John Keats Choose Something Like A Star

Words: 501
Pages: 3
Open Document
The poems “Bright Star’ by John Keats and “Choose Something Like a Star” by Robert Frost are similar in their use of personification of a star, but vary in how they approach their topic. Not only do the poems give off different tones concerning the subject, they are separated by the style and technique used to create them.
A constant between both of the poems is the way that they personify a star. The two poems use apostrophe, as they directly speak to the star they are personifying. This is seen in line 1 one Keats’ poem, “Bright star, would I were stedfast as thou art,” and line 1 of Frost’s poem, “O star (The fairest one in sight.)” These two lines have the speakers directly trying to communicate with the stars, treating them as though they can hear them.
Even though the poems are relative in their content, the way in which the subject is approaches is different. “bright Star” is written as a standard english sonnet, while “Choose Something Like a Star” has no set form or rhyme scheme. Using the sonnet form creates a lulling effect on the reader in Keats’ poem that isn’t present in Frost’s. Frost’s poem doesn’t let the reader …show more content…
A reader can feel the regret and loneliness in “Bright Star.” The diction and setting create a sense of tragedy and beauty, shown in lines 10-11, “Pillow’d upon my fair love’s ripening breast, to feel for ever its soft fall and swell.” The diction is remorseful and the imagery shows everything the speaker misses. The Frost poem has a significantly different impact. The speaker in “Choose Something Like a Star,” is looking to the stars as a sign of hope. He is looking for answers he cannot find among men. This is demonstrated in lines 9-10, “Say something to us we can learn by heart and when alone repeat.” This man is searching for answers and a source of hope that he isn’t able to attain due to his
Show More

Related Documents: John Keats Choose Something Like A Star

Comparing Poems 'Choose Something Like A Star And Keats' Bright Star

contrasting Robert Frost’s “Choose Something Like a Star” and John Keats’ “Bright Star,” has displayed the obvious similarities and differences of the two, but also the subtle implications of deeper similarities based on the lives of the two poets. Both, for their different reasons, based their poems on the steadfastness of a star. There is intimacy present in “Bright Star” versus the public concern in “Choose Something Like a Star.” There is envy of the star in Keats’ poem, where Frost appreciates…

Words 657 - Pages 3

IN WHAT WAYS DO IMAGES CONSTRUCT IDENTI Essays

mid-Eighteenth Century. Referring to Andrew Spicer’s lecture on ‘Celebrity Culture and Stardom’, naming Lord Byron, that become: “…One of the great figures of British Romanticism together with William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Shelley and Keats.”  These celebrities, as well as artists and composers, became famous, more or less on their own steam, as they were exceptionally talented in their own field, considering the fact there was no media attention, as we know it. I find it interesting…

Words 2792 - Pages 12