Fire and Brian Essay

Submitted By thebsbrown
Words: 599
Pages: 3
Open Document
How one answers that question may depend entirely on one’s own sense of morality. The fact that Sara and Brian used science to conceive Anna raises its own set of issues. Sara and Brian intervened in the natural process of pregnancy to choose the specific embryo they wanted to fertilize. They sought an embryo that matched Kate genetically, because they wanted to create a sibling for Kate who could serve as her donor. Although Brian argues in their television interview that he and Sara didn’t choose their baby’s eye color or IQ or any of the other traits that parents often select, they did use the same process involved in selecting those characteristics to choose a different set of characteristics. The ends may have been different, but the means were the same.
Perhaps more importantly, Sara and Brian deliberately created a child as a donor for their existing daughter, Kate. That act lead directly to Sara’s mindset in which she considered her new child not as an individual but essentially as a form of treatment for Kate. Just after Anna was born, Sara’s first words to the doctors were to be careful with the umbilical cord, which they needed for Kate, not to ask about her newborn. Brian says at one point that they intended Anna’s use as a donor to end with her birth, but clearly that didn’t happen. Throughout her life, Anna acted as Kate’s donor, and although her parents did love her and treat her as a person, to some degree her wishes always remained subordinate to Kate’s medical needs.

2. What is the significance of fire in the story?
Both Jesse and Brian have close relationships to fire. Brian, for instance, works as a firefighter, putting out fires and at times saving people from burning buildings. Jesse, we learn, began playing with matches young, possibly because he recognized that fire played a central role in Brian’s career, and he turns out to be the arsonist setting fires all over the city. For both of them, fire represents a destructive and ultimately uncontrollable force, and they often treat it as a symbol of Kate’s cancer. Jesse, because he feels powerless to stop Kate’s cancer, turns to using
Show More

Related Documents: Fire and Brian Essay

Why Did Brian Survive The Hatchet

wilderness for over 54 days? For Brian Robeson, this accident happened to him. This is the main premise, of Hatchet, by Gary Paulsen. Throughout the book, Brian learned many things that would help him survive. In the terms of “Signpost”, these moments were called “Aha Moments”. In this essay, I will be going over two of the biggest “Aha Moments”, that helped Brian survive the long 3 months that he was trapped in the Canadian Wilderness. In the eighth chapter, Brian figured out something very important…

Words 409 - Pages 2

Analysis Of Hatchet By Gary Paulsen

Hatchet by Gary Paulsen, is about a 13-year old boy named Brian Robeson who was on his way to see his dad when the plane he was on crashed. Brain was all alone in the Canadian wilderness, having to deal with the brightly burning sun, and he needed to teach himself some survival skills. The most important ones are finding food, making a fire, and making a shelter. By reading this, you might learn some survival skills of your own. Brian needed to find food to stay alive and well. When he woke up…

Words 486 - Pages 2

Hatchet By Gary Paulsen Summary

plane crash, the moose attack, and the first fire day. A boy named Brian was riding in a plane. The pilot had a heart attack, so Brian had to fly the plane by himself. Brian tried using the radio to call for help, but no one answered him. After a while, he crashed in a small lake and got stranded in a forest. Brian was just sitting down, minding his own business, when a moose charged at him. The moose pushed Brian under water and started fighting. Brian escaped and tried to fool the moose by pretending…

Words 310 - Pages 2

Hatchet By Gary Paulsen Character Analysis

exactly what happens to thirteen year old Brian Robeson when the plane he is flying in crashes due to the pilot’s sudden heart attack. Brian is isolated and stranded in the Canadian wilderness with nothing but a hatchet and himself. However, despite his limited resources, Brian manages to survive, and he is rescued after a grueling fifty four days. After carefully reflecting upon Brian’s situation and my own traits and attributes, I unfortunately believe, unlike Brian, I would not be able to survive this…

Words 647 - Pages 3

Brian Hatchet Research Paper

Brian could be a survivalist because he survived in the Canadian woods for 54 days. Brian caught fish for food, used his survival strategies and used his hatchet for making tools, fire, and cutting wood. Brian used trial and error to land the plane and to survive in the Canadian woods. How Brian used his hatchet. Brian used his hatchet to make tools, such as a bow and arrow, and to cut wood to make fires. He used it to cut into the plane and get all of the things he needed to survive. He also…

Words 361 - Pages 2

Essay on Thomas Pampalone Hatchet

written by Gary Paulsen. The publisher of Hatchet is Puffin Books, the copyright date is 1987. Hatchet begins off by, introducing the main character, a thirteen year old boy named Brian Robeson. Brian’s parents are divorced, and as the story begins he is on the plane to go spend the summer with his father in Canada. Brian is obviously upset about the divorce between his father and his mother and has a difficult time coping with his sadness that he holds back. Brian’s mother has sent him away with an…

Words 876 - Pages 4

Small Mistakes In Hatchet By Gary Paulsen

Small mistakes could lead to big disasters.” In the book Hatchet by Gary Paulsen, Brian Robeson, makes a lot of mistakes that could've changed his life. He is stranded alone in the northern woods of Canada after surviving a deadly plane crash. The theme of this book is “there is no growth without resistance.” An addition, this occurrence happens many times throughout the story. One way Brian is showing growth is when he had to land the airplane by himself. “When the plane ran out of gas, he…

Words 356 - Pages 2

Hatchet Analysis

Could you survive being stranded alone in the Canadian North?In the book Hatchet, written by Gary Paulsen, Brian has to survive in the rugged Canadian north. In the oil fields, it's a tough place to live, especially if you don't have the right skills, knowledge, and character to keep yourself alive.The boy defies all odds by conquering the numerous threats such as ferocious animals, extreme temperatures and lack of resources, thanks to his skills, character traits, and knowledge. I know that I too…

Words 740 - Pages 3

The Glass Castle Literary Analysis

burned. Jeanette was 3 years old and as she said she was often allowed to cook alone in the kitchen without her parents looking after. The kids were allowed to venture out on their own and often made many mistakes causing severe damage. Jeanette and Brian often played at the…

Words 338 - Pages 2

How Did The Hatchet Survive

same thing happened to the 13 year old Brian Robeson in the book Hatchet by: Gary Paulsen. He was left with only a hatchet to survive. He survived for a heart wrenching 54 days before being rescued. As I think about the skills it took for Brian to survive for that long. As I do this, I think sadly that I would not survive for as long and in the same conditions that Brian was in. The first reason I believe I would not survive in the wilderness like Brian because I can’t stand bugs and insects.…

Words 486 - Pages 2