International Self Determination

Words: 1323
Pages: 6
Open Document
2. Introduction
My proposed PhD project aims to research women and self-determination within the field of international feminist legal studies. It seeks to examine the multiple narratives provided by women and the international legal system on women’s rights and political agency as citizens to promote individual and collective self-determination. It argues that the study of international law does not usually consider its colonial origins, or the resistance movements which colonialism provokes, ignoring also any sense of female activism or a female space of agency. Linked to this proposition there is a second one, according to which legal international acts, texts and their interpretations are often detached from a consideration of the people …show more content…
The right to self-determination has been largely interpreted in the international legal scholarship as the internal freedom of people to determine the way the government is organised and the external right of a group to reject claims of jurisdictions by another state. This main account of self-determination has generated a large set of critiques from feminist and critical legal theories. A feminist set of analyses concerns a critique of the western liberal accounts of legal personhood within a national legal structure that goes beyond a version of sovereign international self-determination which does not take into account the individual self-determination of its citizens. (H. Charlesworth and C.M. Chinkin, 2000; G. Heathcote, 2011) A second set of analyses stress the colonial roots of international law, affirming how it was created as a tool of colonisation and how it developed afterwards as a tool of legitimising colonial projects including those which extend into the League and the UN via the Mandate and Trusteeship system. (A. Anghie, …show more content…
It was created precisely with the purpose of promoting self-determination in the colonial territories and to include them in the larger ‘Family of Nations’ once they had fulfilled certain conditions-namely, progress and civilisation. (A. Anghie, 2005) In fact, they were considered .(Covenant ofthe League of Nation, 1920, Art.22) Nowadays, ICJ and UN seem currently to interpret the international legal rules on self-determination not as an immediate effective substantive right – as required by several treaties and previous ICJ judgements- but as a process, whose steps have to be assessed and recognised by international institutions. (D.Z. Dass, 1992; C. Drew, 2001; M. Craven, 2010) This above-mentioned analysis focuseson looking at the right to self-determination as grounded in the functioning of international legal institutions and remains largely silent on the role of women’s status and gender issues as a yardstick to assess people’s right to
Show More

Related Documents: International Self Determination

Aboriginal Self-Determination Case Study

Australians have strived to achieve self-determination for their communities which has been largely hindered by the Australian government. However, this has not always been the case. When the leader of the labour party Gough Whitlam was elected to be the Australian Prime Minister in 1967 he envisioned for the Aboriginal people to have their own self-determination granting them the ability to govern themselves within their communities. It states in article 1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political…

Words 313 - Pages 2

Outline: International Relations and Sovereignty Positive- Capabilities Essay examples

PSC285 International Relations Fall 2012 Midterm Exam Study Guide 1. Identify the actors that participate in international system and explain how each affects international relations. * States- states dominate the conventional discourse * International Organizations- spreaders of global norms * Nongovernmental organizations- fulfill social and political or economical objectives * Individuals – independent leaders, that usually are more effective when they operate from an…

Words 847 - Pages 4

Iris Young Paper

and self-determination. Taking sovereignty as the focus, I will critically evaluate the one and two-state models in terms of their viability and advocate Young’s proposal of a bi-national federation as the best solution to the conflict. In her article Self-determination as non-domination, Ideals applied to Palestine/Israel, Young differentiates between her concept of self-determination as non-domination and the more common concept of self-determination as non-interference. Self-determination as…

Words 2307 - Pages 10

Pros And Cons Of The Treaty Of Versailles

heroic figure as he arrived to Paris, France. They had high hopes of Wilson would be able to creating lasting peace. President Wilson tried to promote peace, equality, rights, opportunity, liberty, and democracy to the other countries by forming an international organization called the League of Nations and the creation of the Fourteen Points. The United States should have ratified the Treaty of Versailles because it would have benefit all nations. The ratification of the treaty would bring peace to all…

Words 572 - Pages 3

The Ideas Of The League Of Nations

peace can be established by making the seas free, allowing free trade, reducing arms, ending secret treaties, self-determination of national groups, and establishing the League of Nations. My plan also includes power being granted to local citizens in order to settle territorial disputes and Germany evacuating their occupied territory in Europe. One of my big ideas is self-determination, meaning the ability of a nation to determine its own statehood based on distinctions. I truly think this is the…

Words 381 - Pages 2

How Did George Washington's Farewell Address

America into international conflict, thus weakening the power of the government, and it did not include much of what America wanted in the treaty. The Treaty of Versailles would have forced American into international affairs through the League of Nations, causing the power of the US government to weaken. Article 10 of the League of Nation’s charter…

Words 812 - Pages 4

Human Rights Essay

these rights differ from ordinary rights under domestic law in that they are considered to be universal, inalienable (cannot be taken away) and inherent in all people. The UDHR is an international declaration of these rights which has formed the basis for laws, constitutions, international treaties and ongoing international debate on human rights. Human rights are a collection of fundamental standards for the treatment of individuals in a fair, just and free society. They aim to protect individuals…

Words 9485 - Pages 38

Why Do Wars Occur between States Essay

are) has to exist and operate with a need to survive, prosper and develop. History has shown that this very notion of self-protection and organisation has ultimately transpired into engagement in war and conflict; however, it is incumbent to question the reason why war can occur between states. Is it the absence of legally binding resolutions and consequences set by international society that acts as a check-and-balance on state power, growth and outreach? Indeed, in a scenario where the state resorts…

Words 648 - Pages 3

Concept Of Human Rights

Documents Magna Carta 1215: a political agreement between the King and Barns that paved the way for the development of rights. Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948: first document by the UN on human rights. International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1976 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1976 Convention of the Rights of the Child 1990: develops a regime whereby the rights of children are protected. Children are the most vulnerable humans. Movement for the…

Words 1765 - Pages 8

Socail: Nation and Pg Essay

4. Nationalism (pg 21) A belief in your nation. Nationalism is an abstract concept. 5. International (pg 21) Member of the global community accept responsbillity for challenge that face the world and allows people to move between countries. 6. Collective (pg 23) Done by people working together. 7. Patriotism (pg 24) Love of a country. 8. Self Determination (pg 29) Your identity based on a share of ethnicicty. 9. Sovereignty (pg 29) Political auth…

Words 324 - Pages 2