Rule Utilitarianism Case Study

Words: 1268
Pages: 6
Open Document
Kelly is a pharmacy intern at CVS pharmacy. She is very thankful to her supervising pharmacist, Mary, who is a very close family friend that made sure that she would get the job. Recently, Kelly has noticed that Mary has been acting strangely at work lately, but brushes it off because she knows that she was having problems at home and doesn’t want to be too nosy. One day, Kelly walks to the back room to get her lunch out of her purse for the day. Mary’s bag is right next to hers and she sees part of a beer can in the bag. She thinks this explains Mary’s recent change in behavior. She goes to speak to Mary privately, and tells her what she saw in her purse. Mary says to Kelly, “We decided to go through with the divorce. I’ve been so sad that …show more content…
A Rule Utilitarian will describe the dilemma in terms of rules. The two conflicting rules are 1) the rule of loyalty to those you work with and 2) the rule of professional obligation in terms of reporting a pharmacist’s impairment in the workplace. The Rule Utilitarian will resolve this issue by subordinating one rule to the other such that if pharmacy interns were to follow it in every situation, it produces the greatest amount of happiness. Assume that rule 1) is subordinated to rule 2), meaning that every pharmacy intern is to follow rule 2) and only follow rule 1) if it is not in conflict with rule 2). If pharmacy interns were to follow such a rule, costly mistakes could be avoided, but the trust between pharmacy interns and pharmacists would be severed. Now assume that rule 2) is subordinated to rule 1), meaning that every pharmacy intern is to follow rule 1) and only follow rule 2) if it is not in conflict with rule 1). If this occurred, pharmacy interns would maintain their loyalty to pharmacists, but the consequence would be that impaired pharmacists wouldn’t be reported, leading to a greater number of accidents in the workplace, diminished patient outcomes, and possibly harm to patients. As a result, the right thing for Kelly and for every pharmacy intern to do is to follow the rule of professional obligation in terms of reporting a pharmacist’s impairment in the workplace. A Rule Utilitarian’s view is …show more content…
Rule Utilitarians defend rules at a general level. Therefore, it does not matter what amount of happiness will result in future dilemmas of following either the rule of loyalty to those you work with or the rule of professional obligation in terms of reporting a pharmacist’s impairment in the workplace. What matters is that in general, past experiences can be used to see that reporting pharmacists who had impairments indeed made the patients better off. This is due to the fact that common sense and evidence can be used to know that pharmacists are not able to work as well while impaired than while sober. Following the rule of professional obligation leads to the greatest amount of happiness even if in some cases following that rule caused a lesser amount of happiness. In the case, the rule that Kelly should follow is the rule that in general produces the greatest amount of happiness for all involved. By Kelly following the rule of professional obligation, she will contribute to producing the greatest amount of happiness in the long term since patients will not be put at unnecessary risk due to an impaired
Show More

Related Documents: Rule Utilitarianism Case Study

A Dilemma and My Solution Based On Utilitarianism Ethical Model Essay

A Dilemma and My Solution Based On Utilitarianism Ethical Model (Assignment # 1) Prepared by : Efren A. Course-Section : GNED212-091 Instructor : Mr. Paul B. Class : Friday Afternoons Part 1: Utilitarianism Ethical Model Many people from all walks of life have trouble making decisions in their everyday lives, especially on tough or critical situations that may even involve life and death considerations. To address this issue, there are four ethical models and four ethical…

Words 1368 - Pages 6

The Schiavos, Rule Utilitarianism, and Kantian Ethics Essay

Rui Chaves The Schiavos, Rule Utilitarianism, and Kantian Ethics The case of “The Schiavos” is focused primarily on one member of the family, which is Terri Schiavo. Terri had been in a coma for 13 years. Although, “no one is completely sure what happened but the best guess is she suffered a heart attack” (Pierce, 64) presumably caused by her bulimia. Due to the severity of her heart attack, it left Terri with severe brain damaged which in turn left her in a persistent vegetative state which leaves…

Words 1277 - Pages 6

Outline Utilitairanism Essay example

ethical theory of Utilitarianism In this essay I will be outlining and discussing the ethical theory of Utilitarianism and use examples in order to back my points. I will be discussing the main concepts within Utilitarianism and explaining them fully. Ethics is a branch of philosophy concerned with the study of what is good and bad. Utilitarianism is an ethical study which deals with the usefulness of an action and deals with the outcome of an action. Utilitarianism is suggests…

Words 1924 - Pages 8

Essay on Ethical Dilemma

The case study presents a moral dilemma based on potential harm to innocent people. By using Kohlberg’s moral development model and by examining major ethical systems, namely deontology and utilitarianism, a clear understanding of the factors influencing this type of decision-making can be gained. Specifically, utilitarianism, Kant’s categorical imperative and the doctrine of double effect address the decision from differing viewpoints, providing the decision maker with compelling evidence to support…

Words 3387 - Pages 14

Normative Ethics

ethics is the study of principles, rules, or theories that guide our actions and judgments. The purpose of normative ethics is to establish the soundness of moral norms, or theory. We do normative ethics when doing critical reasoning to demonstrate that a moral principle is justified or if it is contradictory. Applied ethics is the application of moral norms to specific moral issues or cases, usually those in a profession such as medicine or law. By using applied ethics we study the results derived…

Words 2124 - Pages 9

Essay on katie s midterm for philosophy

Katie’s STUDY GUIDE for Midterm Opens Thursday @ Noon- Closes 8 PM Friday People Plato- Ring of Gyges, Psychological egoism Jeremy Bentham- Utilitarianism/ Greatest Happiness/Hedonistic Calculus John Stuart Mill- Utilitarianism/ Greatest Happiness Aristotle- Intellectual Virtue, Principle of the Mean, Moral Virtue, Teleology Immanuel Kant- Categorical Imparative/ Goodwill Epicurus- Ataraxia, Happiness, Epistemology John Rawls -The Two Principles of Justice Concepts Moral Philosophy (Also known…

Words 2696 - Pages 11

Notes On Business Ethics

1/9/2013 Business Ethics Unit 1 I. Ethics is the study of the right (good) using reason, analysis, synthesis, and reflection A) Ethics ≠ morality (just requires that you know someone else’s opinion) Can explain using reason B) Universal Rule guiding behavior Applied to every decision II. Steps in process A. Identify proposed action (what is right/wrong?) B. Identify important dimension of the decision (varies by rules) C. Decide if the action is ethical 1. Ethical tests…

Words 4576 - Pages 19

Essay about Biology: Stem Cell and Advanced Medical Procedures

part of the patients brain off to look at the problem that lies within. By collecting and cloning a skin sample they have the ability to study the neurons; neurons are the part of the cell that electrically transmit signals to the brain and central nervous system. In the past it was very difficult to study the living human body. Scientist generally had to study dead bodies, and even then it was hard because the cells had already died off. Scientist believe that if they are able to advance there…

Words 1064 - Pages 5

Case Against Gun Control

AFFIRMATIVE CASE Yes, people pull the trigger - but guns are the instrument of death. Gun control is necessary, and delay means more death and horror. It is because I agree with Eliot Spitzer that I affirm today’s resolution Resolved: Government limits on the individual's right to bear arms in the United States is justified. For clarification of today's round I offer the following definitions: Government-Exercise of authority in a political unit Limits-A confining or a restricting object,…

Words 1000 - Pages 4

Ethics Midterm Notes

the principles of conduct governing an individual or a group; a guiding philosophy; a consciousness of moral importance A set of moral issues or aspects Reasons to study ethics Simple beliefs may be inadequate for complex issue The study can help a person sort out these complex issue, by seeing what principles operate in those cases Conflicting ethical principles Ethics can provide insights into how to adjudicate between conflicting principles and show why certain courses of action are more desirable…

Words 3955 - Pages 16