words 287 - Pages 2

The Russian Land Midterm ID Study Guide Essay

depend on herding for survival. The Mongols were the only people that could pass through the steppe by using horses. The steppe was seen as a land of death. *Slash and Burn Farming­ The method of farming used in Kievan Rus era and before, this is where the forest is cut down then burned to create a layer of fertile top soil to farm on. It is important because this is an incredibly unsustainable source of farming, but also lead to little groups that would create a hamlet together and work the land until it was no longer fertile…

Words 2069 - Pages 9

Essay about Is Chain-Ganging Caused the World War One?

104-105; Levy 2002). The phenomenon of chain ganging is linked to the realist idea of the balance of power, which is the “…mechanism that operates to prevent one state from achieving such a preponderance of power that it is in a position to lay down and enforce the law over all others” (Devetak 2012: 487). When examining the outbreak of the First World War, the concept of the balance of power and therefore the theory of chain ganging, is quite prominent, however it is a widely debated topic (Tierney…

Words 1998 - Pages 8

Essay about Nationalism: French Revolution and Powerful Royal Tradition

Nationalism was formed with the idea that a nation is made up of people who are joined together by common language, customs, cultures and history. It held the belief that one should be loyal to the people of their nation, not a king or empire. Nationalists believed that people of a single nationality should unite under a single government. The concept of Nationalism emerged in the French Revolution and was spread to the rest of Europe by Napoleon’s conquests.The Congress of Vienna was convened (gathered)…

Words 564 - Pages 3