Racial Disparity Argument

Words: 779

Pages: 4

Open Document

1.
The central arguments over the topic, “Justice can be accomplished by the State executing criminals” were the application of justice, equality, and racial disparity in the context of State execution of criminals. The idea of justice was defined in the very first proposition speech and then they applied it to the idea of justice for crime not victim. The opposition agreed with the proposition’s definition from the Oxford dictionary, but added the words fair and equality. This was very pivotal in the opposition’s argument because they continued this argument of equality and its relation to justice throughout the entire debate. They related it to disparity of punishments throughout the different states and the racial disparities. The proposition tried to combat the racial disparity argument by stating along the lines that the legal system may be racist, but capitol punishment isn’t. But in the end, the argument of stating inequalities within the system itself really was to the opposition’s advantage, they were able to connect to this overarching ideology that capital punishment is not fair or equal so therefore it is not justice. The proposition’s argument focused on that capital punishment deters crime. This was a point that the …show more content…
The proposition argued that justice for the crime not the victim and that equality in justice cannot be reciprocated. While the opposition pushed back that the system that capitol punishment is delivered in is inherently racist so why wouldn’t this punishment be. One of the arguments that I was surprised that wasn’t a main point was the “can be” in the topic. I feel as if the proposition only had to prove one example where capitol punishment was justice. I think the this could’ve ended up being a main persuasive factor in their argument, but overall I thought that both sides where able to hold up their arguments and deliver them

Literatuire review Essay

decisions which they base off of their prejudices every day. The following studies and analyses provide insight on minorities’ differential treatment in the judicial system causing severe sentencing disparities. Racial Disparity in Sentencing In the study Patterns of Death: An Analysis of Racial Disparities in Capital Sentencing and Homicide victimization, the authors Samuel Gross and Robert Mauro examine the effect race plays in Capital Sentencing. This study observes 8 states sentencing of capital…

Words 4273 - Pages 18

Disparity In Health Care

nation today is improving its healthcare. Trillions of dollars being poured into the healthcare system has still not been able to fix the health disparities we see in America today. Racial and ethnic health disparities have been a part of American society since its creation. Increased research on the inequalities that occur in healthcare across different racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic groups has started to raise awareness of a much dangerous part of institutional racism we face in society. This is…

Words 1035 - Pages 5

Being Black Living In The Red Analysis

factors such as income, education, and occupation, and we must also consider accumulated wealth. However, the overall argument of the book is that when studying the racial disparities in America researchers have overlooked a vital missing variable: accumulated family wealth. The book is broken up into separate, statistical analysis by chapter that each support the overall argument presented in the first…

Words 109 - Pages 1

Outcry Against Racial Profiling

they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.” Whether racial disparities and systematic discrimination exists in the judicial system has long been the subject of discussion and debate. Begging the question is if the very law enforcement in charge of “Protecting and Serving”, are the very ones’ abusing and enslaving. Important to consider the various arguments of the prejudicial treatment of the supposed law enforcement, this essay exams multiple sources and…

Words 272 - Pages 2

Systematic Racism In The Criminal Justice System

Systemic racism requires a thorough and strategic attack to demolish its deeply ingrained mechanisms, since it is a persistent and entrenched problem that still plagues American society. The complex network of racial disparities ingrained in the country has generated heated discussions, making the issue of whether or not schools should be in charge of teaching pupils about systemic racism a central theme in the country's discourse. Because systemic racism is complex, it requires a thorough investigation…

Words 1207 - Pages 5

Mccleskey V. Kemp Case Summary

discrimination, McCleskey must first demonstrate that he belonged to a group “that is a recognizable, distinct class, singled out for different treatment” (McCleskey v. Kemp 318). Here, McCleskey relied on the Baldus study, a statistical study that shows a “disparity in the imposition of the death sentence…based on the race of the murder victim and…the race of the defendant” (McCleskey v. Kemp 300). The study showed that black defendants have the greatest likelihood of receiving the death penalty; therefore,…

Words 1496 - Pages 6

Plessy V. Ferguson Case Analysis

Plessy v Ferguson case was morally based on racial bias and discrimination due to the demonstration of unjust racial disparity in the criminal justice system. The ruling of the Plessy v Ferguson case led to civil war and gave legal standing to the idea of separate but equal. In the first opposition, the justices rejected Plessy’s argument that the Louisiana law conflicted with the Thirteenth Amendment because it was believed to be “ too clear for argument” (78 Plessy v. Ferguson) . According to page…

Words 814 - Pages 4

The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration

incarceration in the United States is an attempt to maintain blacks as an underclass. Michelle Alexander asserts that “[w]e have not ended racial caste in America; we have merely redesigned it.” (Alexander 2). The result is Black and Latino men who face hurdles and denial of civil liberties…

Words 1635 - Pages 7

Student: Prison and Glenn C. Loury Essay

disadvantaged corners of our unequal society, cannot be ignored. In 2006, one in nine Black men between the ages of 20 and 34 was serving time. The role of race ;4n this drama is subtle and ¿important, and the racial ^breakdown is not incidenftal: prisons both reflect and »exacerbate existing racial and class inequalities. Why are there so many mandatory minimum-type behavior. Rather, the larger statutes such as California's • society is implicated in a Three Strikes Law, are dif- criminal's choices…

Words 1791 - Pages 8

Essay about George Zimmerman

case broke out was if this case had anything to do with racial profiling. This issue is a key factor in influencing how the society viewed and judged this case. There were many arguments about whether or not Trayvon Martin was racially profiled by George Zimmerman. Mark Nejame, a legal analyst and contributor of CNN opinion, argued that this case was not a case of racial profiling. He said that “There's a difference of opinion about whether racial profiling was actually involved, but a key question…

Words 2083 - Pages 9