Should Immigrants Be Allowed To Illegal Immigrants

Submitted By Jclanda1
Words: 2364
Pages: 10
Open Document
Juan Landa
Syd
English 4
Amnesty in the 21st Century In 1986 amnesty allowed 3 million illegal aliens to become legalized, and without proper enforcement has helped to lead to the now 11 million illegal aliens now living in the United States. These immigrants have not done any harm to Americans, and thus should not be treated as though they have done so. Joseph H. Carens, author of “The Case for Amnesty: Time Erodes the State’s Right to Deport”, states that it is only right for illegal aliens who have been here a period of time to receive amnesty; Carens point also relates to the fact that it would be almost impossible to deport every illegal immigrant. Amnesty should therefore be allowed to illegal aliens, but with restrictions. The legalization of immigrants should be allowed to those immigrants and their children who have been in the U.S. for a number of years via the Dream Act and new policies; amnesty should also pertain to non-criminals, along with future proposals and tougher enforcement to ensure that more illegal immigrants will not be coming in without legal permission. The only way to deal with the problem of illegal immigration is to enforce amnesty with restrictions and enforcement, so that the problem does not occur once again in the future. All immigrants come to America for one underlying reason: to live a better life for themselves and/ or their families; amnesty would help immigrants to live the “American dream”. David DeCosse, director of the campus ethics programs at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University in California, believes that immigrants share motives that all humanity holds. DeCosse is stating that not only is migrating to a new country for a better life natural, but also pertains to motives of all living humans. If the United States were to become poor and economically disabled, American’s would also migrate to other countries just as immigrants are migrating to the U.S. Joseph Carens also agrees with DeCosse in this subject matter by stating that, “living with one’s family is a fundamental human interest.” (3) It is morally unsound to take a person away from their family, and is the reason why immigrants should not be deported if they have lived in the U.S. for a certain amount of years.
Undocumented children, whom are growing in numbers, must not be left out when talking about future legalization policies. The Dream Act, introduced by Senator Dick Durbin in the Senate and Representative Howard Berman in the House, is a form of amnesty that applies to undocumented immigrants; The Dream Act has been established for illegal immigrants who are willing to contribute to society through the armed forces or college, and creates a path to citizenship and allows states to determine eligibility requirements for instate tuition. Through the Dream Act, an undocumented immigrant must be of sixteen years or older, and have been resided in the United States for 5 years or more (Palacios). Just as stated in Carens argument, The Dream Act emphasizes time tremendously and it has been effective in doing so. According to Robert Gonzales, an Assistant Professor at the University of Washington School of Social Work and author of “On the Rights of Undocumented Children”, states that undocumented children face a number of social, economic and legal barriers in which a great number of them live in poverty with a number of stressors. The Dream Act has been established to help illegal children receive the help they need, but amnesty should also be applied to the parents of illegal children who are stressing far worse than the children are. In the Bipartisan Framework, it is said that the United Sates needs to do a better job at attracting and keeping the world’s best and brightest—The Dream Act helps this concept thrive. If the Dream Act is a functioning form of amnesty, it is possible that a functioning form of legalization for all illegal immigrants could be established. The only way to
Show More

Related Documents: Should Immigrants Be Allowed To Illegal Immigrants

Persuasive Essay On Immigration

According to Timothy Murphy, “Illegal immigration is crisis for our country. It is an open door for drugs, criminals, and potential terrorists to enter our country. It is straining our economy, adding costs to our judicial, healthcare, and education systems.” There is a major controversy over whether or not we should let these immigrants into our country, give them benefits, give them protection and sanctuary, and give them equal opportunities and rights as citizens of the nation. Various groups…

Words 1446 - Pages 6

Immigration Policies In The United States

Thousands of people are affected every day by the immigration policies put in place. In the United States, the concept of asylum seekers and refugees is different but also very similar when working with immigration policy. Refugees are people who are in their own country; according to Amnesty International they are people who feel their human rights are at risk, but their country and government will not protect them from that. On the other hand, asylum seekers are people who have fled their homes…

Words 1272 - Pages 6

Essay on Obama on Immigration

Mary Hyland 10/9/14 Title­ Obama Defends His Use of Executive Authority on Immigration Source­ New York Times Date­ November 23, 2014 Writer­ Brian Knowlton Website­ http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/24/us/politics/obama­immigration.html?hp&action=c lick&pgtype=Homepage&module=first­column­region®ion=top­news&WT.nav=top­news&_ r=0 ★ President Obama rejected republican criticism in an interview on Sunday that said he was using too much executive power in his actions to protect millions of…

Words 701 - Pages 3

Us Immigration Policy Essay

United States Immigration Policy Our economic times, international relations, and terrorism have shaped our countries immigration policy. These issues have driven us to pass legislation opening and closing our borders in response to current events. Though not always at the forefront of concern, it has been a constant struggle that has affected the dynamics of our country. Arizona’s recent passing of tough immigration laws aimed at identifying and deporting illegal immigrants has again put immigration…

Words 3703 - Pages 15

CCJ 1020 1 TERM PAPER

illegal aliens in the U.S. These individuals started their lives in the United States as criminals by not following the proper channels. They have entered or resided without the permission or knowledge of our Government and while doing so have violated the laws of the States, Nation and metropolises. The cost of arresting, prosecuting, sentencing, and supervising these illegal criminals has become a major issue at the State and local levels. ILLEGAL ALIENS AND CRIME Preventing the admission of…

Words 1370 - Pages 6

Argumentative Essay On Daca

Background The United States of America has been founded on immigrants that were looking for freedom, and opportunities to succeed. Every year the United States’ department of homeland security legally accepts around 1 million of people. However, it has been established that between illegal immigrants that just cross the borders the amount mounts to 4 million (Dye, 2016, 227). Due to the increase of undocumented immigrants who have been able to either stay illegally, cross the border without any…

Words 671 - Pages 3

Immigration: Liberalism Essay

and liberal party in regards to immigration are defined as liberals support towards illegal immigration and conservatives support for legal immigration. Liberals support amnesty for those who enter the U.S. illegally. Liberals believe undocumented immigrants have the right to all educational and health benefits that citizens receive, regardless of legal status. Governor Jerry Brown stated, “In order to avoid dire consequences for our state, comprehensive immigration reform must occur this year and…

Words 1204 - Pages 5

Us & France Pres. Elections Essay

there were presidential elections for each country. In the United States President, elect Barrack Obama and Governor of Massachusetts Mitt Romney ran against each other the presidency of the United States of America. Across the Atlantic, President elect Nicolas Sarkozy and Francois Holland faced off for the presidential title of their nation of France. The election in France took place on April 22, 2012 and the election in the United States took place November 6, 2012. Elections in France take place…

Words 3929 - Pages 16

Illegal Immigration in the United States Essay

Illegal Immigration in the United States Illegal Immigration in the United States The United States (US) has always been viewed as the land of opportunity because it is the only true free country in the world. This being the case people have been fighting their way into the country for decades. However, it is becoming more and more of a problem each decade that passes. With the United States border being so close to Mexico it is now seeing the highest population of illegal immigrants to…

Words 2065 - Pages 9

Government Essay Due

The second President of the United States John Adams once said, “Government is instituted for the common good; for the protection, safety, prosperity, and happiness of the people; not for the profit, honor, or private interest of anyone man, family, or class of men”. In the United States, Political parties exist such as the Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, Greens and etc., these political parties are more dominate in some states than others. Each political party has their own philosophy and…

Words 634 - Pages 3