Odysseus Decision To Die In Homer's Odyssey

Words: 664

Pages: 3

Open Document

If you knew someone was going to die tomorrow, would you tell them? Odysseus was in a similar situation in the Odyssey, an epic poem by Homer when he knew that his crew was going to die according to some prophecies, but he kept that information to himself. Odysseus’s decision to withhold information about the prophecies of Tiresias and Circe was the right choice because telling the crew may have caused different reactions among them, it prevents the crew from worrying about future events and giving up, and it forces the crew to give all their effort in the face of death. If Odysseus were to tell his crew about the prophecies and how they might die, they could have been able to brush it off and keep fighting, or they could have given up completely. Odysseus had fought alongside these men for at least ten years, but everyone reacts to their death …show more content…
Even though they were scared when they came across Scylla and Charybdis, the crew acted on instinct in order to escape death. Odysseus wanted them to live or die trying, so the crew followed his order and gave all of their efforts. If Zeus had not destroyed their ship, they surely would have helped Odysseus to keep trying to get home to Ithaca. The entire crew gave all they could, but Odysseus had no way of knowing if they were going to act this way if they had knowledge of the prophecies beforehand. Odysseus did what he thought was right as the leader of the crew by keeping the fact that the crew was going to die a secret. He made sure that they would not act differently because of their fateful death by avoiding breaking the news in the first place. If Odysseus told his crew that they were going to die, they could have made the situation worse by giving up or taking matters into their own hands regarding their death. If you were Odysseus, wouldn’t you save your crew from losing hope

The Punishment Of Odysseus In Homer's The Odyssey

Imagine a king lost at sea for twenty years with no way to reach his kingdom. In Homer’s The Odyssey, an epic hero, Odysseus, undergoes many situations and adventures. Toward the end of the book, after finally arriving to his home of Ithaca, Odysseus is exposed to those who infringe his island. Odysseus now has to consider decisions on how to punish these people who have created such a dilemma at his castle. Odysseus’ deportment at the end of the book is unjustifiable; his punishments do not fit the…

Words 740 - Pages 3

Odysseus As An Epic Hero In Homer's The Odyssey

hero. The main character of Homer's The Odyssey is a well-known example of this. Odysseus is a well-respected man and through his trials we see heroism shine through. Human characteristics depicted throughout the many trials Odysseus faced makes him an epic hero. Odysseus shows his cunningest the most throughout the book. The man of twists and turns tends to use his tricks and craftiness to get what he wants, however, that does not go as planned in the first trial. Odysseus becomes very prideful in…

Words 940 - Pages 4

inter questions Essay

demonstrated during his quest home. The Odyssey is one of the two major Greek epic poems written by Homer. It is a sequel to Iliad, which describes the fictional conflict between a coalition of Greeks and the occupants of Troy, known as The Trojan War. After the Greeks victoriously end the war, due to Odysseus’s cunning Trojan horse subterfuge, the Greeks are faced with even more danger in their long voyage back to Greece. Odysseus, the protagonist of Homer’s epic poem, is one of the last few Greeks…

Words 1742 - Pages 7

How Is Odysseus Noble Or Noble

man or a hero? To answer this question simply, absolutely not, but in Homer’s epic poem, The Odyssey, Odysseus is considered one of the greatest heroes along with being a very noble man, while his actions would say otherwise. The story begins with Odysseus’ son, Telemachus at his home in Ithaca. At his home, there are many suitors waiting to be chosen to wed the thought to be widowed, Queen Penelope. Everyone believes Odysseus to be dead because he has been gone at the Trojan war and on his journey…

Words 2092 - Pages 9

Essay about The Odyssey

Homer’s The Odyssey: A Moments That Molds You Journal Entry #2 Part One: Throughout all of our lives we all have moments that defines who we are and what type of person we are. Whether it be an insignificant situation or a large situation our lives are all provoked on what has and will happen to us. When placed in a stressful decision making situation we all act on instinct. In a spilt second you can decide on what you need to do and that decision could change your life. With that being said…

Words 1692 - Pages 7

Achilles: The Ancient Greek Hero from the Movie Troy Essay

brother, Agamemnon, who is only too happy to oblige, though Agamemnon's decision comes mostly from his desire to sack Troy. Odysseus (Sean Bean), king of Ithaca and under command of Agamemnon, goes to convince Achilles to accompany them in the conquest of Troy. He finds him sparring with his young cousin, Patroclus (Garrett Hedlund), who is more than eager to join in the fighting. But Achilles refuses to go, despite Odysseus' assurance that this war will go down into history. Achilles later seeks…

Words 9856 - Pages 40