Mr J Davies Essay

Submitted By jamesd246
Words: 1794
Pages: 8
Open Document
‘Managing suppliers through long term collaborative relationships constitutes best practice’. To what extent do you agree?

Collaboration is ‘’the process by which partners adopt a high level of purposeful cooperation to maintain a trading relationship over time. The relationship is bilateral; both parties have the power to shape its nature and future direction over time.’’ (Monczka, Trent and Handfield). Examples of long term collaboration include Microsoft and Novell. In 2006 the two companies announced ‘’broad business and technical collaborations’’ to provide products that function better when used together. This partnership would be in place until at least 2012.
Research has shown that businesses will benefit from collaboration (Dyer and Singh, 1998). However there are certain criteria that will affect the level of success of collaboration (Singh and Mitchell 1996). In the essay I will look at the positives and negatives of collaboration and look at the factors that contribute to the levels of success companies will gain from a collaborative relationship with their suppliers.

In order to establish if long term collaboration is a positive practices it is necessary to look at the factors that influence a company’s decision to collaborate with its suppliers. Supplier selection is vital when choosing who to collaborate with; ideally the buyer wants to be the dominant player in the relationship but also wants a competent supplier. In order to get one of these options a buyer usually has to sacrifice the other. Acquiring a competent supplier is particularly valuable if the buyer is diversifying into new areas and is relatively inexperience. However, a competent supplier will hold more power as they know they have a superior product to other less competent companies. The diagram below shows that the ideal supplier would be in the gray shaded area. In this area you have a supplier that is fully competent yet the buyer is still dominant and has the power. Suppliers such as this would make the best collaborative partners for the producer.
However one advantage of a long term collaborative relationship is that through investment the buyer may be able to improve the competence of the supplier and push them closer towards the gray area without loosing the power in the relationship. This is known as supplier development; ‘’A bilateral effort by both the buying and supplying organizations to jointly improve the supplier’s performance’’ (Krause and Handfield)
| |Buyer Dominance |
|Buyer-Supplie| |
|r Power | |
| |Buyer - Supplier Equality |
| |Buyer Dependence |
| |

Collaboration does have its negatives and pitfalls; it can be a time consuming and costly to begin a collaborative relationship. Direct costs are likely to include new labour, training and new research and development. Other cost maybe incurred in order to facilitate efficiency between the buyer and supplier. It will be necessary for the buyer to release information about the company; therefore security will be an issue. A company is liable to loose its competitive advantage if important information is leaked to competitors.
Problems will also arise if the two companies have different company cultures. A culture clash may occur if the two companies hold different attitudes on how day to day business should be carried out. There may be information barriers if the two companies use different methods of communication and unifying these methods will again require time and investment.
It is becoming more common to have suppliers in different countries to take advantage of cheaper labour; this may add a language barrier as well as time zone differences which can lead to delays in relaying information and inefficiency. Companies need to find ways around such
Show More

Related Documents: Mr J Davies Essay

Hawkins V Clayton Case Summary Essay

Jurisdiction: High Court of Australia Before: C.J Mason J. Wilson J. Brennan J. Deane J. Gaudron Catchwords: Negligence - Duty of care - Solicitor - Will held by solicitor - Failure to inform executor of death of testator and of contents - Whether duty to do so - Loss to estate caused by executor's ignorance of death - Measure of damages. Limitation of Actions - Tort - Accrual of cause of action -…

Words 1082 - Pages 5

The lottery STUDY GUIDE Essay

of stones. Mr. Martin: Bobby Martin's father. He operates a grocery store. Mrs. Martin: Wife of Mr. Martin. Joe Summers: Coal dealer who conducts the lottery. He has no children. Mr. Summers's Wife: Shrewish woman. Mr. Graves: Postmaster. He assists Mr. Summers. Mrs. Graves: Wife of the postmaster. Old Man Warner: Oldest man in town. Tessie Hutchinson: Woman who arrives late for the lottery. Bill Hutchinson: Husband of Mrs. Hutchinson. Bill Jr., Nancy, Little Dave: Children of Mr. and Mrs. Hutchinson…

Words 3132 - Pages 13

Assignment On Business Law For Managers

Assignment On Business Law for Managers Prepared By LCA Student Num: Anglia Ruskin ID: Prepared For Date of Submission 10 January 2014 Word Count: 3,944 Academic Year: 2013/14 Acknowledgement I am thankful to many people who have supported and advised me during the writing of this assignment. I am grateful to my honourable supervisor Ms. Christina Mccarthy, for his guidelines and several corrections. Without his proper lectures this study could not be done. I am also thankful to…

Words 4414 - Pages 18

Task Centred and Crisis Intervention Essay for Social Work

encouraged user participation, as one of its characteristics is that it is short term and time limited. I also felt that it would empower J and build a working alliance, which was centred on a negotiated agreement. The agreement covered the nature of the problems experienced, the agreed goals and the time limit for the work. It involves careful exploration of problems with J, from her perspective. This stage is an essential foundation for the next, which…

Words 3872 - Pages 16

Essay on Critical Analysis of Patient Care Utilising John’s Model of Structured Reflection

The complex nature of septic shock and MODS is one good example where proactive and creative nursing measures need to be implemented. In dealing with Mr Cox, I was caught in the situation where critical decision-making was required to determine the priority of care. My awareness of the nursing process (assessment, nursing diagnosis, planning, intervention and evaluation) and the background knowledge…

Words 5701 - Pages 23

Discuss the phrase “wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business” Essay

guests. The company whose trade was in brewery with its properties of brewers and inns wanted to claim the compensation and repair costs of the chimney as a deduction against their trade profits and was subsequently denied by the House of Lords. Lord Davy, a member of the House of law explained in 5TC page 220 that although the compensation was related to its trade, it does not hinder Strong & Co of Romsey Ltd.’s ability to carry on and earn their profits. He would later describe that only expenditures…

Words 2209 - Pages 9

Letters To Iwo Jima

Scott Rice Japanese Culture Through Film Mrs. Sigler 11/25/14 War Morals: Japan vs. America I have learned a lot while taking this Japanese culture through film class. I never really truly knew how the Japanese were in everyday life. While taking this class I learned a lot of interesting things that I am glad I learned. One of the main things I learned was how dedicated Japanese are to their country and to their beliefs, which I found out that the majority of Japanese people share quite similar beliefs…

Words 1455 - Pages 6

B 52 Essay

The B-52 Stratofortress & Its Constant Evolution When one thinks of aircraft, one of the most notable names is Boeing. To say that Boeing aircraft have revolutionized the industry, both from a defense and commercial perspective, would not be an overstatement. This assessment will focus on the Boeing B-52 Stratofortress, a long-range, strategic heavy bomber with enhanced capability. The flexibility that the aircraft possesses separates it from others within the industry, even the most strategic of…

Words 3108 - Pages 13

SAORA Newsletter 2 November 2014 Essay example

1 S .A.O.R.A. newsletter November 2014 PRESIDENT ’S R E P ORT N o v e m be r , 2 0 1 4 Another year has flown past, I am not sure whether it’s the aging process or simply the pace at which we are moving that makes each year go faster. SAORA has had a very successful year. Despite the weather, our 111th birthday celebration in March was a wonderful, happy day. It was so heart-warming Philippa Crichton - President this year to have some of the youngest Old Girls and two of the oldest Old Girls…

Words 4253 - Pages 18

Annotated Bibliography Essay

com/docview/1418458128?accountid=11530 This article explains the connection between the federal government and the increasing use of social networks. Federal government employees have been using social media for personal use and also for professional purposes. Mr. Bratton talks about the role of ethical practices that take place within the global business market. It seems that in the past members of the federal government have not acted in the most ethical way and therefore have experienced some negativity when…

Words 2931 - Pages 12