Essay about Harvey Milk

Submitted By luv4mook
Words: 3767
Pages: 16
Open Document
1. The Akratic
A. Describe the akratic generally:
• Akrasia is the state of mind in which someone acts against their better judgment though weakness of will
• Failure to obey one’s rational calculation.
• Passions do not allow in accord with reasoned decision where being self controlled (continent) does not follow appetites based on what reason decided
• Akrasia requires culpability and irrationality, where is where strong feelings come in. B. Specify the description using an example:
• Example: Tasty pasty on table, you wander by it and take a piece than a moment later realized maybe you shouldn’t have. Passion takes over first! Weakness based Akrasia: Passions do not allow the agent to act in accord with reasoned decision. Example: See the cake sit there and think about it for a minute and finally take a piece. 2) Socrates’ Ethical Intellectualism
A. Describe Socratic intellectualism generally as well as in relation to his claim that virtue is knowledge and his use of the elenchus:
• Elenchus: A logical refutation, an argument that refutes another argument by proving the contrary of the conclusion.
• If I know something, then I do not need to inquire into it (do not need to be taught); and if I do not know something then I cannot inquire into it (cannot be taught).
• Either I know something or I do not know it.
• Therefore, I do not need to nor can I inquire into anything.
• Socratic Intellectualism: Everyone has an innate desire for the good and the capacity for knowing the good. We need to realize this capacity, become virtuous by doing away with the false conceptions of the good (eliminate false consciousness). Socrates seems to have admitted implicitly that an innate desire for the good exists in all human beings. We can now better understand the meaning of the Socratic paradox according to which no one is evil willingly; or in another formulation, virtue is knowledge.
• People only do evil things out of ignorance. There’s an innate intention to do good in all human beings. No matter what a person’s conception of the good might be. No one has evil intentions. There’s an innate intention to do good in all human beings. No matter what a person’s conception of the good might be.
• Hadot: when you act for the sake of that which harms you, it’s a misunderstanding.
• If you want to have virtue, you have to have knowledge. We don’t know the good.
• Our intellectual/reason gives us the good, but we misunderstand it and act according to false conceptions of the good.
• Socrates’ task in Meno, is to undermine Meno. His rhetorical commitment is getting in the way of his good life.

3). Aristotelian Objection to Socratic Intellectualism:
A. Describe Aristotle’s objection from akrasia to Socrates:

• To have the right “prescription” without the habits to carry out in the action, as Aristotle suggested, a situation especially vulnerable to Akrasia: Virtue, on the Socratic understanding, is essentially threatened by the experience the Socratic cannot explain. Aristotle: Socrates’ account is not true to [the ethical] phenomena. We may have requisite clarity and coherence of reasoning, but still fail to do the right thing.
• Practical wisdom is the strongest state of all continence.

• Quotes from Nicomachean Ethics Book VII:

• “Socrates entirely opposed to the view in question, holding that there is no such thing as incontinence; no one, he said acts against what he believes is best - people and so only by reason of ignorance.” (PG 1809-1810)
• “But there are some who concede cerain of Socrates’ contentions but not others; that nothing is stronger than knowledge they admit, but not that no one acts contrary to what has seemed to him the better course, and therefore they say that the incontinent man has not knowledge when he is mastered by his pleasures, but opinion” (PG 1810)
• “Further if continence makes a man ready to stand by any and every opinion, it is bad, i.e., if it
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Harvey Milk

Harvey Milk: A Biographical Film

Milk is a biographical film focusing on the life and political journey of Harvey Milk, the first openly gay man to be elected into public office in California. The film spans the years 1970 through 1978, with some footage of actual riots and protests from previous years. During this time, the fight for gay rights was intense and increasingly growing. The idea for a film centering on Harvey Milk’s life arose in 1991, but it was not released until October of 2008, when laws affecting the lesbian, gay…

Words 909 - Pages 4

Harvey Milk Research Paper

Harvey Milk Harvey Milk was was the first San Francisco County Board of Supervisors openly gay elected. He was born on May 22, 1930. Milk wanted to help the gays and lesbian for their rights. When he was 14 he was aware that he was homosexuals but kept it to himself. He also kept his homosexuals away from his family. Once he had graduate he joined the U.S Navy. He had followed his parents footsteps for joining the Navy. After that he was an icon for gay rights in 1970s. Then in June 25, 1978…

Words 492 - Pages 2

A Letter To Harvey Milk By Lesléa Newman

When I first read, “A Letter to Harvey Milk” by Lesléa Newman, I first wondered, how in the world can a man get off for killing two men? How can Twinkies be the reasoning for such a horrible crime? The documentary, The Times of Harvey Milk, shed some light on these questions. Dan White, the man who killed Harvey Milk and the Mayor, did only five and a half years in prison, for a crime that is meant to be life in prison. The junk food he ate so much of like Twinkies is what helped him plead for an…

Words 590 - Pages 3

Harvey Bernard Milk: The Gay Rights Movement

more gay organizations and activists arose, the gay rights movement took off. Harvey Bernard Milk, a political gay rights activist who at first had trouble coming to terms with his own sexuality, carried the responsibility of the gay…

Words 1882 - Pages 8

Political Movie Writing Essay

Harvey Milk: The inspiring Gay Activist Milk was a biographical film based on gay right activists and a politician by the name of Harvey Milk. Harvey was the first homosexual individual to be elected into the public office in California as one of the members of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. The film begins with the police raiding gay bars and arresting homosexuals during the 1950’s and 1960’s and then this follows up with a fast forward to 1978 in November where the press is releasing…

Words 1169 - Pages 5

Lgbt and Milk Essay

could not become a political leader? Harvey Milk is a prime example of this situation. Based on a true story, Milk is a 2008 film directed by Gus Van Sant on an American gay activist who struggles for gay rights. It all started in the 1970’s when he lived in New York opening a camera shop, Castro Camera, which becomes the store for San Francisco’s increasing gay community. Throughout the process Milk organizes gays to pull together upon political coalition. Milk moves to San Francisco while running…

Words 1066 - Pages 5

Ethical Issues In The Movie Milk

still exist with homosexual rights to this day. The film Milk, directed by Gus Van Sant, is a film about homosexual rights. The character Harvey Milk, fought hard against the cruel society, that discriminated against homosexuals. Harvey ran twice for the Board of Supervisors in San Francisco. Harvey and his boyfriend Scott worked hard to gain followers and protesters. In the middle of the film, Harvey finally won the election…

Words 636 - Pages 3

Gilbert Baker Research Paper

The rainbow flag, popularised as a gay, Lesbian bisexual and transgender LGBT community, the pride flag commonly known for the symbol of freedom and peace, the colours reflect the diversity in the LGBT community. Designed by Gilbert Baker in 1978, gilbert baker who original came from Kansas came to San Francisco as an army draftee. His home town would occasionally be associated with Oz but Baker did not want to click his heels back to Kansas. Baker was discharged from hospital in San Francisco…

Words 295 - Pages 2

paper 5

commercial are mainly all different kinds of farmers in the United States. The commercial has a monologue which was a speech written by Paul Harvey. “Paul Harvey delivered conservative broadcasts on current events, reaching, at his peak, 24 million people daily” (Paul par. 1). Paul Harvey was a very famous broadcaster through the 1950’s and the 1960’s. “Paul Harvey died February 28, 2009” (Paul par. 2), he died as an American icon. The commercial was done by the truck company Dodge Ram. Dodge used…

Words 991 - Pages 4

Extra Credit Options For Humanities 105 Essay

the CCC public Library). ▪ This is an A&E Biography of the life and work of Pablo Picasso. Execution of Justice (may be difficult to find) ▪ The true story of the assassination of San Francisco Mayor George Moscone and City Supervisor Harvey Milk on November 27, 1978, told from the perspective of the assassin Dan White. ❑ Make a "soundtrack" for this class. Put together and explain how your choices in songs represent the themes we have covered in class. (Include the audio). ❑…

Words 326 - Pages 2