Pros And Cons Of The Constitutional Convention

Words: 457

Pages: 2

Open Document

The Constitutional Convention is a series of meetings that occurred in the summer of 1787. The Constitutional Convention considered several methods of electing the President of a nation that was composed of thirteen large and small States. The first plan was to have the Congress choose the president, but this plan was rejected because some felt that this choice would be too disruptive. Others felt that this choice would bring undignified political bargaining, corruption and would bother the balance of power of the federal government. The second plan was to have the State Legislatures select the president, but this idea was rejected out of the fears that a president, indebted to the State Legislatures might tolerate them to destroy federal authority and thus undermine the whole idea of federation. The third plan was to have the president elected by a direct popular vote, but this plan was …show more content…
The initial plan was for the most knowledgeable and enlightened individuals from each state to select the president based entirely on advantage and without regard to State of origin or political party. Under the centurial Assembly System of the Roman Republic, the adult male citizens of Rome were divided, according to their wealth, into groups of 100 called Centuries. Each group of 100 had to choose only one vote either in favor or against proposals submitted to them by the Roman Senate. In the Electoral College System, the states act as the group of 100 or as Centuries, but they are not based on their wealth, and the number of votes per state is determined by the size of each State’s Congressional delegation. The Constitution gave each state several elections equal to the combined total of its membership in the Senate, two of each state, and its delegation in the House of Representatives ranging from one to 52

Electoral College Pros And Cons

When the delegates of the constitutional convention were trying to decide on how to have the president elected, there were many thoughts brought to the table. Some delegates wanted the president to be elected directly by the citizens, while other wanted congress to choose the president. After deciphering what was best, they combined their ideas into the electoral college. There are many pros and cons about the electoral college and what they do. One con of the electoral college, is that most people…

Words 680 - Pages 3

United States Constitution and Rep Votes Way Essay

and farmer Leader of rebellion Constitution Relevancy Made leaders realize that the Art of Confed. were not strong because of the lack of a strong nat’l gov’t 5) Give three pros and three cons of Federalism. Pros Promotes diversity Protects individual rights from nat’l gov’t Allows for experimentation Cons Difficult to enforce nat’l policy May promote inequality Spillover effects and competition 6) Discuss the difference between a mandate delegate representative and an independent…

Words 553 - Pages 3

Birthright Citizenship Debate

other hand, Roman stated, “Trump’s proposal would require a constitutional amendment, which would require a two-thirds majority vote in both the House and the Senate, followed by ratification of three-fourths of the states, or by a constitutional convention called for by two-thirds of the State legislatures.” To begin with, a president cannot abolish a law by itself, it has to have a process of evaluation keeping in mind the pros and cons, and other government organizations has to participate as well…

Words 662 - Pages 3

Pros And Cons Of The Electoral College

The Electoral College is an institution as old as our country and has been around since it was created during the Constitutional Convention of 1787. The Convention debated many methods of electing the president of the United States. Some called for more direct voting, such as in a direct democracy, while others wanted the vote to belong to members of congress themselves. This method was not selected because it would hamper the checks and balances they were building into the constitution, giving more…

Words 598 - Pages 3

The Biography Of Presidential Power

Erik Root February 21, 2014 During the Constitutional Convention, the founders spent their time framing and building the foundation of the government for the new nation. James Madison, Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton, and the other fathers spent a large amount of their time discussing and mapping out the office of the Executive. According to Charles Thach’s The Creation of the Presidency, 1775-1789: A Study in Constitutional History, the authors of the Constitution were puzzled…

Words 1802 - Pages 8

Codified Constituion Essay

codified constitution with the exception of the UK, New Zealand, Israel and Saudi Arabia. This brings in to question how relevant and up to date the UK's political system is compared to the rest of the world. This essay plans to illustrate the pros and cons of a codified constitution and answers the original question; should Britain adopt a codified constitution? The main argument against a written constitution is that Britain has survived very well without one and that the strength of an unwritten…

Words 1088 - Pages 5

Essay on Terror: Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Amendment

view spoke about the significance for obtaining a search warrant in all investigating procedures. The warrant assures that investigating officers wont consider the land beyond US borders as the lawless Wild West. “As a matter of United States constitutional law, a warrant serves the same primary function overseas as it does domestically: it assures that a neutral magistrate has authorized the search and limited its scope. The need to protect those suspected of criminal activity from the unbridled…

Words 2981 - Pages 12

Essay about History: State Thomas Jefferson

pre-Revolutionary era, suppressed by 12,000 militia-men without much of a fight, controversy over using force (Feds. vs. D-Rs) -How should US act in war between France & Britain in 1793? US too weak militarily to get involved, Feds were pro-British, D-Rs were pro-French, 90% of US imports came from Britain, Washington said US was neutral, but British seized US ships in Caribbean trading with French, Washington sent John Jay to negotiate with the British and Thomas Pinckney to negotiate with the Spanish…

Words 1569 - Pages 7

Ap Gov Review

and James Madison and John Jayy; argued philosophical foundations of U.S. gov. ; argued separation of powers and federalism check the growth of tyranny and also guard against dangers of direct democracy (controlled by majority only) Constitutional Convention- 1787 meeting of all state reps in Philly. Originally going to amend Articles but instead got rid of them Great Compromise- called for one house in which each state would have an equal vote (the Senate) and a second house (the House of Representatives)…

Words 3457 - Pages 14

The Electoral College System

The Electoral College is the system with which we elect the president and vice president of the United States. The Electoral College was created and established at the Constitutional Convention of 1787. One of the issues that the delegates needed to determine at the convention was how they were going to elect a president and vice president. There was much argument over whether or not the president should be elected by a popular vote or by Congressional appointments as there were concerns with both…

Words 1789 - Pages 8