In The Symposium

Words: 1109
Pages: 5
Open Document
Ben Cooke
December 5th 2014
Philosophy 302

Criticism of Love in the Symposium In the Symposium by Plato there are seven speeches on love. Each person giving the speech attempts to define what love is or what the ideal form of love is. While there are some useful ideas in the speeches, particularly in Socrates’s speech, when it comes to love Plato missed the mark. One of the useful ideas put forth is the idea of true belief. True belief is a middle ground between knowledge and ignorance. Given my knowledge of the world today and knowing my ignorance of philosophical thought in general, it is my true belief that love as discussed in The Symposium does not exist. Love is a purely social construct and does not exist as a god or a intrinsic …show more content…
It is what keeps marriages together, stays the hand of would be murderers and thieves, and prevents the governments of the world from wiping out humanity with their wars. The truth is love exists not because it is part of the universe, but because it has survival value. Without the noble lie of love, mankind would have already wiped itself out either through ignorance or violence. In the first speech Phaedrus speaks of the primordial god of love and the wild energy that causes lovers to drive each other to greater and greater feats and sacrifices for one another. He also speaks of the tamer, more tender version of this intimacy that civilizes and socializes the younger lover. First of all, the concept of a god of love still exists today. Its absorption into Christianity can be summed up with the popular statement “God is Love”. This concept of a god of love is a noble lie used to keep the masses sedated and in the pews, or to manipulate political and cultural opinions towards tolerance. Phaedrus’s second and third ideas have merit and are observed in many species, including our own. These behaviors are not limited to lovers and are frequently …show more content…
First, he maneuvers Agathon into contradicting himself, then goes on to tell about love of beauty, wisdom, and knowledge. He tells an allegory of the painful ascent to enlightenment. At first, I did not think his position was relevant to love as I view it, particularly in respect to virtue continuing after death. Then I reconsidered his, or rather Diatoma’s, statements on immortality and enlightenment. The seeker on the path of enlightenment must elevate others along the way, providing a sort of mentorship. Their relentless pursuit of beauty and examination of reality inevitably yields some sort of clue to the true nature of the world, and the seeker shares it with others along his journey. (White) This is the very root of social survival strategies, and the beginnings of scientific discovery. By observing the world and sharing knowledge, by assisting those mentally weaker than they are, the seeker of enlightenment helps to ensure the survival of the entire species. In that way they achieve immortality both physically and mentally. Their genetic material will still exist in some form among their peers and their useful observations will be passed down from generation to generation. The noble lie of love will perpetuate itself through them without them ever needing to truly experience it. (Levy) The seventh and final speech in The Symposium is a drunken rant by Alcibiates about Socrates, and exemplifies
Show More

Related Documents: In The Symposium

Love In Agathon's Symposium

In Symposium, Agathon wishes to discuss about what love is, rather than what it does, as he states “ In the case of love, it is right for us to praise him first for what he is and afterward for his gifts”(195a). In discussing what love is he first states how, God of love is beautiful, young, and good. He sets this picture of how love appears to him stating “And the exquisite coloring of his skin!, the way the god consorts with flowers show that. His place is wherever it is flowery and fragrant; there…

Words 429 - Pages 2

Love In Plato's Symposium

Plato's Symposium is a progression of discourses on Adoration given at a gathering in Ancient Greece. They manage inquiries of: what Love is; relational connections through adoration; what sorts of affection are deserving of acclaim; the reason for adoration; and others. It is the principal major philosophical on affection in Western writing. It can be delegated a tragicomedy, utilizing components of both classes. The Early on Exchange acquaints the mind boggling layers with the portrayal, as the…

Words 1026 - Pages 5

Meaning Of Love In Plato's Symposium '

Most notable Eros is seen throughout the Symposium; an ancient Greek play written by Plato. Six men are at a dinner party of sorts and decided to discuss the meaning of love, each gives a different account of love. Phaedrus spoke of the Conventional human love, meaning basically he was in love with the idea of love, the shallowest form of love we see. Then Pausanias explains love as noble human love, meaning its interest was in sex and love distinguishes between earthly and heavenly love. Eryximachous…

Words 268 - Pages 2

Comparing Beauty In Republic And The Symposium

Beauty is a prevalent theme throughout works of literature by Plato, namely Republic and The Symposium. Republic describes several instances which prove the subjective nature of beauty. The Symposium, on the other hand, presents and argues the idea that beauty is inherent, and is therefore objective. Which of these two works, then, correctly depicts the concept and beauty? Furthermore, why would Plato choose to depict beauty in different ways within his novels? In Book V of Republic Socrates begins…

Words 1351 - Pages 6

Essay on Symposium: Democracy and Bloom

The Symposium The soul needs to ask the hard questions about life such as man’s role in nature, and address them. The best way to accomplish that is by doing it with people who have the same longings, in a friendly, educated, civilized, yet natural environment like the symposium of the Greeks. Plato and Socrates were looking for answers together, despite all the political and cultural turmoil that was going around them, such as an inevitable war and the decline of their Greek empire. Open discussion…

Words 3909 - Pages 16

Definition Of Love In Aristophane's Symposium

Aristophanes’s Thorough Definition of Love Symposium by Plato is set at a dinner party hosted by Agathon, who is entertaining other famous philosophers of his time who designate their night to giving speeches on the topic of praising love. One of the speeches told by Aristophanes being particularly successful in explaining all aspects of love, both as a human emotion along with it’s sexual components and where love comes from. This speech is contrasted with another one told by Socrates which goes…

Words 1421 - Pages 6

Symposium: Leadership and Leader Development Essay

ARI Research Note 96-63 1996 Army Symposium: "Leadership Challenges of the 21st Century Army" Executive Summary James G. (Jerry) Hunt and Robert L. Phillips Texas Tech University Army Trends Analysis Group Alma G. Steinberg, Chief May 1996 19960815 145 United States Army Research Institute for the Behavioral and Social Sciences Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. U.S. ARMY RESEARCH INSTITUTE FOR THE BEHAVIORAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCES A Field Operating Agency…

Words 7670 - Pages 31

Aristophanes View Of Love In St. Augustine's Symposium

different answers. When examining Plato’s “Symposium,” each of the seven different speakers are expected to give an account or explanation of love to praise the Greek god of Love in a symposium at Agathon’s house. One speaker in particular explains his account of love in abstract way of both physical and emotional connection between soul mates. Aristophanes, considered a comedian at that time, gives an account of love unlike anyone else at the symposium. Aristophanes’ account of love starts off bleak…

Words 955 - Pages 4

Who Is Socrates Rejection Of Alcibiades In Plato's Symposium

Socrates’ rejection of Alcibiades in Plato’s Symposium clearly demonstrates the former’s understanding of the art of love as presented to him by Diotima. Diotima outlines the art of love in a very particular way, laying out its origins, its characteristic properties, and its relation to the Form of Beauty. Socrates rejection seamlessly aligns with this description and demonstrates all of these essential concepts. It must be noted the broader, more general use of the word love is presented interchangeably…

Words 1917 - Pages 8

F103 Planning, Programming, Budgeting and Execution (PPBE); Gen. Odierno AUSA Winter Symposium Essay

US ARMY COMMAND AND GENERAL STAFF COLLEGE US Army Command and General Staff School Command and General Staff Officer’s Course (CGSOC) Common Core F103: Planning, Programming, Budgeting and Execution (PPBE) F103RB Feb. 24, 2012 - Gen. Odierno AUSA Winter Symposium1 The position of strength that the Army has is that everyone has seen over the last ten years what our Army has done, and is capable of. Lots of people want to put the Army in a box. They want to say this is what the Army can…

Words 2668 - Pages 11