Justice After War Essay example

Submitted By kdr0588
Words: 3418
Pages: 14
Open Document
Sadly, there are few restraints on the endings of wars. There has never been an international treaty to regulate war's final phase, and there are sharp disagreements regarding the nature of a just peace treaty. There are, by contrast, restraints aplenty on starting wars, and on conduct during war. These restraints include: political pressure from allies and enemies; the logistics of raising and deploying force; the United Nations, its Charter and Security Council; and international laws like the Hague and Geneva Conventions. Indeed, in just war theory--which flames moral principles to regulate wartime actions--here is a robust set of rules for resorting to war (jus ad bellum) and for conduct during war (jus in bello) but not for the termination phase of war. (1) Recent events in Afghanistan, and the "war against terrorism" vividly underline the relevance of reflecting on this omission, and the complex issues related to it.

The international community should remedy this glaring gap in our ongoing struggle to restrain warfare. The following facts bear this out:

* Recent armed conflicts--in the Persian Gulf, Bosnia, Rwanda, and Kosovo--demonstrate the difficulty, and illustrate the importance, of ending wars in a full and fair fashion. We know that when wars are wrapped up badly, they sow the seeds for future bloodshed. (2)

* To allow unconstrained war termination is to allow the winner to enjoy the spoils of war. This is dangerously permissive, as winners have been known to exact peace terms that are draconian and vengeful. The Treaty of Versailles, terminating World War I, is often mentioned in this connection. (3)

* Failure to regulate war termination may prolong fighting on the ground. Since they have few assurances regarding the nature of the settlement, belligerents will be sorely tempted to keep using force to jockey for position. Many observers felt that this reality plagued the Bosnian civil war, which saw many failed negotiations and a three-year "slow burn" of continuous violence as the very negotiations took place. (4)

* Allowing war termination to be determined without normative restraints leads to inconsistency and confusion. First, how can we try to regulate the first two phases of war--the beginning and middle--yet not the end? Second, the lack of established norms to guide the construction of peace treaties leads to patchwork "solutions," mere ad hoc arrangements that may not meet well-considered standards of prudence and justice.

Peace treaties should still, of course, remain tightly tailored to the historical realities of the particular conflict in question. But admitting this is not to concede that the search for general guidelines, or universal standards, is futile or naive. There is no inconsistency, or mystery, in holding particular actors in complex local conflicts up to more general, even universal standards of conduct. Judges and juries do that daily, evaluating the factual complexities of a given case in light of general principles. We should do the same regarding war termination.

This article will consider what participants should do as they move to wrap up a war. It will do so while drawing on the resources contained within the just war tradition, particularly its reworking offered by Michael Walzer. (5) Since just war theory has played a constructive role thus far in its influence on political and legal discourse concerning launching and carrying out war, there is reason to believe it has light to shed on war termination. My goal is to construct a general set of plausible principles to guide communities seeking to resolve their armed conflicts fairly.

THE ENDS OF A JUST WAR

The first step is to answer the question: What may a participant rightly aim for with regard to a just war? What are the goals to be achieved by the settlement of the conflict? We need some starting assumptions to focus our thoughts on these issues. First, this article will consider classical cases of
Show More

Related Documents: Justice After War Essay example

Dwight D. Eisenhower: A War Hero

served in the military and was celebrated as a war hero of World War II. This image propelled him to the highest office in the land despite no political experience. Dwight D. Eisenhower took the experience that he learned from the military, and his view that war is the enemy, to shape his presidency into a great foreign and domestic leader. Dwight D. Eisenhower was born on October 14, 1890 in Denison Texas. At a very early age his family moved to Abilene. After graduating high school there Eisenhower landed…

Words 2040 - Pages 9

Difference Between Race And Criminal Justice Reform

dynamic between race, crime, and criminal justice reform is similar. Tell people that blacks are overpoliced and over-represented in prison, and it triggers thoughts of crime, which leads to fear, which causes a backfire effect as people follow their fear and embrace the status of unfair, overly punishments. The immediate takeaway is that advocates might want to try different language or a different approach in their campaign to reform the criminal justice system. Racial injustice might be the main…

Words 361 - Pages 2

Rwanda Genocide Research Paper

The Rwandan genocide began on the dawn of April 7, 1994 after a plane crash which killed both the Rwandan and Burundian Presidents. The genocide lasted for a hundred days in which many people were slaughtered by fellow Rwandans. The world media has often portrayed the genocide as an ancient tribal conflict between the majority Hutu and minority Tutsi, implying that it is a phenomenon more specific to the African population. This idea is in line with theories of conflict such as the Huntington’s Clash…

Words 1360 - Pages 6

Abraham Lincoln Research Paper

community. Later on, due to arguments of the land with the community people forced the Lincoln family to move towards Indiana in 1817. After a year later in 1818, Lincoln’s mother, Nancy passed away from a milk illness. Lincoln’s mother’s death gravely affected him, and it also strained the relationship between him and his father even more. Thomas Lincoln, after a year later remarried to a widow named, Sarah. Sarah was an affectionate woman who Lincoln seemed to bond with instantly. Neither his father…

Words 979 - Pages 4

War on Drugs Essay

The War on Drugs Renee Bailly CJA/394 April 22, 2015 Jeremy Barnett The War on Drugs “The ‘war on drugs’ that was declared in the early 1980s has been a primary contributor to the enormous growth of the prison system in the U.S. [Spell out United States here....may abbreviate after that] since that time and has affected all aspects of the criminal justice system” ("Drug Policy And The Criminal Justice System", 2001). [Remove quotations from the source information at the end...quotes…

Words 1178 - Pages 5

Cather Guenther Criminal Justice Analysis

The Criminal Justice system is often criticized, critiqued, and interpreted in many various ways. In 1976, Guenther presented his early analysis into the state of the Criminal Justice System, in which he expressed that it is “unfair, harsh, and biased”. He expresses that instead of this “unfair, harsh, and biased” Criminal Justice System, we have a Criminal Processing System. There was a comment made by Heather McDonald that opposes that view, in which she said that the Criminal Justice System is not…

Words 1722 - Pages 7

The 13th Film Analysis

Prior to watching 13th, I had a very vague and general understanding of our current criminal justice system. The movie widened my horizon in recognizing the injustice the majority of Americans see in the justice system, as well as compare modern day situations to historical methods of discrimination against specifically, African Americans. Through the modernization of the media, the world is able to receive more accurate and faster information that has led to the widespread knowledge of movements…

Words 710 - Pages 3

Immigration, Multiculturalism, And Citizenship Analysis

The article "Immigration, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship: The Development of the Canadian Social Justice Infrastructure" by Charles Ungerleider, demonstrates the policy and practice changes in Canada about immigration, citizenship and the introduction of multiculturalism by giving minorities language and human rights which has established social justice infrastructure in Canadian society after a long history of discriminatory treatment towards Aboriginals, Chinese, Indians, Jewish and Japanese…

Words 289 - Pages 2

Comparing Justice In 'Clytemnestra And Oresteia'

Justice is not as clearly defined within certain situations people face throughout their lives. In fact, the Oresteia’s first two plays enable to reader to decide for themselves what they believe to be justifiable acts of the characters, Clytemnestra and Orestes. When Clytemnestra kills Agamemnon, she expressed a lustful enjoyment that shows a lack of regret. However, when Orestes kills Clytemnestra he is conflicted and feels guilty afterwards. This shows the great contrast between the two characters…

Words 639 - Pages 3

Justice In Joseph Heller's Catch-22

Justice is something that we all wish everyone and every place in the world had. Yossarian, the main character in the novel Catch-22, by Joseph Heller, is no exception. This novel tells of a young man enlisted in the American army during World War II and stationed at Italy, Yossarian. The plot follows his past and present war adventures through flashbacks and different characters’ perspectives. We see Yossarian witness deaths of his closest friends, such as Clevinger, McWatt, Nately, Snowden, Hungry…

Words 660 - Pages 3