Northern Ireland Assembly Essay

Submitted By adammmtay
Words: 1147
Pages: 5
Open Document
JUNE 2009
Assess the extent to which the Assembly has made the government of Northern Ireland more democratic. [26]

The assembly of Northern Ireland which was established after the Good Friday Agreement and the Northern Ireland Act 1998 has for various reasons made NI more democratic. Under The GFA and consequently the St Andrews agreement the democratic deficit no longer exists that was evident under direct rule, the representative and scrutiny functions now in place can be viewed as more democratic to a certain extent while the power sharing executive formed from the assembly has also provided more democracy. There are however limitations with the assembly that suggest it is not totally more democratic and still lacks complete democracy.

The fact a scrutiny function is now in place suggests there is more democracy. Under direct rule this was non-existent with policies made by MPs from Westminster not being scrutinised and with MPs not being held accountable. Now within the assembly the committees take on the role of scrutiny. The main form of scrutiny comes from statutory committees. They hold the executive to account by examining each department and their ministers. They do this by looking at the actions and policies of the minister and suggesting amendments, criticising the minister and proposing legislation. They have the power to get expertise from outsiders and form a collective bond from the permanent nature of the committees meaning they are well placed to scrutinise. Scrutiny also comes in the form of debates that occur every Monday and Tuesday; here policies are debated and scrutinised. A recent example of this is the debate on abortion which produced a wide range of views and scrutinised a policy brought forward by the DUP and SDLP that suggested abortion should only be administered by the NHS .There is however a suggestion that a real lack of an opposition limits the democratic nature of the assembly with parties from the executive also being in the committees. There is doubt that real scrutiny can take place if a party is forced to scrutinise the work of itself. Also debates rarely change anything for example the recent debate on the shared future document had already been agreed by Sinn Fein and DUP which like most bills and policies already decide what is going to happen with their majorities.

The representation function of the assembly has made the government of NI more democratic. We now have a system were the people governing us are now voted in by the electorate, something that was not evident under direct rule. With the democratic Single transferable vote which is a form of proportional representation in place the seats a party attains in the assembly is equivalent to their vote share. This system has given the Nationalist parties more influence as they achieve more seats than they did under the old first past the post system. Sinn Fein for example are now in a position of more power with 29 seats as their vote is spread across the country. With 6 MLAs per constituency now representing the electorate in the assembly it is clear this is far more democratic than the MPs from Westminster deciding legislation.

The forced coalition of parties in the NI executive from the assembly which is in place can be viewed as more democratic. It gives all parties the opportunity to participate in the executive if they achieve enough votes, this is done through D’hont which allocates ministerial seats on the basis of party strength in the assembly, and this means that the parties and personal we decide to elect are actually governing us under a system that fairly distributes executive seats. This forms a cabinet style government that is able to work collectively and produce better legislation than their Westminster counterparts who had no real interest or desire for NI and its growth. The assembly term between 2007 and 2011 for example produced 69 bills and lasted the full term with EC reaching around 50% of
Show More

Related Documents: Northern Ireland Assembly Essay

United Kingdom and Northern Ireland assembly Essay

states on issues such as: * The environment, * Equal opportunities, * Transport, * Consumer rights, * Movement of workers and goods. Next in level of importance I would put the Devolved Assemblies. UK Devotion created a national Parliament in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. This process transfers levels of the power in the UK Parliament. Devolution is a process whereby power is transferred from a centralised government organisation to a regional organisation. Devolution consists…

Words 1631 - Pages 7

Social Democratic and Labour Party and Northern Ireland Essay

driving forces for peace in Northern Ireland under leader John Hume and deputy leader Seamus Mallon in particular. The party advocates a united Ireland but not one in which a new minority is simply created. It also proposes the abolition of the 11+ exams, greater protection for agricultural and rural communities and greater environmental standards. The SDLP were the first to advocate the so-called principle of "consent" recognising that fundamental changes in Northern Ireland's constitutional…

Words 330 - Pages 2

Referenda: Election and Outcome Essay examples

governments from losing voters at the next general election. For example, the 1998 peace settlement in Northern Ireland, there was a turnout of 81%, which means that this was a very popular question set forward, with a vast mass of the public having an opinion on it; with the yes vote receiving 71.7% and the no vote receiving 28.9%. If the government had decided not to make a peace settlement with Ireland, then a small amount of people would have been satisfied with the outcome. However, they also represent…

Words 918 - Pages 4

Essay Government 3

citizens. To vote you have to be electoral register. The Single Transferable Vote system is used to elect the ‘Deputy Speakers’ in the House of Commons. STV is also used for electing the Northern Ireland Assembly, local elections in Scotland and Northern Ireland and European Parliament elections in Northern Ireland. Multi-member constituencies are required for STV which means constituencies are normally larger but elect several representatives rather than just one. Under STV, voters rank candidates…

Words 640 - Pages 3

Critically compare and contrast two case studies and assess the success or failure of SSR efforts Essay

reform in Northern Ireland and South Africa. While initially as Northern Ireland continued to negotiate a peace process it seemed that lessons could be learnt from the settlement in South Africa, however it is now the programme of security sector reform undertaken in Northern Ireland that is most often held up as the blueprint for successful reform for other post-conflict countries. This essay will compare and contrast security sector reform efforts in South Africa and Northern Ireland in terms of…

Words 2712 - Pages 11

The Precarious Nature Of Faulkner's Corruption In The June Election Of 1973

the situation in Northern Ireland during 1973 and 1974? The year 1972 saw the death toll soar to its highest in the 25 years of the Troubles, as a result the British Prime Minister suspended Stormont and Northern Ireland was placed under direct rule from Westminster. Edward Heath was concerned law and order was about to completely breakdown in N Ireland and felt rapid reforms were needed to regain control of the rapidly deteriorating situation. However the problems in N Ireland were deep rooted…

Words 2003 - Pages 9

Essay about Segregation Final Upload

the Irish labour market and ethnic residential segregation in contemporary Ireland. It will first discuss how gender segregation is present today in the Irish labour market, north and south. The Irish labour market has undergone significant change over the last ten years (Barry and Sherlock, 2008). The level of employment has risen due to an increase in women’s paid employment and increasing levels of migration into Ireland (Barry, Potter and Healy, 2007; Barry and Sherlock, 2008). Gender segregation…

Words 3331 - Pages 14

Critically Analyse 5p carrier bag levy in Northern Ireland Essay examples

banners around the store will ease this problem. Further to this, an argument from the British Retail Consortium (BRC) points out that the Northern Ireland Assembly cannot both accumulate revenue on the taxation of bags and reduce the use of bags as it will mean that if one goal succeeds the other will fail (Gordon, 2011). In contrast to BRC, the Northern Ireland government services explain that the levy is not about raising money; it is about changing habits and improving the environment, for a healthy…

Words 1420 - Pages 6

Essay on Critical Comparison Between Budgeting Methodologies of for Profit Educational Institutions and Public University

Literature Numerous studies have been conducted on budgeting and its impacts on organisational performance. Budget is generally defined as an estimation of revenues and expenses over a specified future period of time. Harper (1995) as cited in Northern Ireland Assembly (2010) listed various functions fulfilled by budgeting, which consists of mapping, controlling, co-ordinating, communicating, instructing, authorising, motivating, performance measurement and decision-making. Community Accounting National…

Words 2851 - Pages 12

GB Briefing Paper

Irish Republic's withdrawal from the union. The postwar years were a time of great moral disillusionment. In addition to disarmament, reparations , and war deb ts, came domestic economic problems, the task of reorganizing the British Empire , and the conflict with Ireland. The wartime alliance of Great Britain, the USSR, and the United States led to the formation of the United Nations . Leadership in world trade, shipping, and banking had passed to the United States, and overseas investments had been largely liquidated to pay the cost of the world wars…

Words 1474 - Pages 6