How Does Plato Show Sympathy For The Three Men

Words: 659
Pages: 3
Open Document
The first judge shows his sympathy to the three men and his understanding of its unique circumstances of the case. However, contrary to his personal sympathy, he sentence Dudley, Stephens, and even Brooks who did not contribute to the actual murder to be executed for their crime; murder. The first judge does not let his emotions rule over his decision, solely bases his decision on the legal definition of the law, and he does not dare to change any of it. He states “I am not free to make the law”. His point of view is similar to Socrates’ philosophy of law, because Socrates strongly believes in the concept of “Rule of Law”, which means that everyone is equal under the law, and everyone should obey and uphold the law. The first judge demonstrates how not only the three men, but himself as well must obey the law in any circumstances. …show more content…
However, he recognizes different opinions of the public; some say the three men deserve punishment, and others show sympathy to the three men and their unfortunate situation. He balances both sides’ opinion, and find the men guilty, but of the lesser charge of manslaughter and sentence them to a six-month prison time. The second judge’s decision reflects on Plato’s point of view. Plato believes that the ultimate purpose of law is to be moral, but that it is also circumstantial. Although the judge charge the men guilty to maintain the purpose of law; to be moral, he still considers the rare circumstance and gives them a lesser
Show More

Related Documents: How Does Plato Show Sympathy For The Three Men

Biography Of Socrates

Socrates 469 BC–399 BC, was a classical Greek Athenian philosopher. Credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy, he is an enigmatic figure known chiefly through the accounts of later classical writers, especially the writings of his students Plato and Xenophon, and the plays of his contemporary Aristophanes. Many would claim that Plato's dialogues are the most comprehensive accounts of Socrates to survive from antiquity. Through his portrayal in Plato's dialogues, Socrates has become renowned…

Words 9241 - Pages 37

The Organic Ethnologist of Algeriani Migration Essay

everyday life of Algerian slums on the Parisian periphery during the fifties, all informed by an acute awareness of the political-economic roots and import of human transhumance1- the Algerian sociologist both elaborated and demonstrated the potency of three pivotal principles for the study of migration. The first is the simple but fundamental proposition, whose implications remain to be fully drawn out by scholars and policy makers alike, that before he or she becomes an immigrant, the migrant is always…

Words 2912 - Pages 12

Biblical Scriptures Underlying Six Ethical Models Influencing Organizational Practices Essay

Organization Rodgers Susana organizations among the that in frauds reflection regarding decision-making. this recent The a been Six Practices Organizational Springer 2006 about how many opinion phases and subroutines within the phases there are and the order in which occur How 1987; Simon, phases (Hogarth, 1957). ever, at least four dominant phases appear with some are (a) Percep in the Hterature. These consistency tion (P), (b) Information Gathering (I), (c) Analyzes of Information…

Words 7350 - Pages 30

Sailing The Wine-Dark Se Why The Greeks Matter

we are and how real is history? What everyone knows about western civilization, is that correct? Well, these are complicated questions and they really deserve careful, considerate answers. Today, you will get some of those answers from a very, very special author, thomas cahill. He has written four of the series of seven books about history of western civilization. The series is called "hinges of history" and you'll soon find out why the greeks matter. The first of the four books was how the irish…

Words 7801 - Pages 32

Hist 350 Origins of Christianity Essay

Council of Nicea (325) • When does it end o Nicene, 325-451 or the second in 787 ( argued by the east) o WEST end it with the last great theologist gregorty the great 325-604 • This is the age of the apologist o Justifications of such, some of the most important writings of the time are apologetics o To demonstrate that Christianity was not a antithetical attempt at the roman belief o We find an intensification of persecution o Rigorist heresies • What does that mean o The first stirrings…

Words 9913 - Pages 40