regulatory finance Essay

Submitted By YANI1000
Words: 6911
Pages: 28
Open Document
An Academic Response to Basel II
By

Jón Daníelsson, Paul Embrechts,
Charles Goodhart, Con Keating, Felix Muennich,
Olivier Renault and Hyun Song Shin

SPECIAL PAPER NO 130

LSE Financial Markets Group an ESRC Research Centre

Special Paper Series
May 2001
ISSN 1359-9151-130

Submitted* in Response to the Basel Committee for Banking
Supervision’s Request for Comments

by

Dr. Jón Daníelsson (LSE/FMG)+
Prof. Paul Embrechts (ETHZ)
Prof. Charles Goodhart (LSE/FMG)
Con Keating (Finance Development Centre)
Felix Muennich (LSE/FMG)
Dr. Olivier Renault (LSE/FMG)
Prof. Hyun Song Shin (LSE/FMG/CEP)

May 31, 2001

*

The views expressed in this response do not necessarily reflect those of any of the wider groups with which the authors are associated and are in each case personal views. This document is not to be circulated or quoted without permission.
+
Corresponding Author: Jón Daníelsson, London School of Economics, London WC2A 2AE, UK; Tel.
+44-207-955-6056; e-mail: j.danielsson@lse.ac.uk; www.riskresearch.org

An Academic Response to Basel II

Executive Summary
It is our view that the Basel Committee for Banking Supervision, in its Basel II proposals, has failed to address many of the key deficiencies of the global financial regulatory system and even created the potential for new sources of instability. In this document we present the following arguments:
• The proposed regulations fail to consider the fact that risk is endogenous.
Value-at-Risk can destabilise an economy and induce crashes when they would not otherwise occur.
• Statistical models used for forecasting risk have been proven to give inconsistent and biased forecasts, notably under-estimating the joint downside risk of different assets. The Basel Committee has chosen poor quality measures of risk when better risk measures are available.
• Heavy reliance on credit rating agencies for the standard approach to credit risk is misguided as they have been shown to provide conflicting and inconsistent forecasts of individual clients' creditworthiness. They are unregulated and the quality of their risk estimates is largely unobservable.
• Operational risk modelling is not possible given current databases and technology even if a meaningful definition of this risk were to be provided by
Basel. No convincing argument for the need of regulation in this area has yet been made.
• Financial regulation is inherently procyclical. Our view is that this set of proposals will, overall, exacerbate this tendency significantly. In so far as the purpose of financial regulation is to reduce the likelihood of systemic crisis, these proposals will actually tend to negate, not promote this useful purpose.

The document highlights our concerns that the failure of the proposals to address the above issues can have destabilising effects and thus harm the global financial system. In particular, there is considerable scope for under-estimation of financial risk, which may lead to complacency on the part of policy makers and insufficient understanding of the likelihood of a systemic crisis. Furthermore, it is unfortunate that the Basel Committee has not considered how financial institutions will react to the new regulations. Of special concern is how the proposed regulations would induce the harmonisation of investment decisions during crises with the consequence of destabilising rather than stabilising the global financial system.
-3-

An Academic Response to Basel II

1. Introduction
We welcome the opportunity to respond to the Basel Committee for Banking
Supervision’s new proposals for changes to the Capital Adequacy Accord of 1988. This response arose out of a conference on the new proposals, organised on Wednesday, May
16th, 2001, by the Financial Markets Group and the Centre for Economic Performance, both of the London School of Economics. Most of the views articulated in this response reflect comments
Show More

Related Documents: regulatory finance Essay

Canada Financial Regulation Essay

Canadian Regulatory Landscape Individual Term Paper Abstract In McKay report to Expert Panel on Securities Regulation, it has been 10 years since the discussion about improvement on Canadian Regulatory Framework that indicate changes have to be done. Major and minor obstacles have been debated since which calls for action of changes. In this research I will try to explain how and why changes are needed for securities regulation in Canada in order to bring our capital market compete-able…

Words 1198 - Pages 5

Importance Of Micro Finance

and 60 percent depend on agriculture (according to the World Bank reports), micro-finance can play a vital role in providing financial services to the poor and low income individuals. Microfinance is the form of a broad range of financial services such as deposits, loans, payment services, money transfers, insurance, savings, micro-credit etc. to the poor and low income individuals. The importance of micro-finance in the developing economies like India cannot be undermined, where a large size of…

Words 1570 - Pages 7

Saliu Research Essays

THE BOARD OF POSTGRADUATE STUDIES CERTIFY That this dissertation, “An Assessment of the Effectiveness of the Legal and Financial Regulatory Framework on Public Expenditure Management and Control in Sierra Leone” is the original work of the candidate, and that it is accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree of MASTER OF FINANCE AND ACCOUNTING ……………………………. ………………………………… ……………………. Supervisor Signature…

Words 1598 - Pages 7

Accounting: Management Accountants Essay

relationships and responsibilities to the corporation's finance organization. The activities management accountants provide inclusive of forecasting and planning, performing variance analysis, reviewing and monitoring costs inherent in the business are ones that have dual accountability to both finance and the business team. Examples of tasks where accountability may be more meaningful to the business management team vs. the corporate finance department are the development of new product costing…

Words 395 - Pages 2

Professional Reflection For Portfolio

Professional Reflection for Portfolio 1 There were 12 objectives this semester for the Healthcare Policy, Finance and Regulatory environment class. We covered all these objectives in several ways, either through board discussions, course readings and specific course assignments. I will go through each objective and describe how we reach our objective. Objective #1: Demonstrate basic knowledge of healthcare policy, finance, and regulatory environments, including local, state, national, and global healthcare trends…

Words 855 - Pages 4

Government's Role in an Interconnected Global Financial Market Essay

Recent events have merely confirmed what economists have known for some time, namely, that the interconnectedness of global economic activity renders macro-management by single governments redundant. Their function is now to regulate markets to ensure economically efficient solutions. This essay will argue that the 2008 financial crisis has brought to the forefront of global political consideration what some economists have known for some time. This is that 1) The global financial system is…

Words 3011 - Pages 13

Essay about An overview of online banking in Russia

2013). This can be achieved by increasing the financial awareness of the society, and reducing technology and regulatory constraints. This paper attempts to identify the correlations between these three factors by generating a survey of the customers’ preferences and perceptions towards online banking. As a global system, the Internet has a tremendous influence on economy, business and finance. The changes in these industries include, among others, the development of Internet banking. As a rule, western…

Words 839 - Pages 4

Business: Financial Adviser Essay

financial adviser you must take an industry-recognised qualification that meets regulatory standards set by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). If you want to be a financial adviser working in the retail investment market you will need to have a Level 4 approved qualification as a minimum. Recognised qualifications include: * Chartered Insurance Institute (CII) Diploma in Regulated Financial Planning * ifs School of Finance Diploma for Financial Advisers (DipFA) * Chartered Institute…

Words 295 - Pages 2

Essay on SWOT Analysis: Splunk

of the marginal barrel of oil is up and going higher. IOCs are switching from oil to natural gas, despite rising oil prices and declining natural gas prices. Even with the most optimistic of scenarios, stock is richly valued. POSITIVES Regulatory – 1) revenue based resource…

Words 547 - Pages 3

FIN 419 Week 5 Learning Team Assignment International Finance Paper

This archive file contains FIN 419 Week 5 Learning Team Assignment International Finance Paper Locate an organization that has an international presence. · Write a 1,400- to 1,750-word paper on your organization in which you address the following: · How the global investment banking process has assisted the organization · How regulatory bodies affect financial decision-making · Identify and evaluate contemporary issues in international financial management…

Words 406 - Pages 2