Dred Scott Vs Sanford Case Study

Words: 339
Pages: 2
Open Document
I disagree with the holding in the case of Dred Scott v Sanford for three reasons. One reason being that because of Chief Justice Taney's failure to recognize the rights of the people to be free , his decision was unjust. Chief Justice Taney decision was morally wrong under federalism which gives every state it own legal system. therefore , CJ Taney was disobeying a state law under the full faith and Credit a clause which states that slaves including Dred Scott were citizens of Illinois , due to the states law's entitling them to all privileges and Immunities right under Article IV, Section 2. The second reason is asserted under article 1 , Section 9 of the constitution , which claimed powers forbidden to congress, in Paragraph 1 "the
Show More

Related Documents: Dred Scott Vs Sanford Case Study

Dred Scott Vs Sanford Case Study

The court wanted to make sure that former slaves were barred from the rights given to citizens. The Dred Scott vs Sanford court case ruling is the most important court decision in U.S. history because it disregarded the Missouri Compromise and increased tension between abolitionists in the North and slaveowners in the South eventually leading to the Civil War.…

Words 59 - Pages 1

African Americans in America Essay example

African Americans in America: The Fight Name HIS204: American History Since 1865 Dr. Kirk Strawbridge 30 Sep 13 African Americans have struggled with freedom before America was even a country. Freedom is something that Americans today take for granted. We look at third world countries that continue to exercise discrimination and segregation and America looks down on them. American’s fight wars to protect those discriminated against in other countries. We are almost numb to the…

Words 2143 - Pages 9