Logic and Circumstantial Evidence Essay

Submitted By vatimyala

Words: 328

Pages: 2

Open Document

The state argued that Mr Pistorius had had an argument with Ms Steenkamp, after which he deliberately shot her dead.

The judge ruled this had not been proved, as there was only circumstantial evidence of an argument - uncorroborated witnesses' statements.

She also dismissed witnesses who said they had heard Ms Steenkamp scream before the shots were fired, or before the final shot.

"The state has not proved beyond reasonable doubt that the accused is guilty of premeditated murder," she said. "There are just not enough facts to support such a finding."

The judge found that he consistently said he had fired in the belief there was an intruder and she had no reason to disbelieve him.

This means there was no intention to kill but the actions were negligent and not in keeping with a reasonable person.

Judge Masipa was critical of Mr Pistorius' actions, saying that he had ample time to call for help, rather than going to confront a perceived intruder with a loaded gun.

"The accused had reasonable time to reflect, to think and conduct himself reasonably.

"The accused knew that there was a person behind the door, he chose to use a firearm which was a lethal weapon, was competent in the use of firearms as he had received training," she said.

The judge also took time to reject the defence arguments that Mr Pistorius is more likely to confront danger because of his disability - both his legs have been amputated.

"Vulnerability is not unique - There are many

Examples Of Ethos In To Kill A Mockingbird

to circumstantial evidence being absent with regard to the prosecution’s claim in the Tom Robinson case, Tom also is comparatively crippled in his left arm. Atticus Finch asserts this claim when he states “What did her father do? We don’t know, but there is circumstantial evidence to indicate that Mayella Ewell was beaten savagely by someone who led most exclusively with his left” (Lee 272). By reason of Atticus Finch being a lawyer, he must use logic to corroborate his case. The use of logic in…

Words 594 - Pages 3

Proof For The Existence Of God

is the safest thing we can say without too much speculation. And, in fact, that is precisely what God is self-energetic awareness. I claim that God can be proven indirectly through very convincing circumstantial evidence and directly through personal experience. The body of circumstantial evidence that has been collected over the years is tremendous and by itself a proof simply through the overwhelming accumulation proofs. We fear death and seek assurance that survival is not only possible but…

Words 2330 - Pages 10

Critical Thinking Primer Essay

The unit that you are enrolled in is strictly not a logic, philosophy or even critical thinking skills course. As such, this is not an in-depth treatment of critical thinking though some terms and definitions are necessary but rather how to put into practice a few basic critical thinking skills in order to perform some critical analysis and evaluation of a situation using theory, models or frameworks. Disclaimer: the contents here in no way constitute or form a specific or general method of performing…

Words 3043 - Pages 13

The Twelve Angry Men Juror 3 and Juror 8 Comparing Essay

Comparison essay comparing Juror 3 and Juror 8 What are some similarities between Jurors 3 and 8? What about differences? Oh gosh, it's been years since I've seen the movie (didn't read the play). Okay, Juror #3 is the angry father, and Juror #8 is the guy who stands alone in the INNOCENT vote, right? I suspect the similarities are easier to find by reading the play because the movie really shows their contrasts. There is one similarity in that when they really believe something, they…

Words 1921 - Pages 8

Fallacy: Fallacy and Argument Essays

argument on the logic of its presentation; that is, whether the premises lead to a valid conclusion. It is irrelevant whether or not we agree with the conclusion; we need to be able to assess whether the conclusion is based on sound premises and reasons. The more we seek to analyse others’ arguments, the better we become at constructing our own arguments. Many people claim to be arguing rationally and logically, when all they are doing is asserting their scepticism. If there is no evidence to support…

Words 5195 - Pages 21

Essay about Study Guide

areas. Diction, syntax, and mechanics are excessively flawed. Fails to accomplish the goals of the assignment. Summary: Philosophy may be divided into three fields: physics (the study of the physical world), ethics (the study of morals), and logic (the study of logical principles). These fields may involve either "empirical" study of our experiences, or "pure" analysis of concepts. "Metaphysics" is the study of pure concepts as they relate to moral or physical experience. People generally presume…

Words 5286 - Pages 22

Essay about Asbergers Report

Asperger syndrome From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Asperger syndrome Classification and external resources People with Asperger syndrome often display intense interests, such as this boy's fascination with molecular structure. ICD-10 F84.5 ICD-9 299.80 OMIM 608638 DiseasesDB 31268 MedlinePlus 001549 eMedicine ped/147 MeSH F03.550.325.100 Asperger syndrome (AS), also known as Asperger's syndrome or Asperger disorder (AD), is an autism spectrum disorder (ASD) that is characterized…

Words 9740 - Pages 39