Peer Editor: xxx
Writer: xxx
Content
Yes
No
Appropriate title
Introduction
Purpose: Describes report purpose
Problem: Reviews background or history of problem
Describes problem
Identifies what in general needs to be done
Explains what happens if problem is addressed
Explain what happens if problem is left unaddressed
Problem sections read smoothly
Scope: Describes specific solution
Identifies what report will cover and why
Identifies what report will not cover and why
Discussion
#1 Explanation: Definition: Qualifier (if needed) + Name + Class + Differentiation
Criterion is specific and focuses on only one area
Explains why criterion was chosen
Identifies criterion weighting
Explains why criterion weighted so
Data: Reports findings without comparing
Interpretation: States reason why each model is/isn’t preferred
Identifies preferred solution
#2 Explanation: Definition: Qualifier (if needed) + Name + Class + Differentiation
Criterion is specific and focuses on only one area
Explains why criterion was chosen
Identifies criterion weighting
Explains why criterion weighted so
Data: Reports findings without comparing
Interpretation: States reason why each model is/isn’t preferred
Identifies preferred solution
#3 Explanation: Definition: Qualifier (if needed) + Name + Class + Differentiation
Criterion is specific and focuses on only one area
Explains why criterion was chosen
Identifies criterion weighting
Explains why criterion weighted so
Data: Reports findings without comparing
Interpretation: States reason why each model is/isn’t preferred
Identifies preferred solution
Conclusion
Summary: Provides concise, objective abstract of report/findings
Includes a Table
Conclusions
Explains why some preferences are more or less important than others
Reader gets a clear sense of which