Essay about French Veil

Submitted By fendyL
Words: 1277
Pages: 6
Open Document
Yifei Ling
Religion and Public Education in International Context
Paper 2
Headscarf issue in France
October 1989, three girls, Smira, and sisters Leila and Fatima Achboun-,were suspended from the Gabriel -Havez Middle School in the town of Creil after refusing to remove their headscarves at their principal’s demand (France, 119). After several rounds of negotiation, the parents and the school board compromised that, the girls could wear headscarves in school, but not during classes. However, when the girls broke the compromise and started to put on their headscarves in classes again, they were expelled from the school for allegedly contravening the fundamental French value of laïcité- secularism and the neutrality of the public school. This local incident sparked a broad range of media attention, causing the issue to expand into a national level debate. Some people argued that the students were entitled to the right to choose to wear their headscarves. They believed that the law that bans veils in school, violates Muslim students’ rights of practicing their religion freely. Others justify these laws on the principle of lacïté. Since 1989, French politicians have continuously issued statements clarifying the French government’s stand on the veil affair. In my opinion, since France is a country established through a radical revolution against the power of church and king, grounded by the value of lacïté (secularism), and aimed to realize a goal of French conformity through the public school system, I regard that the laws banning headscarf in French public school are reasonable, both historically and socially.
The history of struggling to build a country through a radical revolution, provides one explanation for why France treats the headscarf issue so seriously today. Although both the United States and France were founded through revolution, The French Revolution had a different approach. Tracing back to 1789, when the revolutionist and progressivists in France rose up a radical revolution against the “Catholic monarchy,” its aim was to make France a country of “republic secularism,” which “relegate religion strictly to the private sphere and regulate its entry into the public sphere” (“Headscarf Politics”; France, 49). The founders of this newly established nation, claiming themselves to be believers of reason, aimed to secularize an already religious country by forbidding public worship, removing Christian signs, and closing churches (class note). “About 15,000 Catholic schools were closed, and tens of thousands of clerical teachers lost their jobs” (“Headscarf Politics”). These continuous efforts made France move gradually towards a nation of complete secularism. The notion of being religious was considered wired, and only when Napoleon came to power had the churches regained a little ground, but no church had ever restored its political reign again.
In 1905, the issuing of a law of separation had confirmed the French separation of church and state, which established a legal foundation of French laïcité, a unique French idea that cannot be fully translated into any other language: “a republic can ensure the separation of public and private only by refraining from recognizing distinctive cultural or religious identities within the public sphere” (France, 50; Wieviorka, 29). The Article 1 of the French Constitution states that, “France shall be an indivisible, secular, democratic and social Republic.” Compared to the United States, France is a more secular country. The idea of French secularism is both written in laws and implanted in the heads of all French citizens. I think the individuals break the code are selfish, and the veil ban mandate is reasonable because the interest of preserving the public order and unity of the country is greater than satisfying individual practices.
The principle of laïcité is realized through its public school system. Since public school is the only institution that teaches students French
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about French Veil

Should the Islamic Face Veil Be Banned? Essay

Why the Islamic Face veil should not banned There has been debates about whether the Islamic face veil should be banned in countries. The arguments that governments of countries that have banned the Muslim face veil (France, Syria, Netherlands, Spain, and Belgium) argue that the full-face veil is oppressive, degrading towards women, and goes against values of each country. However, many Muslim women believe otherwise and strongly disagree with the banning of the veil. I strongly believe that…

Words 1265 - Pages 6

Pride: Islamic Veil Essay

Scarves and veils of different colors and shapes were customary in countless cultures long before Islam came into being in the seventh century in the Arabian Peninsula (which includes present-day Saudi Arabia). To this day, head coverings play a significant role in many religions, including Orthodox Judaism and Catholicism. Since the seventh century, Islam has grown to be one of the major world religions. As it spread through the Middle East to Saharan and sub-Saharan Africa, to Central Asia, and…

Words 664 - Pages 3

Belgium Research Paper

Belgium’s Immigration, Migration, and Emigration Crystal Escamilla HUMN 305-F1W Caroline Fernandez 10/19/14 Belgium’s Immigration, Migration, and Emigration Immigration Belgium is usually unnoticed when it comes to immigration, since it is small in size and the kingdom’s less known background of immigration. However, in the past years Belgium has become a permanent home for many different immigrants and ethnic groups. The country’s society is impacted by the diverse cultures who have settled historically…

Words 1168 - Pages 5

What Is The Minister's Black Veil

In The Minister’s Black Veil written by Nathaniel Hawthorne a common theme of choices and possibilities is displayed. In The Minister’s Black Veil the minister, Reverend Hooper, made the decision to wear a black veil that would cover his face as a symbol of hidden sins. Mr. Hooper put on the veil knowing that the people of the town could react in two different ways: show their support or reject him.The town chose the latter of the two and avoided Mr. Hooper out of fear. Numerous people in the town…

Words 1144 - Pages 5

The Veil Short Story

A Ten year Old Passion behind The Veil The short story “The Veil” by Marjane Satrapi used drawing to describe how she was a ten-year-old forced to wear a veil and how it changed her view of her surroundings. Using drawing and writing makes readers think and interpret the feeling and the situation that was going on. Satrapi uses dark faces and bright backgrounds for the things that made her insecure, and she uses a black background and a white face to show the happy faces or the positive feelings…

Words 1344 - Pages 6

Essay on Persepolis: United States Bankruptcy Law and Page

Chapter Name and Number Title of the graphic and page number Why is it the most important? Chapter 1 : The Veil “Bilingual Capitalism” - page 4 This is the most important part of the chapter because it shows how the islamic culture takes what they believe is not right and then changes it to make other believe that it is bad. Chapter 2 : The Bicycle “The Revolting Bicycle” - page 10 This is the most important part of the chapter because it shows the relationship between the tyranny of the people…

Words 1745 - Pages 7

Burqa Dbq

He commented that the niqāb was not prescribed in Islam, that in the French and contemporary context its spread was associated with radicalization and criminal behavior and that its wearing was inconsistent with Frances concept of the secular state; but that due to expected difficulties in applying a legal ban, he would prefer to see the issue handled "case by case". Mohammed Moussaoui the president of the french council of the muslim faith, opposed using a law but favored discouraging Muslim…

Words 616 - Pages 3

Sound of Music: Properties of Musical Sounds Essay

and double bass. * Greatest versatility and expressive range. * Pizzicato (Plucked string) * Double Stop (Two notes at once) * Vibrato * Rocking the left hand while pressing the strings down. * Mute * Musician can veil or muffle the tone by fitting a clamp onto the bridge. * Tremolo * Rapidly repeats tones by quick up-and-down strokes of the bow. This creates tension, when loud; or shimmering when lightly touch. * Harmonics * High-pitched tones…

Words 1169 - Pages 5

Edmund Burke French Revolution Rhetorical Analysis

Burke included, despise change; they prefer the world to stay constant. The upheaval of social order is deemed as an unnecessary and a wasteful change. Edmund Burke shares a politically conservative view; therefore, he opposes revolutions, namely the French Revolution. In his opinion, the revolution only served to destroy France’s foundation and tradition. For example, he explained the people of France were making rash decisions; their rationalization was compromised. To maintain order, Burk suggested…

Words 1456 - Pages 6

Essay about Candid: Voltaire Candide

Bryan C. Barr Professor Walls World Literature 27 March 2014 Candide: Voltaire Candide is a French Satire published in 1759 by a young man by the name of Voltaire, a philosopher of the age of enlightenment. Candide is a genre of literature that is sometimes graphic, and performing arts, in which vices, follies, abuses, and shortcomings are held up to ridicule ideally with the intent of shaming individuals, corporations, governments or society itself, into improvement. The Age of Enlightenment…

Words 315 - Pages 2