Financial Crisis and Stock Market Crash Essay

Submitted By jgallop
Words: 3003
Pages: 13
Open Document
John Gallop EH101 13/3/15 (Group 11 Franz Zobl)
Does historical experience suggest that financial crises are the result of weak economic fundamentals or self-fulfilling panics?
A financial crisis is ‘a disturbance to financial markets – associated with falling asset prices and insolvency, which spreads through the financial system, disrupting the market’s capacity to allocate capital.’1 Nearly all crises feature both weak fundamentals of some sort and a period of panic. If a fundamental becomes irreparably weak – that is to say a country has become insolvent - then a crisis is inevitable. However a panic is a symptom not a cause of crisis and arises as a result of an external trigger. Accordingly, crises are a result of weak fundamentals, which I will show by reference to several historical experiences.
The process of a crisis2
A crisis usually has a benign beginning and often starts following a welcome shock to the macro-economic system. For example the 1980’s Latin American (LA) debt crisis arose out of excess Western bank deposits post the ’73 oil price hike (petro-dollars) whilst the 1987 stock market crash was born out of the market liberalisation known as ‘big bang’ in 1986. This macroeconomic shock/change often fuels an expansion in credit and allows an economy to begin to over-heat. The first fundamental weakness comes when the regulatory system fails to moderate the economy allowing mania buying/lending/investing to develop during which other fundamentals weaken. Such was the case in the South East Asian (SEA) crisis of 1997. A sudden shift in risk perception might then occur to throw a particular fundamental weakness into sharp focus. In October 1987 the Iranians fired at ships in the Gulf and in September 2008 Lehman Brothers collapsed. Fundamentals had not changed but risk perceptions based on one or more of the fundamentals had altered and realisation of a problem dawned on lenders/investors - the Wile E Coyote moment3!
Wile E Coyote demonstrates ‘the moment!’
The international community then leaps into action, for example the IMF arranged interim lending to Mexico when it threatened default in 1981. However these actions can only succeed if the underlying fundamental weakness has fallen to a point where the debtor country remains solvent but illiquid.

The weakening fundamentals 4
Liberalisation, regulation and policy. Nearly all crises reveal a degree of failure in the area of financial liberalisation coupled with inadequate financial regulation and sometimes poor/ inconsistent policy decisions. The failure of the FSA and Bank of England to moderate mortgage lending prior to 2007/8 contributed to the banking crisis which emerged. I have already mentioned a similar failure of regulators in SEA in the years before 1997 and in that crisis regulators exacerbated matters by ‘flip-flopping’ – adopting inconsistent policies.
Rising Asset prices.

Sharp asset price rises highlight pride before a fall. Asset bubbles always burst and growth rates should be monitored.

Left: the 2007 house price bubble is clear, as is the rapid recovery by 2010.

Slowing GDP growth.

Left: The solid black line shows waning US GDP growth in the years before the ‘great recession’ took hold (2007 is ‘t’).

Rising current account deficit.

Left: The US deficit as a % of GDP increased 2003-6.
Increasing debt.

A sustained and exponential growth in domestic and/or international debt is a clear sign of a weakening fundamental, particularly if combined with any of the other factors in this list.
It is rare for all the fundamentals listed to show weakness prior to a crisis although Rogoff suggests that all the above were ‘blinking red’ prior to the Great Recession5.
Self-fulfilling panic
Financial panic occurs when international creditors suddenly change expectations and lose confidence. For example in an asset-bubble panic creates real losses whereas delaying sales might have allowed prices to return
Show More

Related Documents: Financial Crisis and Stock Market Crash Essay

Management Essay 2

increasingly development of internationalisation, global finance and business have been interlinked so strong that the consequences of the financial crisis have been more and more serious and widely spreading. Thus international business is very often affected and attacked under financial crisis. Two financial crisis Charles Kindleberger (2011) argued that financial crisis occurs periodically and regularly in the business cycle. It is then documented by Reinhart and Rogoff (2009) as a system of regular…

Words 2001 - Pages 9

A Brief Note On The Efficient Market Hypothesis

the stock returns fluctuations are explained by general movements in the market. 2) Based on the article and the findings, I would have to say that I do not agree with the Efficient Market Hypothesis. The theory states that the market is always correct and that all the markets info…

Words 347 - Pages 2

The Causes of the Great Depression Essay

Unit 8­ Ch. 30: The Causes of the Great Depression Ch. 30 Vocabulary­ 1) Black Tuesday ­ October 29, 1929; the worst day of plunging stock market prices during the stock market crash that helped initiate the Great Depression 2) Bear Market­ a period in which stock prices are steadily decreasing 3) Overproduction­ a situation in which more goods are being produced than people can afford to buy 4) …

Words 362 - Pages 2

Essay about Spanish Financial Crisis

Spanish financial crisis Introduction (source: Wikipedia) The 2008–2010 Spanish financial crisis is part of the world economic crisis of 2008. In Spain, the crisis was generated by long term loans (commonly issued for 40 years), the building market crash which included the bankruptcy of major companies, and a particularly severe increase in unemployment, which rose to 13.9% in February 2009. Spain continued the path of economic growth when the ruling party changed in 2004, keeping robust GDP…

Words 1064 - Pages 5

Essay on Woo: Financial Crisis Comparison

Financial Crisis Comparison 1929 vs. 2009 In the crisis of 1929 and 2009 a mass production is accompanied mass consumption which in turn implies a distribution of wealth, wealth that in non­existent but wealth that is currently being produced by the consumption. In 1929 the object being mass produced were stocks and in 2009 the housing and credit crisis. In both crisis’ the prices of the objects were greater than the actual value, so when individuals see that they go running to get the t…

Words 570 - Pages 3

Recession and the History Behind It Essay

Dates: August 1929 – Late 1930s –Early 1940s Peak Unemployment: 24.9% GDP decline: -26.7% The Wall Street Crash of 1929 is considered the main cause of the Great Depression. The initial crash occurred over several days with ‘Black Tuesday’ being the most devastating. On this day, the market lost $14 billion. The loss for the whole week was $30 billion. The Dow Jones market peaked at 381 on September 3, 1929 and bottomed out at 42 in 1932. This was an 89% decline. Other causes of the…

Words 1060 - Pages 5

Financial Crises, Slumps, Causes And Effects, History And Future

Issues in Management MSc International Business Financial Crises, slumps and booms, causes and effects, history and future Jihad Al Naddaf ID: 1258826 What are the causes of the booms and slumps in the financial system? What are the factors that will influence how long it is before the next cycle begins? INTRODUCTION: The global financial system had been through a lot of booms and slumps through history, some lasted for few years, some for decades; some had a minor effect, some had a…

Words 1996 - Pages 8

How The Great Depression Affected America

America was in despair. 13 million people had lost their jobs, the stock market’s had lost 25 billion dollars, and 60 percent of American’s were living in complete poverty. The Great Depression had officially begun. Of course, it wasn’t just Americans that were affected by this traumatic situation, but American’s were definitely affected the most by it. It’s inarguable. During this time period Americans were so hopeless that to survive many of them ate roadkill. The luckier of them drank depression…

Words 683 - Pages 3

Essay on Asian Currency

are similar in the sense that their actions affected the path of the markets and the economies. The decisions made where often wrong in both crises and the effect of these failed policies was escalation in bubbles and subsequent crash. The lessons that must be learnt to prevent such events from occurring in the future lie in the decisions made by each central bank in dictating policy for the markets. Prior to the Asian crash of 1997, the environment in Thailand in the 80’s and 90’s was one of strong…

Words 2356 - Pages 10

Explain And Differentiate Between The Great Depression Of 1929 And The Recession Of 2008

differences between the great depression of 1929 and the financial crisis of 2008. The paper identifies the causes of the Great Depression of 1929 and the financial crisis of 2008. It further looks at the government agencies relating to human resource that arose from the Great Depression. The Great Depression of 1929 The great depression is documented to have been one of the worst economic depressions in the history of the United States. It was a financial decay that started in 1929 and lasted well into…

Words 1441 - Pages 6