Essay on Profilers: Police and Fbi Special Agent

Submitted By Brittany58
Words: 941
Pages: 4
Open Document
Misconceptions About Criminal Profiling One of the most predominant genres in television today is the crime drama. Unfortunately, these crime dramas are written by screenwriters and not anyone actually in law enforcement. Hollywood’s exaggeration and dramatization of law enforcement and the criminal justice system has led to a phenomenon called the CSI effect. The CSI effect is when viewers mistake what happens on crime dramas, like CSI, for how solving crimes actually works (“Profiling”). For example, while a case can be solved on CSI in the space of a day, it takes much longer in real life, with cases taking weeks, years, or even decades to solve. This discrepancy is due in no little part to the idea that forensic tests take a short amount of time when they can occupy hours or even overnight. The CSI effect has skewed not only the public’s view on forensic science but also criminal justice careers themselves. We see FBI profilers on television solving crimes through psychology when the truth of the matter is “profiler” isn’t even a real job at the FBI. “Profilers” are actually supervisory special agents with the FBI’s National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crimes (NCAVC) in Quantico, Virginia. A basic requirement to be considered for the program is that an individual have served as an FBI special agent for three years. However, due to the high amount competition for placement in the program, individuals selected usually have eight to ten years of experience with the Bureau (“Frequently Asked Questions”). Newly assigned agents typically undergo a “structured training program of more than 500 hours” (“Profiling”). This is all so they can learn how to “profile” offenders.
This act of “profiling” has as many misrepresentations as profilers themselves. Main objectives of offender profiles tend to be one or more of the following:
1) The development of a description of an unknown offender, based on an interpretation of crime scene elements of the unsolved offence. This is perhaps the most common purpose of profiling.
2) Establishing the probability of a future offence from the same offender based on the crime scene analysis.
3) The linking of a series of unsolved crimes that appears to share distinct features, often through linking ‘signature aspects.’ These are essentially personalized offender-specific behaviors that reflect individual interpersonal behaviors and/or fantasies.
4) The development of an interrogation strategy to assist police in “asking the right questions”. Again, this is based on a psychological portrait inferred from an analysis of the crime scene and/or statistical data from offenders thought similar to the unknown subject (Horgan 4). Profilers are usually brought onto a case after all other leads are exhausted by local police. Profiles themselves rarely lead the police to immediate identification of an offender although this remains one of the core myths of profiling (Horgan 13). The very nature of a profile is not to find an offender but rather narrow the pool of suspects, allowing police officers to focus their efforts on individuals most likely to have committed the crime.
Even so, criminal profiling is a polarizing concept. While some people argue the concept’s validity, others are quick to point out its failings. One thing to keep in mind is the immense task faced by the very prospect of profiling. The profiler is essentially “constructing a set of subjective judgments and offering hypotheses about a person whom the profiler has never met” (Horgan 11). This leads to some profiles being so vague as to be practically useless to the police, and seem even to suffer the P.T. Barnum effect. The P.T. Barnum effect is when personality descriptions are vague and universal enough that nearly everyone
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Profilers: Police and Fbi Special Agent

Capturing Serial Killers

by the police. From the study emerged twelve different ways that these killers were caught. For example, the large majority of the serial killers that were studied were turned in by somebody who knew the offender, others were arrested for other offences and some were linked to the victim by other eyewitnesses. The conclusion that was reached was that serial killers are rarely captured based on forensic evidence and profiling alone. Instead serial killers were usually apprehended by police because…

Words 623 - Pages 3

Dr. Hannibal Lecter Essay

Fairy" stalks and murders seemingly random families during sequential full moons. He first kills the Jacobi family in Birmingham, Alabama, then the Leeds family in Atlanta, Georgia. Two days after the Leeds murders, FBI agent Jack Crawford seeks out his protégé, Will Graham, a brilliant profiler who captured the serial killer Hannibal Lecter three years earlier, but retired after Lecter almost killed him. Crawford goes to Graham's Sugarloaf Key residence and pleads for his assistance; Graham reluctantly…

Words 4067 - Pages 17

Behavioral Analysis Model

just happens to be the 3rd best criminology school in the country. I have had my heart set on joining the FBI, the Behavioral Analysis Unit in particular, and working on improving my chances of becoming a Supervisory Special Agent some day was basically what I do in my free time. I know what you’re thinking, how, when you weren’t even in college, improve your chances of becoming a profiler? Well, I was, well am super into crime TV, especially Criminal Minds; that is one of the reasons I decided…

Words 2751 - Pages 12

Essay on Murder and Regards Serial Killers

killing of another human being especially with premeditated malice. However the definition of murder may differ between countries. However serial murder is slightly more difficult to define and if ; and is often the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) define serial murder as the murder of three or more victims in separate events with an emotional cooling off period between homicides. The term serial killer and mass murderer are often used synonymously, however it is important to note that criminologists…

Words 2653 - Pages 11