The Ellen Jamesians purposely cut their tongues out to protest and to support Ellen, although both Ellen nor Garp understood it many people thought it was a sweet thing. I do think she was right to publish her opinion, how else was she going to get her opinion out there? She couldn’t speak her mind, literally. Ellen deserved to be heard finally after so many years of holding it in. It might of made several people (probably more) upset but Ellen needed to be heard just as much as the Ellen Jamesian’s thought they needed to be