John Locke Innate Ideas

Submitted By barckless
Words: 2030
Pages: 9
Open Document
Evaluate the application of Locke’s critique of innate ideas with explicit reference to Descartes

The debate surrounding innate ideas is not a recent controversy in philosophy as opinions have been known to differ on whether the mind is born with innate knowledge, or whether knowledge is learned. Seventeenth century philosophers John Locke and Rene Descartes held conflicting views on the topic of innatism, with Locke arguing against the idea and Descartes supporting it. This essay will explore Locke’s main criticisms which include the argument of general consent, the argument from the use of reason and the argument concerning implicit knowledge, all of which will be compared to Descartes’ views. I will focus on the primary texts of Locke’s ‘An Essay Concerning Human Understanding’ (1996) and Descartes’ ‘Meditations of First Philosophy’ (1993), whilst making reference to other sources. I will evaluate both of the philosopher’s views to show that both theories have flaws. For example, Descartes’ requirement to believe in God and Locke’s heavy focus on empiricism, despite the problem of regularity. Due to this, I will conclude that whilst neither argument is fully convincing with their views on innate ideas, Descartes’ case is more convincing as the theory of having innate ideas is possible. Whilst Locke believes that God has created us for a certain purpose, he rejects the idea that theoretical nor ethical knowledge has been imprinted upon our minds from the outset. Taking an empiricist role, Locke describes this by imagining the mind as a blank slate, or tabula rasa, where man has no previous knowledge and all must be acquired through senses and experience. He sets out to use the “historical, plain method” (Locke, 1996, 316b) in order to discover “the original, certainty, and extent of human knowledge, together with the grounds and degrees of belief, opinion and assent.” (Locke, 1996, 316a) Descartes expresses an opposing view to Locke. The notion that certain ideas are inborn labels him as a rationalist and dates back to Plato’s writings. In his epistemological writings in the Meditations, Descartes attempts to discover what knowledge can be acquired. A key concept of Descartes’ philosophy is the cogito ergo sum, I am thinking therefore I exist. He uses this to support innate ideas as it is impossible to doubt one’s own existence and any thought in the mind is proof that one exists. The origins of the concepts brought up can be traced back to one’s nature, as Descartes’ claims that his “understanding of what a thing is, what truth is, and what thought is, seems to derive simply from my own nature.” (Descartes, 1993, pp. 37-8) Locke’s critique of innate ideas begins with the argument that there are no universal principles that mankind have collectively agreed upon. This is in response to the supporting premise that there are speculative and practical principles which are universally agreed upon from birth. Locke argues that in order for innate ideas to be factual, they must exist in the mind of every person. Since this is not the case, the concept of innate ideas has no logical grounds to be true. For example, a fundamental principle would be to refrain from telling lies, however there is no general agreement as some people feel comfortable in doing so. In addition, children do not recognise that they have to tell the truth, it is taught and experienced. This is discussed further in Locke’s writings in Book 1 of An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1996). Locke argues his case using two examples of proposals where universal consent could be applied: “What is, is” and “it is impossible for the same thing to be and not to be.” He supports this with the claim that “it is evident, that all children and idiots have not the least apprehension or thought of them,” (Locke, 1996, I) implying that the previous concepts are not understood by everyone, therefore
Show More

Related Documents: John Locke Innate Ideas

Define Europe? How Do We Define Europe

factor that unifies European countries. It is difficult to define Europe in a simple geographical, economical, political, religious, linguistic or other cultural framework. Half of Russia is in Europe and half is in Asia. Europe is a subcontinent of Eurasia. Why are Europe and Asia separated? (Geologically there are 6 continents, but politically sometimes they are seen as 7) => has to do with culture and politics, not geology. Russia presents a problem in defining it as European or Asian. Christendom…

Words 308 - Pages 2

Cherokee Voices Essay

relationship with the Europeans and Americans, but established grounds for disagreement over trade practices, regional control, and the complicated loyalties among the various Indian tribes and European powers. Over the years, the Cherokees struggled to maintain their prehistoric traditions as the tribe was assimilated into the white man’s culture. The Cherokees adjusted to the arrival of Europeans and Americans by adapting new methods such as weaving, which the Europeans taught the Native Americans…

Words 678 - Pages 3

Essay about Ming Dynasty and Chinese Luxury Goods

Europeans began to explore the East because of greater wealth, spread of Christianity, and technology. In the 1400’s Europeans had developed a taste for Chinese luxury goods. The Europeans liked the products but they hated having to pay the Muslim and Italian merchants. Their goal was to find a cheaper way to get Chinese luxury goods. Portuguese were the first to move East. Portuguese dominated the East. They were able to take control of more territory along the trade routes in Africa. They used…

Words 319 - Pages 2

The Iroquois And Huron Rivalry

and other Europeans within Indigenous affairs and the increased trade of goods between Europeans and other Indigenous nations changed the dynamics of war in the region. Even though the French historically weren’t involved in the beginnings of the Iroquois and Huron rivalry, but because they “posed a strategic threat” to the Mohawks and allied the Algonquins they got into the middle of it(JR 9). The Jesuit and French being a factor of diplomacy and traditions changed by continued European involvement…

Words 392 - Pages 2

Examples Of Assimilation Of Native Americans

arrival of European colonizers who viewed native Americans as bad people and thought their lives were inferior. With this, they wanted to assimilate native Americans into European society. One major aspect of assimilation they used was to establish boarding schools. This caused native Americans to replace their culture and replace it with European traditions and their culture. The children were taken from their families and forced to speak English, practice Christianity, and have European standards…

Words 241 - Pages 1

Black Political Theory Essays

Introduction: Inventing Traditions, to point out the so-called present traditions were selected, written, modified, ritualized, and institutionalized. Hobsbawn notes, “invented tradition is a set of practices, normally governed by overtly or tacitly accepted rules and of a ritual or symbolic nature, which seek to inculcate certain values and norms of behavior by repetition, which automatically implies continuity with the past.”1 According to Hobsbawn these invented traditions which reintroduce superiority…

Words 1657 - Pages 7

Native Americans Essay examples

Native American Relations With Europeans “When European explorers arrived in America in 1492 they found around 2 million Native Americans living there. The Europeans mistakenly called them Indians, thinking they had landed in the Indies in the Far East of Asia. These 'Indians' belonged to at least 300 different tribes and spoke over 2,000 different languages. Famous examples of these tribes are: * The Cheyennethe * Blackfoot * The Comanchethe * Sioux Each tribe spoke a separate…

Words 316 - Pages 2

The Broken Spears: the Aztec Account of the Conquest of Mexico Essays

different texts written by many different indigenous people. Numerous texts are written in such a way that show the fear that the people experienced while having their towns overtaken, while other texts simply explain what was happening at the time. In Traditions and Encounters, a more factual approach is…

Words 1405 - Pages 6

After the Fact Essay

that the Europeans brought over diseases, which had a catastrophic effect on the Native American population, religious beliefs, different social structures and non- native plant and animal species, not to mention the destruction of entire civilizations. Before contact, according to several of the reading materials, there were many tribes that were constructed into nations among the people. Within these groupings they had several different languages and they had their own oral traditions and faith…

Words 504 - Pages 3

The Colonizer and the Colonized Essay

1783, other colonies of the Americas began to win their freedom from the European homeland. After much of the European presence had been lifted from the continents, Europe began to focus much of their imperial power on areas close to home, their southern neighbors in Africa. Much of the same methods that governed rule in the new world were used: it was to convert those who they had been trading with for centuries to European philosophies on religion and government and to plunder their lands of natural…

Words 1899 - Pages 8