Insanity Defense Research Paper

Words: 1414
Pages: 6
Open Document
Whitney Gonsalves
Mrs. Dalton
English Language Arts 12, Hour 5
31 October 2016
Rough Draft
Is the insanity plea a valid one in criminal cases and what kind of assessment could be used to prove a person is criminally insane? The insanity defense states that a criminal is not guilty by reason of insanity. The theory is that the criminal either did not know the act was wrong or cannot control their violent actions even when they understand that what they did was wrong. This theory is also controversial because it is difficult to define whether someone is insane. The process of proving a criminal insane should be a lot more complex than it is or has been in the past. The insanity plea, otherwise known as the insanity defense, is a type of criminal …show more content…
Then, in later years the “complete madness definition evolved into the “wild beast” test, which would run test to determine whether a person was really insane or not. Under this test, the insanity defense was available to a person who was "totally deprived of his understanding and memory so as not to know what he was doing, no more than an infant, a brute, or a wild beast" (Feigl 1995,161). As years passed the Insanity plea defense evolved and got a lot more credible and stronger. An example of how this plea has evolved is, A Biddeford man who was pulled over last year on the Maine Turnpike with an AK-47 assault rifle, several handguns and news clippings of a mass shooting in Colorado was found not guilty by reason of insanity …show more content…
Robinson, traces the development of the insanity plea, exonerating from punishment criminals judged to have been mad at the time of committing their crime (New York Times). For many years, Psychologist have been studying this theory and are still pondering whether this is a positive or a negative plea. Some may say this is neither, the insanity plea should not be a thing cause there a lot of possible consequences. For example, Equating physical illness with mental illness has the appearance of equity, but it is an equation based on a false premise that they are identical. Furthermore, it is destructive culturally, making us, as one writer terms it, a nation of victims (“Task Force Aims”). Insanity can be deceiving to the human eye, this is why people should study the criminals pleading for insanity. No one wants a criminal to get a light sentence or be let off because they took advantage of this plea. You can also tell whether someone is just out of it, for example, "When I first saw Mr. Courtois in September, he was completely unable to concentrate. When I saw him, he was delusional," LeBlanc said. "He did not demonstrate any types of skills for competency to stand trial"
Show More

Related Documents: Insanity Defense Research Paper

Insanity Defense Research Paper

Not guilty by reason of insanity has perplexed the most qualified legal and psychiatric professionals for centuries. The insanity defense is rooted in the belief that when a person is so mentally disturbed that their irrationality or compulsion is impossible to control, it would be unfair to punish them in such an extreme condition (4). This beginning the argument of is the mental health of an individual more important than them paying for their crimes. The insanity defense has become a media sensation…

Words 597 - Pages 3

Essay on Stockholm Syndrome

their captors (Fisher 2010). According to the Encyclopedia of Victimology and Crime Prevention, Stockholm syndrome is a “psychological and emotional process whereby the abused comes to identify with the abuser” (Fisher 2010). Dee Graham, a former research psychologist for the University of Cincinnati, came up with four conditions for Stockholm syndrome: “The first of…

Words 2944 - Pages 12

The Case Of Frank Lee Smith

gy paper The Case of Frank Lee Smith Johnnie Daniels Psychology and Law Case Summary The case of Frank Lee Smith was a very interesting one and yet at the same time, a very sad one. An innocent man that was wrongfully convicted gave up 14 years, and eventually his life inside of a prison for a crime that he did not commit. Later it was found that he was actually telling the truth about the whole thing. According to the innocent project Frank…

Words 3090 - Pages 13

Essay on Final Project

January 2, 2015 Heather Morris Unit 11 Introduction This paper will explain what a subspecialty is and how forensic psychologists use their knowledge to address and use this knowledge in each subspecialty. Each subspecialty will be explained and the affect that the forensic psychologists plays and to what affect…

Words 2962 - Pages 12

Death Penalty Essay

Research Paper The death penalty has been around for thousands of years, dating as far back to the eighteenth century B.C. in Babylon, seventh century B.C. in Athens, and in the fifth century B.C. in Rome. Since then, the death penalty has found its way to many cultures around the world. The British first influenced the death penalty in America when British colonists began to explore the Americas. When the colonists came to America, they brought the practice of capital punishment with them…

Words 3094 - Pages 13

Essay about The Harms And Politics Of Environmental

Enhancing enforcement through community support and technology ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! "Lobbying is pretty easy. You just go to (political) fund raisers."! ! Oil Company Lobbyist! ! "It is impossible for an oil refinery to be in total compliance."! ! Blood Money: The Harms and Politics of White-Collar Environmental Crime! ! ! ! ! The Same Oil Company Lobbyist! ! ! No doubt “street crime” receives more than its fair share of media and political attention. The media, politicians and enforcement…

Words 3481 - Pages 14

Essay about Psychology Workbook

I. INTRODUCTION Objective I.1 Define psychology: the science of behavior and mental processes. |Margin Learning Question(s) (if applicable) |Page(s) | |None | | Key Terms Psychology: the science of behavior and mental processes. Exercises 1. Put a check mark…

Words 22851 - Pages 92