Political Power Essay

Submitted By saliashass22
Words: 2725
Pages: 11
Open Document
1129674 – Salimah Alias

‘A gets B to do something that he or she would not otherwise do’. Does this sum up the essence of political power?

As a whole, this statement sufficiently provides an overarching view of political power in the pres ence of conflict. However, according to Steven Lukes, we need to acknowledge the existence of more comprehensive conceptions of political power, especially in the absence of a direct conflict of interest. This essay will attempt to use his arguments to demonstrate the nuances that underpin political power and will contextualise using the various case studies ranging from the politics in China to USA. Furthermore, it will attempt to evaluate the extent of success certain approaches of political power have over others. Ultimately it will demonstrate that political power has evolved in accordance to the sophistication of the population and this has demanded radical shifts in the way those in power govern them.

Analysis of Definition Provided

Before approaching the concept of political power in depth, a brief analysis of the statement given is in order. The definition, falling under the pluralist school of thought is broad enough that it highlights the basic idea of political power in successfully getting someone to achieve what one party ones, and it enables one to look into a more comprehensive conception of power. It prompts us to consider the means in which this is achieved either via coercion, force or manipulation and influence and enables us to question the legitimacy, authority and extent of political power across various levels.

However, an extension of this statement is necessary if we wish to encompass the evolving nature of political power. Approaching it from a constructivist point of view in which perceptions are created for the purpose of achieving power. Perhaps one which states that ‘A gets B to do what B would not otherwise do to the point that B accepts A’s point of view as his own unquestioningly’. In this respect, we can see that political power has overcome the conflict of interests and achieved a modus operandi that is much more sustainable as compared to overt force or a system of threats and inducements - not always guaranteeing submission. Hence as the essay continues, let us observe the ascension of this mode of political power.
Power and Interests
Underlying the basis of power is the relationship between the agent and the one being acted upon. The variable that will undergo change is the interests or desires of the one in which action is being exerted on. This can be defined as interests or naturally imbued desires. Reformists deplore that not everyone's wants are given equal weight by the political system. The radical maintains that people's wants may themselves be a product of a system which works against their interests and in such cases relates the latter to what they would want and prefer were they able to make the choice. And the liberal takes people as they are and applies want-regarding principles to them relating their interest to what they actually want or prefer. (Lukes, 2002) For the purpose of this essay, it will tend towards the view of the radical in paving an answer for the future of political power paradigms.
The Three Dimensions of Power
We will now address Lukes’ denominations of power in three dimensions, which critiques outwardly the statement in question.
One-Dimensional View
“A has power over B to the extent that he can get B to do something that B would not otherwise do” (Dahl 1957, p. 201)
The first statement refers to A's capacity while the second specifies a successful attempt - difference between potential and actual power, between its possession and its exercise. The focus on observable behaviour in identifying power demonstrates the pluralists’ method in studying decision-making as their central task. Dahl argues that identifying 'who prevails in decision making' seems the best way to determine which
Show More

Related Documents: Political Power Essay

Essay on Economic: Political Philosophy and Power

CHAPTER 14 Power, Politics, and Organizational Justice CHAPTER OVERVIEW We begin by briefly revisiting the concept of influence. Although we introduced influence at the beginning of Chapter 12 as a basis for defining leadership, we now examine influence a bit more completely, and also describe a specific form of influence known as impression management. We then discuss power in its myriad forms in organizations. Politics and political behavior are then introduced and described in detail. Finally…

Words 9519 - Pages 39

Niccole Machiavelli's Influence On Political Power

his book The Prince,which is one of the most influential works on political power in the western world. Many writers followed prince’s ethics when it came to politics. According to the textbook, “His views on politics have had a profound influence on political leaders who followed.” This was proven when political leaders started to follow his views. Without Machiavelli’s political views and the book The Prince, Political power may not have as many followers or be as strong as it is today.…

Words 101 - Pages 1

Political And Power In Upton Sinclair's The Jungle

social activists” who investigate “sordid conditions of stockyard workers” working under critical conditions under factories and corporations (Buzzanco, 1). This social analysis relates to the theme of Political and Power because the investigation uncovered “work on corporate malfeasance and urban political corruption” that immigrants and the working class had to endure. Sinclair revealed the unhealthy conditions that production companies had for their workers though his book, The Jungle. The book…

Words 184 - Pages 1

US Power reflected on the global political economy Essay

Yohanan Zemichael PSCI 2602: A03 October 11, 2012 The framework of global political economy has evolved through a series of historical periods. For this paper, I will be comparing the overall structure and organization of the global political economy during the Bretton Woods period (1945-1975) and the Contemporary period (1975-2010). The main objective will be the United States’ projection of political power throughout these two historical periods. By comparing, the Bretton Woods period and…

Words 1157 - Pages 5

Nations States Super States And The Scaling Of Political Power MOODLE Essay

superstates and the scaling of political power The state in a shrinking world? • Link to previous lectures: in the context of a ‘shrinking world’, all older certainties seem to be under threat • What is happening, then, to what is arguably the most taken-for-granted unit of political power in the modern world: namely, the state? • Is the state – as an idea / a way of organising political life – under threat? • Is it perhaps ceasing to have relevance, indeed power, in the face of a crazily speeded-up…

Words 1262 - Pages 6

Why Did Henry Viii Break with Rome? Essay

economic (money), political (power), religious (faith) and personal (love)reasons. One reason for the break with Rome was political reasons (power) because after losing most his finance in battle against the king of Spain, Francis I, who was angry at Henry for embarrassing his aunt Catherine of Aragon who at this time was Henry’s wife. When Henry found out the amount of power the Catholic Church in England had, he thought if he changed the Religion in England the amount of Power he would have…

Words 36620 - Pages 147

Essay on Persistence Of Elites

Persistence, of Power, Elites, and Institutions and Missing the Story The two articles Persistence, Power, Elites, and Institutions and Missing the Story both concentrate on the fact that the impact of institutions on economic outcomes depends on the interaction between de jure political power, political institutions, and de facto political power, the investments and organizations of different groups. In the first article by Acemoglu and Robinson, these ideas are developed into a model consisting…

Words 559 - Pages 3

Difference Between Economic And Economic Power

Ralu Nwosu Civic and Economics Mr. Manriquez 9/22/13 How should political and economical power be distributed in a society. Economic power should be held by those who have earned it. Political power should be held by elected officials who are responsible to their constituents. Since we have power is divided in our society most of the power is in our politicians we trust in and give our votes to. But when it comes to economical, some of the richest people in society share it too,…

Words 348 - Pages 2

19th Century European Imperialism: An Analysis

In the 19th century European colonization had begun in Africa. Two of the largest European colonial powers were France and Britain. “Europe justified its colonization of Africa on grounds that it was its moral duty to uplift Africans from their primitive state.” (Graham, 2013, p.106) These European colonial powers believed that they were trying to ‘civilize’ the people of Africa. They believed it was their “Manifest Destiny” to take over Africa.” (Graham, 2013, p.106) They had these motives because…

Words 524 - Pages 3

Animal Farm and Powerplay Essay

“Animal Farmâ€? (1945) “Powerplay” necessitates the multifaceted manipulation of power in public and private relationships to achieve pre-eminence. The interplay of power exists to stipulate the associated characters to stupendously struggle for dominance, popularity and influence at political, sexual, military and psychological levels. This intricate notion of powerplay and the corruption arising from power is profoundly manifested in relationships at all levels within Shakespeare's Antony and…

Words 1383 - Pages 6