Political Economy of Iran Essay

Submitted By broder22
Words: 1193
Pages: 5
Open Document
The political economy of a Semi-industrialized theocratic state: the Islamic republic of Iran
This chapter uses the case of Iran to explore 3 main propositions
For semi-industrialised theocracy is essentially similar to secular dictatorship (economically not socially)
Economics guideline followed to keep clerics in power not on Islamic doctrine
Guiding of political and economic affairs by duality of government (governmental and clergy)
The Iranian Religious Context
Islam, Theocracy, and the Origins of Clerical Power in Iran
-Nations with large share of muslim populations manifest lower level of democracy than other developing nations, have more male orientated, show more skew to military governemnts
-Early life of muhammed – he governed, collected taxes, commanded armies, dispensed justice. Next 4 caliphs followed this however then Sunni Shia split – Sunni accepted more secular caliph whereas shia wanted more divine insipiration. Important thing BOTH wanted strong role of Sharia Principles
-Since 19th century religious figures have played a visible and sometimes critical role in Iranian politics Ayotollahs said only those learned in Islamic way have right to govern
-after departure of shah, theocracy debate was alive – nevertheless constitution (approved by referendum) enshrined religious leaders had final right – despite revolution brought upon by multiplicity of groups religious leaders capitalized on it most (others had been marginalised)
-essential issue of defining Iran’s government
Classical Islam . . . did not recognize a separate institution, with a hierarchy and laws of its own, to regulate religious matters. Does this mean that Islam is a theocracy? In the sense that God is seen as the supreme sovereign, the answer would have to be yes indeed. In the sense of government by a priesthood, most definitely not. The emergence of a priestly hierarchy and its assumption of ultimate authority in the state is a modern innovation and is a unique contribution of the late Ayatollah Khomeini of Iran to Islamic thought and practice.” Bernard Lewis 2003

-essential issue of defining Iran’s government
-(last paragraph entails powers of religious leader ship – they are basically ALL POWERFUL and concludes with “Under this and other constitutional rules, it is impossible legally for the clergy to be removed from, or voted out of, political leadership”

Islam and economic (1 and 2 islamic – rest about iran)

-Islamic nations do not have economic institutions much different from those of other developing countries (backed by empirics) (e.g. the banning of interest in Islamic law is not major prohibition in laws of Islamic countries)

-Islamic doctrine for economics is quite vague (elements of capitalism present traditionally in Islam) however in Islamic countries have put in significantly more regulations

-Khamene’i was willing to accept some pragmatic economic reforms to moderate some irrationalities in Iranian economy. Also more emphasis on political power e.g. strengthening Supreme national security council (this tightening clerical control) and has worked to develop strong ties with revolutionary guard and the basij volunteer morality squad. From this power base he has interfered more with economy (e.g. giving shares to poor people by privatising big industries)

-President has more power on less important issues – Ahmadinejad advocated a full-scale populist programmes (e.g. reallocated Oil Stabilization Funds to numerous Islamic groups for poor, subsidies for consumption goods)

The Iranian context
Economic Legacy of Shah
-Under shah economy did well – 2 decades of rapid economic growth(empirical figures given, quote impressive change)
-Proportion of government role increase from 8.5% to 23% (government consumption in economy)
-criticisms that reserves being exhausted, agrarian ruined, income inequality
-main criticism of the shah was overuse of repression (ironically forces helping shah
Show More

Related Documents: Political Economy of Iran Essay

Anan: Iran and Strong Political Relationship Essay

Causes of weak economy of Iran Iran is a country in the Middle East, which is rich in resources such as oil and gas; even though, it is a rich country, it has a weak economy. In 1979, when Iranian Government completely had changed, the new government cut off their connection and relationship with many countries such as America because Iran Islamic regime believe that the West is its enemy, so its effected other countries which have strong political relationship with Unites States. From that…

Words 422 - Pages 2

Economics: Income and Rentier State Essay

world. Two countries, which both share common characteristics of rentier states, are Iran and Nigeria, controlled by autocratic regimes, not accountable to its citizens. However, the true distinguishing factor of rentier states is how they are doomed to failure in the long-term. The highlights to this theory are the vulnerabilities of a mono-producer, the disparities in rentier economies, and the social and political repercussions that result from this. The most important characteristic of a rentier…

Words 1432 - Pages 6

Iran Hostage Crisis Research Paper

Andres Morris Mrs. Higgins 1B 2 March 2024 The Iranian Hostage Crisis For decades, Iran and the United States have been at odds with one another. The Iranian revolution against the Pahlavi dynasty, whose leader was supported by the United States, was a significant precursor to the Iranian Hostage Crisis of 1979 through 1980. When the revolution broke out, the United States harbored Mohammed Reza Pahlavi, the Shah of Iran at the time, which outraged Iranian citizens. Later, armed and angry, Iranian citizens…

Words 1971 - Pages 8

Essay on Iran: Iran and Qajar Period

Review of Modern Iran: Roots and Results of the Revolution By Nikki Keddie Religious, social, political and economical issues are often the main causes of most revolutions; however, as Keddie explains in Modern Iran; Roots and Results of Revolution, the Iranian revolution of 1979 is an exception. While one may try to classify this revolution into one of the more common categories such as religious, political, social or economic, the fact of the matter is that never can one of such proposals cause…

Words 1976 - Pages 8

The Theoretical Perspective Of Realism And Exploring The Iranian Nuclear Issue

diplomatic tools and ways for the government of Iran to abandon the nuclear weapons program. It is said the Rrealistm Theoretical theoretical perspective has dominated thinking about iInternational politicscies over a millennia, realists claim to view the world as it ought to be. “Realists tend to hold pessimistic views on the likelihood of the transformation of the current world into a more peaceful one, emphasizing the struggle for power among political units each acting in a rational, unitary manner…

Words 950 - Pages 4

A Brief Note On The Islamic Republic Of Iran

Established in 1979, the Islamic Republic of Iran is a country rich in history, culture, scientific growth and economic opportunity. Despite sanctions imposed by western civilizations due to Iran's nuclear activity and resistance from more traditional leaders who oppose western cultural influences, Iran represents an opportunistic market for business…

Words 5330 - Pages 22

Making Islam Democratic: Social Movements And The Post-Islamist Turn

Book: Making Islam Democratic: Social Movements and the Post-Islamist Turn. Publisher: Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2007. Hardcover: 320 pages ISBN-10: 0804755949 ISBN-13: 978-0804755948 Key-words: democracy, Egypt, Iran, Islam, Middle East, political history, political theology. Reviewed by: Jacob Greenberg hile other disciplines in the social sciences and humanities have made use of comparative methodologies, History has been slow to join the trend. Most historical analyses investigate a…

Words 1091 - Pages 5

Final Paper Iran

History of Iran The Islamic Republic of Iran, known as Persia till 1935, has been a very unstable country over the past 74 years with problems like civil war, government corruption, and major disputes with neighboring countries. Most of these problems have been solved but some are still very relevant in the 21 century; also the nation has seen a whole new set of problems arise as well. These present days problems include terrorism, nuclear weapon sanctions, economy, and foreign policy. Iran also shows…

Words 2514 - Pages 11

Essay on Iran: Islam and Private Sector Activity

Iran's economy is marked by an inefficient state sector, reliance on the oil sector, which provides the majority of government revenues, and statist policies, which create major distortions throughout the system. Most economic activity is controlled by the state. Private sector activity is typically limited to small-scale workshops, farming, and services. Price controls, subsidies, and other rigidities weigh down the economy, undermining the potential for private-sector-led growth. Significant…

Words 754 - Pages 4

Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi Essay

who spoke up and made a difference, people, like Marjane Satrapi. Graphic novelist Marjane Satrapi was born on November 22, 1969 in Rasht, an Iranian coastal city (Luebering). Satrapi was raised by her secular, Westernized and Marxist parents in Tehran, Iran (Luebering; Satrapi 3). Although she has written many books, it is the first of her two autobiographical books, Persepolis , that I want to draw your attention to. In Persepolis , little Marjane starts off as a six year old. She tells the story of her life and…

Words 659 - Pages 3