Is the Knowledge We Gain from the Natural Sciences More Reliable Than the Knowledge We Gain from the Human Sciences Essay

Words: 1199
Pages: 5
Open Document
Is the knowledge we gain from the NATURAL SCIENCES more reliable than the knowledge we gain from the HUMAN SCIENCES?

When I first pondered over the question in class confidently my thoughts were natural sciences, of course, but before long I was left bewildered. I realized I had taken the reliability of all sciences for granted, who’s to say any one is more reliable than the other? What even makes something reliable? I strongly believe the reliability of knowledge soundly depends on the variety of WOK’s backing it, the more ways something can be proved through language, perception, reason and emotion the more reliable it would be. Hold your thumb up in the air to cover a distant object(a tree, a car, anything) and close one eye, all …show more content…
However the fascinating counter claim to the above discussion is that with the facts, laws and rules of science constantly changing it could also be argued to create a sort of continuum of truth. Always bettering and updating itself.

The problems with the knowledge gained from the human sciences seem more difficult to overcome than that of the natural sciences. Human sciences aim to explain human behavior, formulate theories to predict it and then develop remedies for the problems identified by the predictions. Surveys are often used to collect data which is then graphed in a way that usually ‘looks pretty’ and statistics are then formulated, quite deductively so that the data fits the model. Geologists claim to know which countries are more developed than another’s by simply looking at a population structure graph and comparing it to the stages of the demographic transition model. Surveys provide the data for the population structure graph which are strongly influenced by language and the demographic transition model is no more than a theory based on an interpretation of demographic history developed in 1929. Yet this theory is still used to make grand assumptions about a country’s developmental status, many times certain ‘experts’ in the field present this data as if it were precisely
Show More

Related Documents: Is the Knowledge We Gain from the Natural Sciences More Reliable Than the Knowledge We Gain from the Human Sciences Essay

Love: Scientific Method and Political Science Essay

Political Science: Thinking Scientifically Readings: Kalof, Chapters 1+2, Roskins, Chapter 1 Brief Outline of Lecture: 1) Politics and science: Are they compatible? (approx. 20 minutes) 2) Thinking scientifically as opposed to “just” thinking (approx. 25 minutes) (5-minute break) 3) Six steps of scientific research (approx. 60 minutes) Lecture Notes: 1) What is politics and what is science? What is political science? (General class discussion based on the questions from AO #1)…

Words 2330 - Pages 10

Sociology and Social Sciences Essay

Chapter 1: Sociology Part 1 In gaining an understanding about our world, we have developed two sets of sciences. The first one is called the natural sciences-developed to explain and predict the events in our natural environment. The natural sciences are divided in to specialized fields of research- such as biology, geology, biology, chemistry and physics. Each area investigates a particular “slice” of nature. Given that, people have not limited themselves to investigating…

Words 2284 - Pages 10

Scientific Revolution Dbq Analysis

The Scientific Revolution was seen as a huge evolution in European sciences. The work of famous scientists such as Sir Isaac Newton and Nicolaus Copernicus changed the mindset of many Europeans. The work that they did was effected by the society that they lived in. The work of scientists in the Scientific Revolution was affected positively by government help, but was negatively affected by the ruthlessness of the Catholic Church and by division of genders. Scientists were affected in a positive…

Words 1008 - Pages 5

AP Biology Paper

What is Human Ecology? Chapter 2. Environment, Technology, and Culture What Is Human Ecology? 1 Chapter 1. WHAT IS HUMAN ECOLOGY? Another Unique Species (Title of Robert Foley’s 1987 book on evolutionary human ecology) I. Introduction What is human ecology? Human ecology is an approach to the study of human behavior marked by two committments. First, human ecologists think that humans should be studied living systems operating in complex environments. The human sciences are balkanized…

Words 7920 - Pages 32

chapter 1 powerpoint Essay

the powerful forces at play. The economics that you’re about to learn will become your most reliable guide. Copyright © 2013 Pearson Canada Inc., Toronto, Ontario Definition of Economics All economic questions arise because we want more than we can get. Our inability to satisfy all our wants is called scarcity. Because we face scarcity, we must make choices. The choices we make depend on the incentives we face. An incentive is a reward that encourages an action or a penalty that discourages an action…

Words 2178 - Pages 9

Origins Of Sociology Chapter Notes

on. ● Industrialization ­ move to cities in 17th and 18th Century social philosophers. ○ Sociology emerged in response to the intellectual ferment and confusion. ● Two factors that supported the development of sociology. ○ Examples of natural sciences. ○ Exposure of Europe to different societies through colonial expansion. ● Auguste Compte ­ (1798­1857) (Europe) ○ Father of Sociology ○ French Revolution overthrew aristocracy and entire social order. ○ He analyzed how societies changed…

Words 2016 - Pages 9

religion notes Essay

and Non-Religion The religious dimension in human history -the expression of the religious dimension in human history Animism Tyler used ‘animism’ to describe the belief that a spirit or life force exists in every animate and inanimate object Good and evil beliefs: ‘Good’ brings benefits such as health, social harmony and good hunting/gathering conditions Evil spirits are believed responsible for sickness and disease or disastrous natural events Animist ritual: the spirits might be placated…

Words 3963 - Pages 16

Explain Research Methodology

the fact that, although research often involves the collection of information, it is more than just reading a few books or articles, talking to a few people or asking people questions. While collecting data may be part of the…

Words 10236 - Pages 41

Is Neuroscience Relevant in the Free Wi Essay

frightening question: Do we have free will? Some find peace within the pragmatic principles that, as humans, we have to make a practical choice of what we are to believe. Some escape this dilemma by finding solace in Cartesian dualism1. But, those still skeptical of such philosophical doctrines are left aimlessly fumbling with the discrepancy between our innate feeling that we have complete control to make our own decisions and the understanding that our minds operate within what science asserts to be a deterministic…

Words 7284 - Pages 30

Gp Essay Mainpoints

Advertising f. Private life of public figures g. Celebrity as a role model h. Blame media for our problems i. Power + Responsibility of Media j. Media ethics k. New Media and Democracy 2. Science/Tech a. Science and Ethics b. Government and scientist role in science c. Rely too much on technology? d. Nuclear technology e. Genetic modification f. Right tech for wrong reasons 3. Arts/Culture a. Arts have a future in Singapore? b. Why pursue Arts? c. Arts…

Words 24667 - Pages 99